The Scent of Our Own

Chapter 23: The Journalist

Claire Ferrand ordered a second espresso before she ordered anything else, which Céline decided to interpret as a good sign. Journalists who were going to gut you usually wanted wine.

The café was on the rue du Temple, four streets from anywhere either of them was known, and Claire had chosen it herself. Small, northern light, a radio behind the bar playing something old. She was Beta, in her forties, with close-cropped grey hair and a canvas bag that had been repaired at the strap with waxed thread, which Manon had noticed within ten seconds of sitting down and had not yet stopped noticing.

"I read the pitch twice," Claire said. She put a small recorder on the table, face-down, switched off. "I'm not recording. If I turn it on later I'll ask."

"Good," Céline said.

"Your pitch said Omega creatives, plural. Freelancers, ateliers, small houses. That's a real story and nobody's writing it. I want to be clear about what it isn't." Claire drank. "It isn't an exposé of Maison Lumière. I work features, not investigations, and my editor would spike anything that reads like I'm carrying someone's lawsuit for them."

Manon's hands stayed flat on the table. She had dressed for this the way she dressed for clients — grey wool, one seam of stitching up the left cuff in a thread two shades darker, visible only if you looked. Céline had watched her choose it. Everything Manon did now was either armour or bait.

"We're not asking you to," Céline said.

"Then tell me what you *are* asking."

Céline had rehearsed three versions of this on the walk over and abandoned all of them. "Two years ago I worked at Lumière under an Alpha named Vincent Vane. I made his bestsellers. He's launching a signature scent line at the end of the month and I believe the central formula is mine. I'm not going to tell you that on the record, because my lawyer would remove my hands."

Claire's eyebrows went up a millimetre and stayed. "You have a lawyer."

"As of Tuesday."

"For which. The formula or the sample."

The café radio shifted to something with a horn section. Céline heard her own breath.

"You know about the sample," Manon said.

"I know there are four people in this city who'd say the word 'sample' in the same breath as 'perfume house' and 'pheromone signature,' and three of them have told me to drop it. I'm not going to quote any of them." Claire turned her cup a quarter-turn. "I'm not going to quote you either. I want to understand what kind of story this is before I decide whether I can write it."

"It's a story about who gets to own a smell," Céline said.

Claire stopped turning the cup.

"Ten years ago a woman in Grasse synthesised a musk that three Alpha houses now sell as proprietary. She's dead. Her name's not on anything. That's not perfume, that's extraction — and it's not a metaphor, it's the actual business model. They sample us, they file, they launch, they call it inspiration." She heard herself getting fast and slowed down. "I can't prove my case to you. I'm not trying to. I'm telling you there's a feature in the Omegas who've stopped waiting for the front door to open."

Claire was quiet long enough that Manon's flat hands moved, one thumb finding the other wrist.

"Here's what I'll say in the other direction," Claire said at last. "If I write this, and it's good, and people read it — you will not be safer. That's the part everyone gets wrong. Exposure feels like armour. It isn't. It's a map." She counted on her fingers without looking at them. "One, I name you, and suddenly every buyer in Paris knows exactly which formulas are contested. Two, I name Lumière, and their lawyers read it twice as carefully as the public does. Three, and this is the one that matters — if you're already in a dispute, printing anything before it's filed gives them a month of time to build a counter-narrative with better reach than yours."

"Before the twenty-second," Manon said.

Claire looked at her. "You have a filing date."

"We have a filing date," Manon said, and did not look at Céline.

Céline felt the room tilt a degree. Manon had just handed a journalist the most valuable fact they owned, and she had done it without blinking, and either it was the best move in the room or it was the worst, and there was no time to decide which.

Claire didn't write it down. Céline watched her not write it down and understood, grudgingly, that she was dealing with someone who had done this before.

