The clinic occupied the ground floor of a building off the rue des Rosiers, sandwiched between a kosher bakery and a shop that sold nothing but buttons. A hand-lettered sign in the window said PERMANENCE JURIDIQUE — OMEGA AFFAIRS, and beneath it, smaller: free consultation, Tuesdays and Thursdays, 14h–18h.
Céline had walked past this street a hundred times and never once looked at it.
Inside, a Beta receptionist with silver hair took her name and told her to wait. The room held six plastic chairs, three of them occupied. An Omega woman in a delivery uniform held a manila envelope against her chest like a shield. Two young men sat together, whispering, one of them crying quietly, the other's hand flat between his shoulder blades.
Céline sat down. She had forty minutes before she needed to leave for the métro, and she spent thirty of them rehearsing what she would say and discarding all of it.
"Rousseau?" The receptionist pointed down a corridor. "Third door."
The office was small and warm and smelled of paper and lemon verbena. Behind the desk sat an Alpha woman in her sixties, silver-haired, wearing a blazer the colour of wet slate and no scent at all — suppressants, strong ones, the kind that cost real money. Céline clocked it immediately and felt something in her chest loosen by one degree.
"Maître Dupont." The lawyer didn't stand, just gestured at the chair opposite. "Sit. You're a perfumer."
Céline sat. "You know me?"
"I read the trades. Everyone in this arrondissement read the trades this week." Dupont folded her hands. "You have the look of someone who has been told her options are worse than they are. Tell me why you're here, and be quick. I have a young man after you whose employer docked his heat leave."
Céline told her. The formula. The registration under Alexandre Vane's name. The twenty-second. The press photograph with her own atelier in the background and the unlabelled jar of orris on the shelf. She told it flat and fast, the way you read out a list, and when she finished, Dupont had not moved.
"May I ask you something personal?"
"You may."
"Is your mother alive?"
Céline blinked. "No."
"Did she work?"
"She was a seamstress."
"And did she ever own anything she made?"
Céline said nothing.
Dupont nodded slowly, as if she'd heard the answer anyway. "That's the shape of it. Alpha employers have been lifting Omega work since long before perfume. Couture, cooking, cosmetics, a hundred years of it. We have a name for it in law. We call it *contrat de cession implicite*, which is a polite way of saying that the person who signs the payroll owns the soul." She picked up a pen and tapped it twice against the desk. "What did you sign when you joined Lumière?"
"An employment contract. Standard. Twenty-two pages."
"Did you read it?"
"Twice."
"Did it name ownership of creative output?"
"It was silent on creative output. I noted that. I thought it meant it didn't apply to me."
"It applied to you." Dupont's voice was not unkind. "Silence is a door, Mademoiselle Rousseau, and someone walked through it while you were looking at the walls. But silence cuts both ways. It means he has to prove assignment. What he has is your job. What he doesn't have is a document."
Céline's hands, in her lap, went very still.
"Now." Dupont turned to a yellow legal pad. "Tell me what he *does* have."
"He has the formula."
"Written where?"
"In my head." Céline paused. "And in a notebook. In his safe, presumably. He had access to my workroom. I demonstrated for him. He smelled the trial batches personally."
"So he has the formula in a form we cannot retrieve. Fine. What else?"
"Launch materials. Press photographs. A date."
Dupont wrote three words, one per line, and underlined the third. "Evidence is the whole of it. Pro bono is not charity, Mademoiselle Rousseau. It's a bet. I take your case for nothing because I believe it will be worth something, and because I have been waiting thirty years for a case with this much spine. But I do not go to court on the strength of a story. I go to court on documents, dates, witnesses, and money trails. If we file on what you have told me, he will crush us in the instruction phase and you will owe me nothing and lose everything."
"What do I need?"
"Three things." Dupont held up a finger. "One. The internal record of when the formula was registered. There is always a paper trail — a filing, a notary, a trademark office, a laboratory batch log. Find the date. If he registered a formula that did not exist in a documented form before your employment, we break him on that alone."
"Two." Another finger. "A witness who saw or heard something that places your work in your hands and not his. Not a friend. Not your partner. Someone with a profession to lose. A supplier. A lab technician. Another perfumer."
"And three." The third finger. "Your notes. Not the formula. The *process*. Your trial sheets, your dilutions, the dates on which you built which accord. The courts care less about what you invented than about proving you invented it, and the proof of invention looks like a pile of kitchen paper with dates on it. Do you keep your trial sheets?"
"I keep everything."
"Then you may be a great deal less ruined than you believe." Dupont set down the pen. "Bring me what you have by Monday. If it is real, I will draft an *assignation* and we will file before the twenty-second."
Céline caught the date. "Before?"
"Launch is a public statement. If we file after, his press is a fait accompli and every headline reads *Alpha maison prevails over Omega ex-employee*. If we file before, the same facts read *Alpha maison sued for theft of Omega work*, and he launches in the shadow of his own lawsuit." Dupont almost smiled. "You don't win perfume cases in court, Mademoiselle Rousseau. You win them in the phraseology. My entire profession is the arrangement of phrases."
There was a knock. The receptionist's voice, muffled: five minutes.
Céline stood. Then stopped. "Maître Dupont — why do you do this?"
"Because I am an Alpha, and it costs me nothing to be ashamed of what Alphas do." Dupont pulled a card from a drawer and slid it across. "And because my grandmother was an Omega who made hats, and when she died, her employer sold the blocks. Her name is not on any of them. I would like, once, before I retire, to put a woman's name on a thing she made. Call it a personal indulgence."
The card was plain. Just a name, a phone number, a bar registration.
Céline put it in her coat pocket. At the door she turned. "The person who sent me to you — Solange Fauré. Did you know?"
Dupont looked up sharply.
"Fauré," she repeated. "The trade circular. It named me publicly. She told me to find a lawyer who would not fold." Céline watched her. "This is not a question. I am telling you that I know who recommended you."
Dupont was quiet for a moment. Then: "Solange and I have known each other forty years. She does not make recommendations for reasons. Her reasons find her later." She tapped the pad. "Monday. Bring paper."
Outside, the light had gone the colour of tea. Céline walked three streets before she stopped and took out her phone, and stood in the doorway of a shuttered florist, and looked at Manon's name in the list without touching it.
Because Dupont had said *before the twenty-second*, which meant filing, which meant naming Vane publicly, which meant that tonight someone would call the atelier and someone else would call the press and the man who had entered with a key on the fourth of October would know that his employer's name had just been written into a court file.
And the only evidence she actually had was a jar of unlabelled orris root on a shelf in a photograph.
Which meant — Céline stood very still in the doorway and let the street pass around her — someone had walked into her atelier, found a jar she had never labelled, and known exactly what it was.
She had never written that down.
She dialled Manon.
"Where are you?" Manon said.
"Near the Marais." Céline's voice was steady, which surprised her. "I have a lawyer. Pro bono. She'll file before the twenty-second. But she needs evidence, and I need you to be at the atelier tonight, because there is something I have to tell you, and it is going to change what we're looking at."
A beat. "Céline."
"What."
"The Thursday meeting. You still haven't told me how you plan to walk into that room."
Céline looked at the shuttered florist. At her own reflection faint in the glass.
"Because I don't have a plan," she said. "I have a date. And a list of everything the man has done to get it. And after tonight, I'll have a witness, because you're going to help me find one."