The Scent of Our Own

Chapter 64: The Legal Precedent

Maître Dupont's office smelled of old paper and lemon oil, a scent Céline had come to associate with the particular optimism of legal machinery moving in her favor. She and Manon sat side by side in the two client chairs, which Dupont had years ago arranged to face her desk at an angle—close enough that clients could read documents together without leaning into each other's space. Today the arrangement felt like a small courtesy extended to a couple, and Céline noticed Manon notice it too.

"There is a version of this meeting," Dupont said, settling into her chair with a folder she did not open, "where I tell you the damages have been paid, the injunction is holding, and we are done. That is not this meeting."

Manon's hand stilled on the armrest. "Something went wrong."

"Nothing went wrong. Something went *elsewhere*." Dupont finally opened the folder and turned it to face them. The top sheet was a printout of a court decision, dense with numbered paragraphs, the kind of text Céline had learned over eighteen months to skim for the three lines that mattered. "Two weeks ago, a parfumeur named Sabine Achterberg filed suit against her former employer in Grasse. She used our brief as a template."

Céline looked up. "She what?"

"Not plagiarism. Precedent. She cited *Rousseau v. Maison Lumière* in her statement of claim—specifically the finding that a scent formula developed by an Omega employee, on Alpha-owned equipment, during paid hours, remains the intellectual property of the creator when the employment contract is silent on authorship. That was our argument. She is now the second person to make it."

"Second," Manon repeated. "There are two?"

"There are, as of this morning, six." Dupont slid a second sheet across the desk. It was a list: Sabine Achterberg in Grasse, a leatherworker in Lyon, a textile designer in Roubaix, two more names Céline didn't recognize, and a perfumer's assistant in Paris who had filed three days ago. "The Achterberg filing was first. Yours was the lever. Hers is the wedge."

Céline read the list twice. The names were ordinary. They were the names of people who had watched a televised apology and decided that the thing they had been told was impossible might, in fact, be doable.

"You're telling us we started something," Manon said. Her voice had the careful flatness she used when she was deciding how to feel about a thing.

"I'm telling you the case has become a *cause célèbre*, which is a different animal than a victory. The legal profession has a habit of taking a single good outcome and treating it as a rule. Sometimes that's generous. Sometimes it's lazy. Either way, the effect is real." Dupont tapped the list. "Four of these six plaintiffs have asked me to represent them. I've taken two, because I think two of them have actual claims and the other four are going to learn painful lessons about what *silence in the contract* means when the contract is not, in fact, silent."

"And the two you took?"

"One is strong. The other is interesting." Dupont allowed herself a small, dry smile. "The interesting one is a woman who signed a contract that *does* address authorship, but she signed it under a clause that requires her to forfeit her authorship if she ever leaves the company within eighteen months of a launch. She left at nineteen months, one week after the launch was delayed by the Alpha's own supplier failure. The company is arguing the launch date in the contract controls."

Manon leaned forward. "And you think the delay counts in her favor."

"I think a court that has already decided an Omega's labor belongs to her will find it hard to decide that an Alpha's supply-chain failure belongs to her too."

Céline set the list down. The office felt suddenly smaller, or perhaps larger—she couldn't tell which. "This is going to make us visible again."

"You never stopped being visible. What it makes you is *citable*." Dupont closed the folder. "Which is why I asked you here. There is a practical consequence, and it's not legal. It's commercial."

She stood and walked to the window, which looked out onto a narrow street where a delivery van was double-parked with its hazards on. "Your settlement with Lumière included a standard confidentiality clause about the terms. It did not—could not—prevent the court from publishing its reasoning. That reasoning is now on the record. The record is public. Which means that every Alpha house in Paris is reading the same list you just read, and most of them are reaching the same conclusion."

"Which is?" Manon asked.

"That Omega employees are now a litigation risk if you treat them carelessly, and an asset if you don't." Dupont turned back. "Some of them will respond by hiring more Omegas and treating them well. Some of them will respond by making every contract airtight and hiring no one without a lawyer's review. And at least one of them will respond by deciding that the easiest way to avoid the precedent is to make sure no Omega ever gets the chance to set one."