"Okay," Claire said. "Feature. No litigation, no investigation, no unnamed sources whispering about Vincent Vane. A piece about Omega and Beta artisans in the Paris trades — perfumers, tailors, bookbinders, whoever else you'll introduce me to — and how the houses are structured so that credit flows upward and out. Structural. Nobody's personal case is in it." She held Céline's eye. "And when your thing is filed, *then* we talk about whether there's a second piece."

"Structural," Céline repeated.

"Structural. That's the deal, and it's a real deal — I'll file it with my editor this week. But I need three things and I need them honestly. One, access. Not photos, introductions. Two, nobody who talks to me can be someone whose livelihood gets worse because they talked. You vet that, not me. Three—" she paused, and for the first time looked slightly less like a professional and slightly more like a person, "—three, when it runs, your name is on it as the source who brought me the story. That's non-negotiable. I don't do anonymous benefactors."

The horn section ended. The radio played a jingle for a mattress shop.

"If my name's on it, Vane knows I talked to you before the filing," Céline said.

"He'll know you talked to *someone*. He'll suspect. There's a difference." Claire drained the cup. "I'm not going to pretend the difference is large. But the alternative is I write the piece and it has no face, and a piece with no face doesn't rally anyone. You told me yourself, outside the door just now—" she gestured vaguely at the street, "—the whole point is we stop hiding the work. That cuts both ways."

Manon said, "What's your deadline."

"Ten days for interviews, then I write. Publishing within the month if my editor holds the slot."

"So it lands near the launch."

"It lands when it lands. I don't move stories for other people's timetables."

Céline stood up. Both of them looked at her — Manon half-rising, Claire just watching.

"Ten days," Céline said. "I'll bring you seven people. Three of them will refuse and I'll tell you why honestly, and you won't approach them again. One of them is a bookbinder in Belleville who'll be the best thing in your piece and never speak to me again if you get her wrong."

"That's fair."

"And I want something from you."

Claire waited.

"Don't call it a scene. Don't write 'a growing underground.' We're not underground. We've been here the whole time. That's the piece."

Claire looked at her for a while. Then she picked up the recorder, put it back in the canvas bag, and stood.

"I'll call you Thursday," she said. "Bring me the bookbinder first."

She shook Céline's hand, then Manon's, and went out into the street without looking back, which Céline noted as either complete trust or complete calculation, and could not decide which.

They didn't speak until they were on the boulevard, walking fast, the way you do when the meeting is over and the next thing hasn't started.

"You told her the filing date," Céline said.

"I did."

"Was that planned?"

"No." Manon's jaw worked. "She was going to write the same piece either way. The date was the only thing that made us not a story she could file in a drawer."

"Or the only thing that told her how much time Lumière has."

"Yes." Manon stopped at the crossing, and the wind came up the boulevard and moved the thread on her cuff. "Both can be true, Céline. You said that to me once."

Céline didn't remember saying it.

The light changed and they crossed, and on the far pavement Céline took out her phone to check the time and saw that she had a message from a number she didn't have saved. It had come in during the meeting. One line.

*I heard you're looking for someone in the trades. I run the textile archive at the Musée de la Mode. There's a bolt of '55 silk in my storeroom with a maker's stamp on the selvedge. Nobody in this city knows whose stamp it is but me. — S. Branchet*

Céline read it twice, standing still in the middle of the pavement with people flowing around her, and then a third time, and handed the phone to Manon without a word.

Manon read it. Her face did something Céline had seen only once before, in a lawyer's office on a Tuesday.

"'55," Manon said.

"Three years before Solange started the house."

"A stamp on the selvedge. Maker's marks on silk selvedge were Omega workshop practice. The Alpha houses bought the bolts and cut the selvedge off before the garments went out." Manon looked up. "Céline. If that bolt is what I think it is—"

"It's a paper trail," Céline said. "Three years older than anything Dupont has."

They stood there, two women on a boulevard with a phone between them, and Céline understood that they had just gotten something better than a journalist and worse than a witness.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 23: The Journalist · The Scent of Our Own · Lumen Reads