The Second Chorus

Chapter 1: First Contact

The gym doors banged open against the cinderblock wall, and half the parents already seated in folding chairs turned to look. Adam Reyes caught the door with his shoulder before it could swing back and hit anyone, and walked in with his boots striking the floor too loud, too fast, still in his turnouts with the reflective tape catching the fluorescent light.

He was forty minutes late.

The school secretary at the table by the entrance gave him a look he'd seen before — the one that said *we all know why you're late, and we all think it's noble, and we all wish you'd washed.* He smelled like a dumpster fire because he had, in fact, just come from a dumpster fire. Behind the Safeway on Vine Street. Someone's restaurant grease had cooked off and taken the cardboard with it, and he'd spent an hour and a half on a ladder with a hose while the whole block stood around filming it for their phones.

"Reyes," he said. "Mayra Reyes. Sixth grade."

"Room two-eleven," the secretary said. "Mr. Whitaker. He's the new music teacher. You're the last one."

The hallway was long and smelled like floor wax and somebody's microwave popcorn. Every door had a construction-paper banner over it. He passed a bulletin board with photographs of last year's community festival taped to it — kids on a stage, kids in costumes, a woman with a fiddle — and he kept his eyes on the linoleum ahead of him and did not slow down.

Room two-eleven had its door propped open with a rubber wedge. Inside, at a table meant for a twelve-year-old, a man was stacking papers into a folder. He looked up when Adam filled the doorway.

He was younger than Adam had expected, with dark curls that were threatening to escape whatever he'd done to them that morning, and a button-down the color of a good sunset, sleeves rolled to the elbow. He had a pen tucked behind his ear like a man who lost things constantly and had learned to keep them attached to his body.

"Mr. Reyes," he said, standing. "I was starting to think Mayra had no one coming."

"She has someone coming. He got held up."

"That would be you."

"That would be me." Adam didn't sit. Sitting would mean he was staying, and he had already decided he was not staying. "What's the problem with her?"

Gabe blinked. "There's no problem. Mayra's a pleasure. Honestly — she's one of the most naturally musical kids I've had."

"Her mother played," Adam said, and the sentence came out flat, the way he said most true things, packed in sand and set down carefully so it wouldn't go off.

Something shifted in the teacher's face — recognition, maybe sympathy, and Adam disliked it immediately. He had a whole speech prepared for people who knew: *we're fine, we've been fine, she's fine.* He didn't need to use it on a stranger. Not tonight.

"Right," Gabe said. He sat back down, which put him lower than Adam, which was maybe a choice. "I've been working with her on piano. At lunch. She asked if she could."

"She didn't tell me that."

"I told her she should." A beat. "You weren't easy to get hold of."

"I work shifts."

"Yeah. I got that." Gabe gestured vaguely at the turnouts, the smell, the whole production of him. "Anyway. The reason I wanted to talk to you tonight."

"Go ahead."

"The festival. The community festival, second weekend of June. Every year the elementary and middle school kids do a showcase, and this year they've asked me to put together a concert — real repertoire, not just the recorder massacre." He smiled, quick and lopsided. "And I want Mayra to audition for a solo. There's an arrangement of 'Shenandoah' I've been reworking for a kid voice and piano, and she — "

"No."

Gabe stopped. The pen behind his ear had slid a little and he didn't notice.

"No," Adam said again, to make it a wall and not a hesitation.

"Can I ask why?"

"You can ask."

"I'm asking."

Adam shifted his weight. The chair beside him was too small for him; everything in this room was too small for him; he wanted to be home, in his own kitchen, with the radio on low. "She's twelve. She's got school, she's got enough going on. She doesn't need a stage and a bunch of people staring at her and a spotlight and whatever else you're planning. She does better without all that."

"She does better than anyone in that class," Gabe said. "I'm not trying to be flattering. I'm telling you what I see five days a week. She plays like she's been playing for years."

"She has."

"Because her mother — "

"Watch it."

The room got very quiet. Out in the hallway, the secretary's chair squeaked. Gabe held up both hands, palms out, easy, easy.

