The Proof of the Pudding

Chapter 78: The Dish Goes Home

The butter dish sat on the passenger seat like a passenger itself, wrapped in the good cloth, the one Amélie used for proofing. Mathilde had spent three evenings on it. The shards from Bertrand's kitchen floor — she had swept them herself that night, before she understood anything — had gone to a restorer in Croix-Rousse, a woman who worked on church windows and understood that some cracks were structural and some were only evidence. The reassembled dish was wider than the original by a hair, the lead seams darker, a pale scar running the length of one lid like a river on a map.

It was not the same dish. She had decided on the drive up that this was the point.

The cemetery at Loyasse climbed the hill in terraces, cypress and gravel, the city laid out below like a proof she could check. Her father's stone was plain. Renaud, Henri, 1956–2019, and under it, in the small letters she'd had cut herself, boulanger.

She knelt and set the dish down on the gravel, and for a moment said nothing, because there was a version of this in which she explained the trial, the conviction, the sentence, the way Bertrand had looked at her across the courtroom as if she were the one who had lied. She had already told the stone most of that, in pieces, over months.

"Papa," she said. "I made the dish again."

The wind moved the cypress. Below, a bus coughed and pulled away from the terminus.

"I know it's not sensible. It's not for baking in. It's for looking at." She turned the lid so the seam caught the light. "The woman who did it said I could have had it recut, new glass, no seam. She asked why I didn't. I told her it was the seam I wanted."

She sat back on her heels. There was no one in the row but an old man at the far end with a watering can, and he was not listening.

"Do you remember the summer I was fourteen and I told you I wanted to do pastry instead of bread. You said the bread would wait for me. You said the bread is patient." She laughed, once, without much sound. "The bread was not patient. The bread almost killed me. But you were right about the rest of it."

She told him about Amélie, then. That she had put a name on the back of the auction notice by hand, thirty percent, and that it was done, and that no one was going to take it back. She told him about Yanis, who burned the first batch of pain de mie and now did the viennoiserie on Thursdays. She told him about the two brands on one door, Huret on one side and her own name on the other, and how for a year it had felt like a compromise and now it felt like a building.

And then she stopped, because there was one thing left, and it had been sitting in her chest like a warm stone since Sunday.

"There's a man," she said.

The old man at the end of the row filled his can from the tap and left, his shoes loud on the gravel, and then it was just the two of them.

"You know him, actually. You met him once, at the market, the year before — you said he looked like he argued for a living. You were right." She pressed the heel of her hand against the lid of the dish. "He said I was wrong in print. He was wrong about why. He said so out loud, in front of two hundred people, and they filmed it, and it's going to be in the paper, and I've been carrying it around like a burn because I don't know what to do with a man who corrects himself in public. People don't do that. You didn't do that. Bertrand certainly didn't do that."

She was quiet a moment.

"I kissed him in the middle of a food festival with a broken rest time and the wrong fold. It was a bad croissant. He made it badly on purpose and then he made it badly by accident and then we were laughing and then we weren't."

She stood. Her knees had gone stiff from the cold gravel.

"Anyway. I'm telling you because you'd want to know, and because I'm thirty-five and I still want you to know things first." She looked down at the dish at her feet. "I'm going to leave this here tonight."

She did not know, exactly, why. Some of it was that she wanted the dish to have been in two places: the kitchen it came from and the ground it came from. Some of it was that she wanted to be the kind of person who could put something down.

She turned the dish so the seam faced the stone, and she went down the hill through the gate, past the caretaker's booth, to the bus stop, and she did not look back.

She came back at seven, before service, because she didn't trust herself to come back at noon.

Frost had come in the night. The gravel was hard, and the cypress smelled sharper, colder, and her father's stone had a rime on it that caught the low sun and made the names look as if they had been freshly cut. She stood at the end of the row with her hands in her coat pockets and looked at the dish from a distance first, the way she would look at a proof.

It looked absurd. A butter dish on a grave, the lid opaque with frost, the lead seams black against the grey, too wide by a hair, the whole thing cocked slightly because the gravel wasn't level. A crow had walked across the lid and left tracks in the frost.

She had meant to leave it, and she had left it, and there it was, and she didn't want it there.

It was not a monument. It was a working thing. The seam was evidence, yes — but evidence of what? Not of Bertrand. Not of the trial. Of the fact that she had made something, and it had been broken, and she had had it put back together so she could keep using it. A thing that only sat on a grave was a thing that had stopped being used.

She picked it up. The cold went through the cloth, and she wiped the frost off with her sleeve, and the crow's tracks smeared.

"You'd have told me not to be sentimental," she said to the stone. "Fine."

She turned and walked back down the row, and at the gate, past the caretaker's booth, on the pavement, in the thin morning light, Gabriel was standing with his hands in his pockets and his collar up.

He had not been asked. She had not told him where she was going. She had not even told Amélie, who had simply been handed the keys and the six o'clock schedule with no explanation.

He looked at the dish in her arms and then at her face, and did not say anything clever, which she noted.

"How long have you been standing there," she said.

"Twenty minutes. Maybe thirty." He shifted his weight. "Sorel told me where you'd gone. He said it in a way that made it clear he thought I already knew."

"Of course he did."

"I brought the van. It's around the corner." He nodded at the dish. "That's not going in the ground."

"No."

"It's going back on the shelf."

"It's going back on the shelf." She adjusted her grip on it, and the two of them started walking, and she was aware of her own face doing something she couldn't stop. "It's a working dish. It goes where the work is."

"Good," Gabriel said. "Because I have a bone to pick with you about the morning bake."

"Already?"

"Yanis doubled the folds on the first lamination. He said he was matching what you did Sunday. He was not matching what you did Sunday."

"Sunday was a demonstration," Mathilde said. "Sunday was a joke."

"I know it was a joke. He doesn't know it was a joke. Now there are six trays of a joke proofing in the walk-in and Amélie is standing in front of them with her arms crossed, refusing to touch them, which I respect."

Mathilde stopped on the pavement. The dish was heavy against her chest and the seam was cold under her palm and she could see the bakery in her mind, the steam on the window, Amélie in the pass and six trays of a joke rising in the walk-in, and a letter still sitting on the counter with a lawyer's letterhead on it, addressed to both of them, unopened since Tuesday, because they had agreed to open it together and then there had been a festival and a correction in the paper and a kiss in daylight, and they had both been avoiding the counter.

"Gabriel," she said.

"Mm."

"We open the letter tonight."

The wind came up the hill and took the smell of the cemetery off them. He looked at her for a moment, and then he looked at the dish in her arms, the reassembled thing, the seam and the frost and the crow's tracks, and something in his face closed and settled.

"Tonight," he said. "At the Fournil. After service. Amélie stays."

"Amélie stays," Mathilde agreed, and they walked the rest of the way to the van, and she did not put the dish down until they were back on the rue and the lights of the bakery were in front of her, and the letter was still on the counter, and it was waiting.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 78: The Dish Goes Home · The Proof of the Pudding · Lumen Reads