The Palais de Justice filled the room with the smell of cold stone and old paper. Céline signed the last page at 9:14 a.m., and Maître Dupont's clerk stamped it before the ink had fully dried.
"That's it," Dupont said, sliding a copy across the table. "The complaint is filed. As of this moment, Maison Lumière has been served notice of an intellectual property and discrimination suit in the Tribunal Judiciaire de Paris."
Manon took the copy and folded it into her bag without looking at it. She had dressed for the occasion — charcoal jacket she'd tailored herself, no perfume, hair pinned. She looked like what she was: a woman who had come to court.
Céline's hands were steady. That surprised her. She had expected to shake.
"Timeline on service?" she asked.
"Alexandre's office will be notified by end of day. His lawyers will respond within the week. Expect a phone call before that — there's always a phone call." Dupont closed his file. "Do not take it. Anything he says to you directly is a potential trap. Do not answer that text from last night either, and for God's sake don't meet him."
Céline and Manon exchanged a look. Neither mentioned that the phone was still on, face-down on the kitchen table at home.
The first call came at eleven.
Céline was in the atelier, blending a test batch of Sororité, when Jules knocked on the glass door and mouthed *press*. The phone rang again. A third call from a number she didn't recognize.
Manon answered the fourth.
"Manon Marchand." A pause. "Yes, she's here. No comment. No, we won't be discussing the terms. File or don't. Goodbye." She hung up and set the phone on a shelf. "Le Figaro. They had the filing before lunch. Someone talked."
"Someone always talks." Céline kept stirring. Vetiver, then a drop of orris. "How bad is it?"
"Bad depends on where you stand."
By evening, two more outlets had run the story. *Le Monde* framed it carefully — *Une petite maison accuse un géant* — and named the Omega discrimination clause in the second paragraph. The trade press was less kind. *FashionDaily Paris* ran a headline that read: *Perfumer Sues Former Employer Weeks After Quiet Exit — Industry Divided.* The comments were worse than the article. *She signed a contract. She wants the money back and the credit too. Classic.* Below it, dozens of Omega users posted the same three words: *We believe her.*
The hashtag #NousCroyonsElle trended for four hours.
At ten past nine that night, the atelier door opened and Claire Boisseau walked in, still in her work coat, carrying a paper bag.
"I brought bread," she said. "And I've been reading since four o'clock. Tell me what I can do."
Manon looked up from her laptop. "You came straight from the studio?"
"I left early. Marie's covering." Claire set the bag down and pulled out a warm baguette, a jar of tapenade, a wheel of cheese the size of a saucer. She looked at Céline. "You look like hell."
"Thank you."
"I mean it as a compliment. You look like someone who filed a lawsuit." Claire sat down and folded her hands. "I've worked in this industry for nineteen years. I've seen three names get stolen. I've never once seen anyone sue. So — what do you need?"
Céline looked at Manon, then back at Claire. "Honestly? People who will still take our calls in March."
"That I can do." Claire reached into her coat and took out a folded sheet of paper. "Which is why I've been emailing since five. Twelve independent ateliers. Seven have already replied. Four say yes to a joint statement. Three want to meet before committing." She slid the paper across. "I also called someone at the Fédération. She's an old friend. She won't go on record, but she told me something."
Manon leaned in. "What?"
"Lumière's legal counsel is out of Lyon."
Céline's stirring stopped. The tincture she'd been holding sat motionless in her hand.
"Lyon," Manon repeated. "*Who* in Lyon?"
"She wouldn't give me a name. She said, and I quote, 'The file is being handled by a firm that also does holding-company work, which struck me as odd for a defamation and IP defense.'" Claire shrugged. "I don't know what that means. But you both just went very still, so I assume you do."
Céline set the tincture down. She did not look at Manon. "It means the same firm that handles the holdings may be handling the defense. It means they're already connected. It means they knew we'd file."
"Or," Manon said carefully, "it means nothing at all. Corporate firms are corporate firms."
"Ferrand's report said Armenier et Fils was signed through a holding that ties back to Withoutière. Now Lumière's counsel is a firm that also does holding work, out of Lyon, the same city where Juliette has lived since 2019." Céline turned to face her. "You don't find that instructive?"
Claire looked between them, tactfully silent.
"I find it *possible*," Manon said. "I don't find it proven. There's a difference, and the difference is what pays for the lawyers."
The bread cooled on the table. Nobody touched it.
The letter arrived the next morning, hand-delivered by a courier in a plain brown envelope, addressed to Céline in looping black ink.
She opened it in the kitchen while Manon was in the shower. Inside was a single sheet, unsigned, no letterhead. Seven lines, typed.
*Mme Rousseau — Before this becomes a matter of public record, consider what you actually want. The formula exists in a hundred places. Your name exists in one. There is a version of this that ends with your name on the door of a house you built yourself. There is another version that ends in a courtroom and takes two years and costs you everything you have and everything you will earn between now and then. I know which I'd choose. I suspect you do too. — A friend.*
Céline read it three times. On the third read she noticed it: the paper had a faint scent. Not perfume — something older, more chemical. Sizing. The smell of a paper mill. It was the same smell she'd noticed on the envelope that contained the original settlement offer, the one Alexandre's lawyers had sent before Dupont.
Manon came out of the bathroom, hair wet. She saw Céline's face and stopped.
"What."
Céline held out the letter without a word.
Manon read it standing, dripping, and when she finished she did not hand it back. She carried it to the window, held it up to the light, turned it over. Then she looked up.
"There's no stamp. No courier slip. Nobody signed for this." She set it on the table. "That means someone walked it to the door. That means they know where you live, Céline. Not the atelier — *here.*"
"I know."
"Then you also know what else." Manon's voice was flat. "Last night's text, and now this. Composing a nice letter takes a day. But finding the address and walking it over takes two hours. So either this was written after you filed — which means they were watching the Palais de Justice — or it was written before and delivered the same night. Either way somebody is standing close enough to smell us."
Céline had already reached for her phone. She found Ferrand's number, then paused with her thumb over the call button.
If they called the investigator, it would become part of the file. If they did not, it would disappear under a stack of complaints and motions. And there was one more thing, the thing Manon had not yet said aloud, the thing sitting in both of their mouths unsaid: a letter that says *consider what you actually want* is not a threat. It is a negotiation. And it is addressed to Céline alone, which means somebody thinks she can still be separated from Manon.
She looked up. Manon was watching her, wet-haired, patient, waiting for her to decide. On the table between them, the letter sat next to the drawer that still held Juliette's unsent envelope.
Céline put the phone face-down, pressed call, and let it ring.