The Scent of Our Own

Chapter 34: The Evidence Room

Maître Dupont's office smelled of old paper and lemon polish, a combination that had, over three prior visits, come to feel like the anteroom of bad news. Today was different. Today there were three stacks of documents on the conference table, each marked with a colored tab, and Dupont herself was standing rather than seated behind her desk.

"Before we begin," she said, "I want to be clear about what I am and am not telling you."

Céline sat. Manon sat beside her, close enough that their shoulders nearly touched. On the table between them: the origami-ed settlement offer, still unsigned, now three days past due. Alexandre's office had stopped calling. That silence had its own weight.

"You have a case," Dupont said. "That is not the same as you have a victory."

She opened the first folder. Photocopies of twelve Omega contracts, the "successors and assigns" clause highlighted in yellow on each, laid out in a grid on the table. The identical language jumped out before Dupont even spoke.

"Claire Devereux's article did half my work for me," Dupont said. "It established a pattern in the public record. That is enormously helpful. What it did not establish is intent. Intent is what a court requires before it awards damages, and intent is what Lumière's counsel will attack from the first hearing."

"Alexandre ordered the theft," Céline said. "Vane told me so."

"Vane told you so *in a room with no witnesses*, and Vane has since been, as the statement put it, 'separated from the house.'" Dupont's tone was dry. "Which brings me to my next point. Alexandre's statement this morning. You've seen it?"

Manon slid her phone across the table. Céline read the press release twice. *Lumière remains committed to transparency and to the principles of fair collaboration. Recent allegations concern a former employee whose conduct was not authorized by this house.*

"He's hanging Vane out to dry," Manon said.

"He's constructing a defense," Dupont corrected. "Every theft you can pin on Vane is a theft Lumière did not commit. He's not just discarding an employee. He's building a firewall."

Céline pressed her thumb against the edge of the settlement offer. Four hundred thousand euros. The debt released. Six years of her family's fear, erased with a signature.

"What does the timeline look like?" she asked.

"Months." Dupont sat down at last, which somehow made it worse. "I want to be honest with you both, because you deserve honesty and because I don't want to be the lawyer who tells you it'll be quick. The filing goes forward. Lumière's counsel will request extensions. There will be discovery — extensive discovery. Your formula, your employment records, your communications. They will depose you. Céline, they will depose you for two days, possibly three."

"Depose me about what?"

"Everything. Your scent memory, your process, how you can prove the formula you created at Lumière and the formula you registered with the INPI are the same formula. They will suggest you never had the formula to begin with. They will suggest you reverse-engineered it from the base the house provided. It will be unpleasant, and it will be designed to be unpleasant, and you cannot let it make you forget what you came in with."

Céline looked at the yellow highlights on the twelve contracts. Twelve Omegas. The clause that buried them. She thought of the baker's assistant with her aunt and her dated file. She thought of the letter in her drawer to Juliette, still unsent.

"And the twenty-second filing?" Manon asked. Dupont had flagged it in their first meeting — a filing Céline's predecessor had attempted, years ago, that had gone nowhere. Something about it had never sat right with Céline.

Dupont turned to the second folder. "This is what I want to walk you through, because it's the part of the case that's strongest, and it's the part neither of you built."

She laid out the documents one by one.

The twenty-second filing had been made by a perfumer named Toussaint in 2021. Toussaint had alleged that Lumière's standard employment contract concealed an assignment of moral rights — the right of an author to be identified with their work, which under French law cannot be waived. The filing had been dismissed on procedural grounds. Toussaint had withdrawn it, settled quietly, and vanished from the industry.

"Toussaint's dismissal," Dupont said, "was granted on a technicality. The court never reached the merits. But the merits are right there in his brief, and the brief is in the public record, and the clause he challenged is the same clause in all twelve of these contracts."

"Then why did he lose?" Manon asked.

"Because he was alone." Dupont tapped the twelve highlighted clauses. "One Omega against a house is a story about one Omega. Twelve Omegas against a house is a story about the house. That is a different case. That is the case you have."

Céline felt the shape of it settle into her chest. Twelve names. The collective. The March eleventh table.

"The Toussaint precedent cuts both ways," Dupont went on. "It proves the clause exists and has been challenged. It also proves that a challenge, alone, gets buried. Lumière's counsel will cite it. They will say this was already litigated and resolved. Our answer is that it was never litigated — it was settled, and a settlement is not a judgment."

"How long?" Manon asked. "Give us a number."

"The discovery process alone, four to six months. A first hearing, perhaps eight. A ruling on the merits — " Dupont spread her hands. "Fifteen months, if we're lucky. Two years, if we're not."