"Okay," he said. "I'm sorry. That was clumsy."

"It was."

"I just mean she told me her mom taught her. That's all I know about it. That's all I need to know."

Adam said nothing. Somewhere behind him a kid ran down the hall and was called back by an adult voice, and the sound receded, and it was just the two of them in a third of the light the room was built for.

"I've got her on the bench four days a week," Gabe said, quietly now. "She comes in on her lunch, she doesn't eat half the time, she sits down and she works. And when she gets something right, she gets this look — you've seen it, I'm sure you've seen it. Like she solved something."

"I've seen it."

"So you know what I'm talking about."

"I know exactly what you're talking about," Adam said, and his voice had gone rough. "Her mother had that same look. Her mother had a keyboard in the front room and she'd sit there with Mayra on her lap before Mayra could even talk, and she'd play until the neighbors complained. And then she got sick. And she'd still — " He stopped. Put a hand on the back of the chair, not for balance, just to have something under it. "The last thing she did that wasn't dying was teach that kid the top hand of a hymn she couldn't finish."

Gabe's face had gone still. He had the grace not to look away.

"I know what the look is," Adam said. "I know what the kid can do. That's not the question."

"Then what's the question?"

The question was: *what happens when she's up there alone, with a microphone, and the one person she's playing for isn't in the room.* The question was: *what happens when she finds out that playing the thing her mother loved is not the same as having her mother.* The question was whether letting her try was love or the opposite, and Adam had been turning it over for two years now and had never once come up with the answer, and he was not going to hand it to a music teacher in a rolled-up shirt with a pen behind his ear and let him solve it in one parent-teacher night.

"The question is I said no," Adam said.

"Mr. Reyes — "

"I said no." He pulled his keys out of his coat pocket. "You want to teach her in your class, that's your job. That's fine. You want to put her on a stage in front of half the town and have her sing her mother's songs — that's not fine. That's not your call. It's mine."

Gabe stood up this time. He wasn't angry, which somehow made it worse; he looked *careful*, like a man handling something breakable that didn't want to be handled. "I'm not trying to put her mother's songs on a stage. That's not — I didn't even know. I picked 'Shenandoah' because it's pretty and it sits low enough for her range. That's it. That's the whole story."

"Then pick another kid."

"There isn't another kid who can do it."

"Then I guess the festival's down a solo."

He was at the door. Gabe said his name — "Mr. Reyes" — and it stopped him, one hand on the doorframe, because he was tired and smelled like smoke and it had been a long shift and he was doing what he always did, which was stand between his daughter and everything that might take her apart.

"You're assuming she wants to be protected," Gabe said.

Adam turned his head, not all the way. "From what?"

"From being good at something." Gabe's voice was low, but it carried in the empty room. "She's not made of glass, Mr. Reyes. She's a kid who lost her mom and who's really, genuinely good at this one thing, and those two facts don't cancel out. Nobody's saying she forgets. I'm saying the opposite." A short breath. "You can't keep her in the front room forever."

The fluorescent light buzzed. Adam heard the words land, one after another, and felt the place where each one hit — because they were true enough that he didn't have a response that wasn't a fight, and he wasn't going to fight a teacher in a classroom. Not tonight. Not ever, if he could help it.

"You don't know me," he said. "You don't know her."

"I know her better than you think."

"That's what worries me."

He walked out. He took the hallway fast, past the construction-paper banner and the bulletin board with last year's festival photos, and this time he did look — a kid in a cowboy hat, a kid with a violin, row after row of them lit up — and he looked away and kept going, and he did not run, because a man in turnouts doesn't run through a school unless something's actually on fire.

Behind him, Gabe Whitaker stood in room two-eleven with the folder of papers in his hands and the pen still balanced behind his ear, listening to the heavy boots go down the hall, and knew, with the certainty of a man who had just been told a lot of things he hadn't been told, that he was going to see Adam Reyes again.

He just didn't know yet whether that would be a good thing.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 1: First Contact · The Second Chorus · Lumen Reads