The Proof of the Pudding

Chapter 64: The Fraud Evidence

The prosecutor's office occupied the second floor of a stone building off the quai, and by ten past eleven the conference room had run out of chairs. Gabriel stood against the window with his folder under his arm. Mathilde sat at the table's edge, spine straight, hands folded, the way she sat when she was keeping something in. Blanchard had come up from Lyon with them and had not stopped checking his phone since the bridge.

Maître Sorel arrived last with a wheeled case she did not bother to open.

The prosecutor, an unhurried woman named Vergne, laid three documents side by side on the table. "The audit is certified. I have read it twice. Before I open anything formal, I want to be certain the documentary spine holds."

"It holds," Gabriel said.

"Then show me."

He set his folder down and opened it. Four years of paper, in order, each delivery note clipped to its matching manifest. He found the first one with his thumb without looking. "Fifteenth of March, the year before last. Salt cod, forty kilos. Same cold-chain carrier Fauré Holdings used on Mathilde's flour run."

"Butter and cream," Mathilde said, sliding her own folder across. "Six deliveries. All six on the same numbered manifests. The carrier's stamp is identical on both sets."

Vergne put on glasses. She took Gabriel's stack first, then Mathilde's, and matched them by manifest number, one hand holding each page. For a while the only sound was paper.

"They don't even pretend," she said at last. "Same number series. Same driver signature, same date. One set was altered afterward and one wasn't." She looked up. "Because you kept yours."

"He does that," Mathilde said. Dry.

"I ran a bakery that lost a supplier for a week on a rumor," Gabriel said. "I started keeping everything that day."

Vergne sorted the pages into three piles and squared them with her palm. "Forgery of commercial documents. Fraudulent alteration of inspection records. Misuse of a certification body's mark. And the email thread is the part that concerns me most." She tapped a printed page. "The audit says B.C. directed it. You are both on record that B.C. is Bertrand Cazal?"

"He signs his initials on the group's internal correspondence like a schoolboy," Sorel said. "It is on file in the Annecy matter. The magistrate noted it."

"Then here is where we are." Vergne wrote a line on a legal pad, underlined it, and turned the pad so the room could read: OUVERTURE D'INFORMATION JUDICIAIRE. "As of this morning I am opening a formal investigation into Bertrand Cazal and Aurélie Fauré for forgery and fraudulent business practices. Not a preliminary inquiry. An investigation. It will be assigned to an investigating magistrate this afternoon."

Blanchard exhaled through his nose.

"That means what?" Gabriel asked.

"It means I can now compel the auction house to name its buyer," Vergne said. "It means I can seize records. It means the thirty-day audit is no longer the only instrument in play." She looked at Mathilde. "And it means, Madame Renaud, that if the building sells privately in the next forty-eight hours, the transaction will be examined as part of a fraud. Which will make it considerably harder to sell."

Mathilde did not smile. She let her hands unclasp, though, which from her was nearly the same thing.

"There is a condition," Vergne said. "I want both originals. Not copies. They become exhibits. You will not get them back before the end of the investigation."

Gabriel looked at the folder. Four years, he had carried that thing from kitchen to kitchen like a passport.

"Take them," he said. "I know what's in them."

Vergne initialed each page, and Blanchard signed as counsel, and it took nineteen minutes, and when it was done the folder left the table in the clerk's arms instead of Gabriel's.

Outside, the river was gray and the wind had picked up. Sorel walked them to the corner and stopped.

"The bank will have been notified," she said.

"Of what?" Gabriel said.

"The audit named the loan facilities used to fund the altered manifests. Your loan was part of that structure. The bank's compliance people will have flagged it the moment the certified audit went to the prosecutor. This is not a surprise. It is Tuesday following Monday."

Gabriel stood very still. "My eighteen thousand."

"Was contracted through the same commercial desk that handled the Fauré facilities. If it is tainted, the debt is frozen. If it is frozen, you cannot be collected on while the investigation runs." She glanced at her watch. "They will call you before five. Answer the phone. Do not sign anything that is not in front of me."

She walked off toward the car.

Mathilde fell into step beside Gabriel along the quai. He did not speak for half a block.

"You told me once it was your father's stove," she said.

"It was the oven. And the proofing cabinet. And three months of rent on the old place." He shrugged, but it sat wrong on him. "I borrowed to stay open after he died. Then the loan desk got folded into the Fauré group. I never read the fine print. I just paid."

"At what rate?"

"Nineteen percent."

She stopped walking. "Gabriel."

"I know."

"You paid nineteen percent for two years and you never once mentioned it."

"What was I going to say? The woman who runs a kitchen like a surgery, I'm going to tell her I'm being bled by a bank?" He started walking again. "You'd have fixed it. You'd have fixed it in an afternoon and then looked at me like I was a broken oven you had to keep an eye on."

"I would have fixed it," she agreed, "and I would not have looked at you like that."

The phone rang at four forty, and it was the bank, exactly as Sorel had promised. Gabriel put it on speaker in the bakery's back office, with Mathilde sitting across from him and the phone lying on the flour-streaked worktable between them.

The compliance officer's name was Delmas and he sounded like a man who had been reading documents he did not enjoy. "Monsieur Vasseur. Following the certified audit forwarded to the prosecutor's office this morning, the bank has identified your facility as part of the affected portfolio. Effectively immediately, all collections on your debt are suspended. No interest accrues. No payments are due."

"For how long?"

"Until the investigation resolves. Weeks, possibly months. Frankly, I have never had a file like this." A pause. "The eighteen thousand is frozen. You do not owe it today. You may not owe it at all, depending on what the magistrate finds."

Gabriel stared at the phone. "And if it resolves in the bank's favor?"

"Then we reconstruct a clean schedule at a lawful rate," Delmas said. "I will not insult you by pretending the rate you were given was defensible. It was not."

When the call ended, Gabriel sat back and looked at the ceiling for a long moment.

Mathilde was watching him.

"Say it," he said.

"I wasn't going to say anything."

"You are absolutely going to say something."

She considered. "Nineteen percent."

"Yes."

"A baker. Borrowing at nineteen percent."

"Yes."

"From a bank that was being bled by the people who tried to ruin me." She stood and brushed flour off her hands. "Gabriel, they didn't just take your money. They made sure you could never leave. Your debt was their collar."

He had not thought of it that way, and once she said it, he could not unthink it. Two years. Every payment he had scraped together, every night he had worked the counter himself instead of hiring, had gone to a company that had been altering manifests and forging stamps and treating him as a line item. He put both hands flat on the table.

"I want it to be them," he said. "Not the bank. Them. On the record. Every sou."

"Good," Mathilde said. "Then we are finally arguing about the same thing."

The office door opened and Sorel came in without knocking, phone in hand, face set. "The auction house named the buyer under compulsion. Seventeen minutes ago."

They both turned.

"Fauré Holdings, through a nominee in Luxembourg, contracted to sell the Fournil Saint-Antoine." She looked up. "The buyer is not an investor, Monsieur Vasseur. It is a demolition and redevelopment contractor. They filed a demolition permit application with the mairie the same day the building was withdrawn from auction. It has not been granted. It has not been refused either."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 64: The Fraud Evidence · The Proof of the Pudding · Lumen Reads