The office's radiator ticked in the silence.

Céline did the arithmetic against the atelier lease, under twenty days now, and the March eleventh table, and the legal fund the collective had barely begun to fill. Fifteen months of legal fees. Two years of depositions. Two years of being asked to prove her own hands.

She looked at Manon. Manon was looking back — not asking, not urging, just watching. Since the night of the debt letter they had been careful with each other, careful in a way that felt like standing on either side of a door neither wanted to open first. Céline had signed the settlement offer's envelope, then un-signed it, then put it in the drawer with the letter. Manon had not asked about either. That restraint had its own language.

"Say the worst case," Céline said. "We lose. What does losing look like?"

"Costs awarded against you. A judgment that the clause is enforceable as written. And the precedent — " Dupont paused. "The precedent would make it harder for the next Omega. My professional advice is that you should weigh that in your decision. Not just what you stand to gain. What a loss would cost the people who come after."

"That's not advice," Manon said quietly. "That's a warning."

"They're the same thing, in my line of work."

Céline stood. She walked to the window. Rue de Rivoli below, gray and wet, bicycles threading between taxis. Somewhere north, the atelier — hers and Manon's, the lease under twenty days — was holding a table for two hundred Omegas at the March eleventh show. Somewhere south, in Lyon, a woman named Juliette Vasseur was doing bookkeeping and signing loan papers under a name that was not hers.

She turned back to the table.

"I want to proceed," she said. "The filing. The depositions. All of it."

Dupont nodded slowly, writing something on a legal pad. "And the settlement offer? Alexandre expects an answer."

"It expires when it expires."

"That's not how it works. He'll call again."

"Then I'll tell him myself." Céline picked up the phone with Alexandre's press release still glowing on the screen and set it face-down on the table. "No. Not myself. Through you. I'm not negotiating with him."

Dupont made a note. "Good. That's the correct instinct."

Manon had not moved. When Céline sat back down, Manon's hand found hers under the edge of the table — brief, firm, gone before Dupont looked up. It said: *I'm here.* It said nothing else, and that was fine, for now.

"There's one more thing," Dupont said, and her voice had changed. Flatter. More careful. "You gave me the Ferrand material to review."

"The investigator's report. The holding company."

"Armenier et Fils. I had a colleague cross-reference the corporate filings with the registry of commercial agents." Dupont opened the third folder, the one neither of them had seen. "Armenier et Fils is a holding. It was registered in 2019. Its listed director is a nominee — a retired accountant in Clermont-Ferrand who directs forty-one other shell entities. But nominees always name a beneficial owner somewhere, and the beneficial owner of Armenier et Fils is listed as a corporate parent."

She turned the page.

"The corporate parent is registered in Luxembourg. And its majority shareholder is a French limited partnership with two partners: a family office in Geneva, and — "

She stopped.

"And?" Céline said.

"Withoutière Holding," Dupont said. "Which is a real estate and investment group based in Paris. The kind that owns a stake in anything with a marble lobby." She looked up. "Lumière's premises at 14 rue de Castiglione are owned by Withoutière. Long-term lease, signed 2013."

The room went very quiet.

"Say it plainly," Manon said.

"Plainly," Dupont said, "the holding company that has been guaranteeing the Rousseau family loan since 2019 appears to be controlled, through an offshore chain, by the same group that owns the building Lumière operates out of. The same building where Céline developed the formula now at the center of this case."

Céline heard her own voice come from somewhere far away. "So when Alexandre's office called me in — when Lumière hired me — "

"It is possible," Dupont said carefully, "that the house did not simply discover a talented Omega perfumer and take her formula. It is possible the house was told to expect one. The debt letter. The list. The contracts. The building." She closed the folder. "It is possible, Céline, that you were recruited by the very mechanism your family signed in 2019, from the day you walked through that door."

Céline's hand found the edge of the table. Manon's found her wrist.

Dupont did not look away. "That changes the case. It changes it from theft to something we don't yet have a word for. And I need to tell you both — before you decide anything else — that if this is what I think it is, then proceeding is no longer a choice about money. It is a choice about who is going to spend the next two years determining the rest of your life."

Céline looked at the three stacks of documents. The highlighted clauses. The filing. The holding company.

She thought of her sister, doing accounts in Lyon under a borrowed name, still guaranteeing the loan six years on.

"I'm not withdrawing," she said. "I want to win this in a courtroom where they have to say it out loud."

Dupont nodded and reached for her pen. Beneath the table, under the folder's edge, Manon's fingers tightened around Céline's — and neither of them let go for the rest of the meeting.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 34: The Evidence Room · The Scent of Our Own · Lumen Reads