The Proof of the Pudding

Chapter 85: Proof of the Pudding

The ovens had been going since four, and by six the whole building smelled like the inside of a loaf. Mathilde stood at the pass with a cloth over her shoulder and watched the first trays come out of the Fournil's deck oven, one hundred and forty croissants, each of them layered by hand across three days, and none of them, she was pleased to note, the color of a traffic cone.

"Third rack's a shade light on the left," she said.

Théo leaned into the oven, spun the rack, and shut the door without answering, which was his way of agreeing. He'd come back to Lyon eleven months ago, after two years in Copenhagen, and he still had the Danish habit of working in silence until the job was done. Mathilde had decided to find it restful.

"Manon's downstairs with the seating chart," he said finally.

"Manon has been downstairs with the seating chart since Tuesday."

"She's a quality manager now. It's what they do."

Mathilde allowed herself a small smile and went down the spiral stair between the two kitchens, into the long room that had been two rooms when they'd bought the building. The wall between the Fournil and the Dôme was now an archway wide enough for a trolley, and the floor was the same stone on both sides, relaid in a single run. The two signs were still mounted over the street door, side by side, and they would stay that way. Some arguments you stop having because you've won them, and some you stop having because they were never the point.

Manon had the chart spread across four meters of counter, pinned at the corners with ramekins.

"Family and staff on the long table," she said without looking up. "Cooperative at two rounds. Press at the far end, near the door, so they can leave without walking through service."

"You've put Gauthier at the far end."

"Gauthier declined."

"Of course he did." Mathilde picked up a ramekin, inspected the chart, and put it back. "And Sabine Vogt?"

"Coming. She asked if she could bring her own camera."

"She can bring it as long as she eats with it down."

Manon made a note. That was the thing about Manon now, Mathilde thought: she wrote everything down, and the things she wrote down happened. A year and a half ago she'd been a commis who couldn't hold a piping bag steady and had cried, once, in the walk-in. Now she ran the quality program for both houses, all the suppliers, all the documentation, and it was largely her doing that the Tressage Renaud file was seven hundred pages thick and had ended the chain's cherry-glaze line in four months, quietly, with no announcement and no apology, which was how these things actually ended.

The rest of it had ended less quietly. The cooperative had bylaws now and a legal stamp and a bank account, and when the chain had tried to undercut the eight of them into a price war, the eight of them had simply not played, and the chain had discovered that a machine braid at twenty cents less does not beat a hand braid at the same price when the hand braid is better. They had opened two more stores and closed three. Mathilde had stopped counting.

Gabriel came up from the Dôme with flour to his elbow and a spoon in his mouth.

"Taste," he said, and held the spoon out.

She tasted. It was a sauce for the pigeon, dark and sharp with something under it she couldn't place.

"Cherry?"

"Cherry vinegar. Your mother's glaze was the sweet version. This is the other one."

"It's good."

"Say it like you mean it."

"I mean it. It's good." She took the spoon from him and set it in the sink. "If you tell anyone I said so, I'll deny it in writing."

"Sorel's filming the toast, by the way."

"He's what?"

"He asked. I said yes." Gabriel wiped his hands. "It's the anniversary. He's been following this since the suspension. Let him have the end of the story."

Mathilde looked at him for a moment. She had spent a long time, most of her life, wanting to be the kind of person nobody could photograph badly. It had taken her an embarrassingly long time to work out that the alternative was worse.

"Fine," she said. "But he doesn't get the croissant re-make."

"He says the re-make is the best thing he's ever shot."

"He says that because he shot it at nine in the morning and you were sweating."

Gabriel grinned and went back down.

They served at eight. Ninety-four covers between the two rooms, the long table down the center, and by nine the noise in the place had gone past conversation into something closer to weather. The cooperative had turned out in force; there were bakers at the rounds from every bakery on the Presqu'île, and one from Villeurbanne who had driven across the river with a box of her own pralines and made a speech nobody had asked for and everybody had enjoyed.