Céline felt the sentence land. She thought of Bertin calling their landlord, asking for their accountant's name. Reconnaissance, she had called it. This was the same motion at a larger scale: not copying, not buying in, but *positioning*.

"You think Lumière is already doing that," she said.

"I think Bertin has been doing that since before the trial ended. I think he read the judgment and understood that the most dangerous thing in the document was not the damages figure." Dupont sat back down. "The dangerous thing was the sentence that said the formula was yours *because you made it*. That sentence is now a weapon anyone can pick up. Bertin's response, if I know the type, will be to make sure that the next Omega who tries to pick it up finds that the thing she made was never entirely hers to begin with—because it was developed on company time, in a company lab, using a company process, and he has twelve lawyers whose only job is to prove the distinction between *made* and *owned*."

"But the court already ruled on that," Manon said.

"The court ruled on Céline's facts. Bertin will arrange different facts." Dupont's voice was matter-of-fact. "That's not cynicism. That's architecture. Whoever gets to build the next contract sets the next precedent."

The room was quiet for a moment. Then Céline asked the question she had been circling since the folder opened. "Why are you telling us this?"

"Because you are the two people in Paris who have the most to lose if the precedent narrows." Dupont looked from one to the other. "And because there is an opportunity in it that I don't want you to miss."

"What kind of opportunity?" Manon said.

"Six plaintiffs. Two of them will win. Four of them will lose, or settle badly, or spend three years learning that a good argument is not the same as a good case. But all six of them know your name." Dupont opened her desk drawer and took out a single sheet of paper, which she did not immediately hand over. "There is a bar committee drafting a proposal on authorship standards in the applied arts. They've asked to cite *Rousseau*. They've also asked whether the two of you would be willing to consult—informally, no fee, no public credit—on the language."

Céline looked at Manon. Manon's jaw had the set it got when she was deciding whether to be pleased or wary, and Céline could see her working through it: a consult meant visibility, visibility meant Bertin's attention, Bertin's attention meant the collection was no longer secret. But a consult also meant the language would be written by people who had actually lived it, not by lawyers who had only argued it.

"Informally," Manon said slowly, "means we can say no if it gets complicated."

"It means you can say no at any point, for any reason, and I will say you were never involved."

"And it means whoever else is in the room reads the draft before we do," Céline said.

Dupont's expression acknowledged the hit. "Yes. That's the cost."

Céline thought about the list again—the leatherworker in Lyon, the textile designer in Roubaix, the perfumer's assistant who had filed three days ago, after watching a televised apology. None of them would ever know her name. But the language she helped write might be the language that decided whether their work stayed theirs. That was not a small thing. It was, in fact, the largest thing she had ever been asked to do, larger than the trial, because the trial had been about a scent and this was about the shape of the ground everyone else would stand on.

"We'll do it," she said. "Under one condition."

Dupont waited.

"The draft comes to us before it goes to the committee. Not after. We read it first or we don't read it at all."

Dupont considered this for a moment, then nodded and slid the paper across the desk. It was a cover letter from the bar committee, three paragraphs of formal language, and at the bottom, in a line of smaller type, the name of the committee's chair.

Manon read it first. Her hand went still.

"What?" Céline said.

Manon turned the paper around. The chair of the committee was listed as Maître Isabelle Fournier—not the advocate who had argued against them at trial, but the junior counsel who had drafted the defense's motion to disqualify the debt-and-pattern argument. The motion that was still pending when the judge had ruled. The motion that had never been withdrawn and never been decided.

"She's chairing the committee that wants to cite our case," Manon said. "Either she's changed her mind, or she wants to write the language herself."

Céline looked at Dupont. Dupont's face gave nothing away, which was itself an answer.

"I noticed that too," Dupont said. "Which is why I wanted you to see the letter before you agreed to anything."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 64: The Legal Precedent · The Scent of Our Own · Lumen Reads