Mathilde worked the pass through the first two courses and then, deliberately, put down her tongs and sat. Gabriel was already at the long table, at the head of it, next to her empty chair. Manon was on her left with her notebook shut for once, and Théo on Gabriel's right, arguing with a pastry chef from the second arrondissement about whether a croissant should be laminated with butter or with something else, which was a conversation Mathilde had heard four hundred times and still found soothing.

The butter dish was in the center of the table.

She had put it there herself, an hour before service, and it had been photographed at least nine times. It was chipped on the rim, the glaze crazed across the bottom, and it was the plainest object in the room. Marie Renaud had used it every day of her working life, and it had sat in the shop window for a year and a half, and this morning Mathilde had taken it out of the window and filled it with butter and put it on the table where everyone could reach it.

Gabriel caught her eye across the table and didn't say anything. He didn't have to. They had had the argument in February, and again in April, and it had ended the way most of their arguments ended, which was with both of them right and neither of them backing down until it stopped mattering which one had been right.

Sorel's camera was up on the far side, small and quiet, red light on.

Gabriel stood up and tapped his glass twice.

"Two things," he said, when the room had come down enough to hear him. "I'm going to keep this short, because Mathilde has a dessert in the back that will die if I don't, and because both of us have said more than enough tonight already."

Someone at the cooperative rounds said something Mathilde didn't catch, and the room laughed.

"A year and a half ago, some of you were in this room when I made a fool of myself in front of everyone. I stand by it." He paused. "A year and a half ago we also got a letter telling us our mother's book was a public document and our name was a marketing term. And instead of doing the sensible thing, which was to fold, we did the other thing, which was to argue. With them. With each other. Constantly. About the signs, about the lease, about whether the two kitchens should share a walk-in—"

"We should not," said Mathilde.

"We should not," Gabriel agreed. "She was right. She's also been right about the braid, the trademark, the cooperative's voting structure, and the fact that I cannot be trusted near a proof box before noon. And I've been right about the pigeon, the wine list, and everything that has actually happened in this room tonight."

"One of those things," said Mathilde.

"Two." He held up his glass. "So here's the toast. To the two things we never stopped doing. Arguing, and cooking."

"Arguing and cooking," the room said back, and glasses went up all down the long table and around both rounds and at the far end, where Sabine Vogt lowered her camera for exactly four seconds to drink.

Mathilde stood. She drank. Then she sat down again and nobody made her make a speech, which was the single best thing about the last eighteen months.

The dessert came out at ten: a cherry and almond tart, the glaze from her mother's notebook, the cherries from a grower in the Ardèche who had been supplying the Fournil since her father's time and had never once raised his price on her. They served it family style, two tarts to a table, and there was a scuffle at the cooperative rounds over the last slice that Sorel filmed in its entirety.

By midnight the room had thinned to the staff table and a few stragglers. Manon was stacking plates because she could not sit still. Théo had his feet up on a chair and was telling a story about a Danish baker who had tried to make a croissant with rye, which Mathilde did not believe but was willing to let stand.

Gabriel came around the table and sat down in the chair beside her, close, his shoulder against hers, and handed her a glass of water.

"Your tart was better than mine," he said.

"It was my mother's tart."

"It was better than mine."

"It was better than yours." She drank the water. In the butter dish in the middle of the table there was about a finger of butter left, and the chip in the rim was facing her, the way it always did. "Sorel got what he needed?"

"He got the toast and the tart and Manon yelling at the dishwashers. He says it's the ending."

"It isn't an ending."

"He knows. He's calling it the ending anyway." Gabriel leaned back. "The press piece runs Sunday. The cooperative's first-year accounts are filed. Gauthier has stopped sending letters. Vogt's documentary airs in the spring and I'm told we come off well, apart from me."

"You come off fine."

"You haven't seen it."

"I don't need to see it."

He turned his head and looked at her, and she let him, which she was better at now than she had been. Somewhere below them the Dôme's ovens were cooling and the Fournil's were already off, and the room smelled of butter and coffee and the last of the cherries.

"Same time tomorrow?" Mathilde said.

Gabriel reached over and moved the butter dish an inch so it sat exactly in the center, the way she liked it, and took her hand under the table where nobody could see.

"Always," he said.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 85: Proof of the Pudding · The Proof of the Pudding · Lumen Reads