The Second Chorus

Chapter 11: The Debt Letter

The envelope was already open on the kitchen counter when Gabe got home, slit along the top with his thumb the way he always did, because leaving it sealed meant it could still be nothing.

It wasn't nothing.

He read it standing up, coat still on, keys still in his hand. The paper had that gray, institutional look — no logo worth remembering, just a return address in some Pennsylvania processing center and the word DEFAULT in a font that managed to be polite about it.

*Your account has been referred to collections.*

He read it again. Third time he set the keys down, pulled out a chair, and sat, which was when his legs reminded him he'd been standing for the last four hours at a piano with a twelve-year-old who kept starting "Rise Up" in the wrong key on purpose just to see if he'd notice.

He'd noticed.

Seventy-one thousand dollars. He knew the number the way you know a scar — not because you look at it, but because it's the first thing you map when you wake up. Six years of loans, deferred twice, then the pandemic, then the move to Colorado because the cost of living in Boston had been eating him alive, then a year of subbing and tutoring and playing wedding gigs at the Broadmoor for people who clapped politely at the Bach and talked through the Shostakovich.

He'd been paying the minimum. Sometimes less than the minimum. There was a grace period that had apparently ended eight months ago, and nobody sends you a letter about the grace period ending, because the whole point of a grace period is that it's the last kindness before they stop being kind.

His phone buzzed. Mayra's number — no, Adam's number, the one labeled *Reyes (Mayra's dad)*, which he'd typed in at the parent-teacher night and never changed.

*Mayra says she wants to try the harmony part in the third verse. Is that allowed or does it break your rules.*

Gabe stared at the screen. He wanted, for a second, to type something real. *I might have to leave. I might have to take a job in Denver and hand her off to someone else three months into this thing.* He watched the cursor blink.

*It's allowed,* he wrote back. *Tell her the third verse is hers.*

Then he put the phone face-down and read the letter a fourth time, because that's what you do when a number is that big. You keep checking to see if there's a decimal point you missed.

The call was a bad idea by every measure. He made it anyway, at nine-forty at night, sitting on his porch with the letter folded into quarters in his jacket pocket, like it was evidence and he was a suspect.

It rang four times.

"Gabe. It's late."

"I know. Sorry." He could hear the television cutting off on the other end. "Is this a bad time?"

"For you? Never." Rachel Sung had been his conducting professor at New England Conservatory, and had spent most of his junior year telling him he played like a man apologizing for taking up space. She'd been right, which he'd resented for about a decade and now just accepted. "You sound like you're sitting outside."

"It's Colorado. We sit outside."

"Mm." She let it sit. That was her gift — she'd wait you out until you said the thing.

"There was a job listing," Gabe said. "You forwarded it. Back in January."

"The Denver one."

"Assistant conductor. Second chair. Full-time, benefits, thirty-eight a year with the touring supplement."

"There's a supplement now. Interesting." A pause. "Are you calling to tell me you applied, or are you calling to tell me you're thinking about applying, which is a different and much more sad phone call."

"I don't know if I can take it," he said. "I'm in the middle of something here."

"The festival."

"There's a kid in it."

The line went quiet long enough that he checked to see if the call had dropped.

"Gabe," Rachel said, "how much is it."

"Seventy-one."

"To the dollar?"

"To the dollar."

She exhaled. He could picture her, in the house in Cambridge with the bad radiator, wrapping the cord around her finger the way she did when she was doing math about someone's life. "The posting closes at the end of the month. They want a demo reel, three references, and a video interview. I can get you on the short list — I still have lunch with Fischer twice a year, though it's mostly so he can complain about the strings."

"Three months," Gabe said. "If they want me for next season. That's three months from now."

"That's three months, yes."

The porch light flickered. A moth was working itself to death against the glass.

"I'd have to move," he said, and then, quieter, "I just started something."

"I know you did." Her voice changed, went gentler, which he hated more than the lecture. "Listen to me. You are a very good conductor and a genuinely terrible steward of your own interests, and I have watched you torch yourself for other people twice now. I'm not going to tell you what to do. I'm going to tell you that the default goes on your credit for seven years, and you cannot teach public school with that, and you cannot rent an apartment with that, and you are thirty-six years old. So. Do the math that keeps the door open."

He didn't answer.

"Send me the reel by the twentieth," she said. "That's all I'm asking. You can always say no."

"You know I'm bad at saying no."

"That's why I said *you can say no.* It's practice." She hung up first, which was also her gift.

He went back inside and did the thing he'd been avoiding since the letter arrived. He got out his laptop, opened the folder labeled *festival 24*, and looked at the schedule he'd built — Thursday rehearsals, the Saturday sectionals, the performance date circled in red on the community center calendar.

Mayra's name was written in the third slot, next to *harmony (own arrangement?)*, with a question mark Gabe had put there because he wasn't sure the arrangement was hers or her mother's or some grafted thing in between.

He'd heard the song. Not the whole thing — she didn't let anyone hear the whole thing — but he'd heard enough, walking past the stairwell after rehearsal, to know it wasn't a folk tune and it wasn't something lifted off the radio. It was hers. Twelve years old and writing in a key she didn't have a name for yet.

He opened the job posting in a second tab. *Assistant Conductor, Colorado Philharmonic. Residency: Denver. Application deadline: March 31.*

Third tab: a mortgage calculator he'd never closed, from some earlier hour of panic.

Fourth tab: the loan servicer's login page. He entered the password wrong twice before he got it. The screen loaded. *Status: Delinquent. Recommended action: Contact your servicer immediately.*

There was a button that said *Request Hardship Deferment.*

He almost clicked it. He had his hand on the trackpad, and then he thought about standing up in front of thirty kids at the community center in six weeks, watching Mayra Reyes sing something she wrote, and then driving home to an apartment with three hundred dollars in his checking account.

He closed the laptop.

Thursday at four, Gabe got to the music room early and moved the chairs into two rows. He taped the set list to the board. He wrote *3rd verse — Mayra (harmony, her call)* in green marker, which was the color he used for things he was proud of.

His phone buzzed at 3:55. Adam.

*We're here. Mayra wants to know if she should bring the notebook.*

Gabe typed back. *Yes.*

Then he locked the phone and put it in his bag, on top of the folded letter, which he'd meant to throw away and hadn't.

The door opened. Mayra came in with the notebook pressed against her chest like a shield and Adam came in behind her with his coat still on and his good arm hanging stiff at his side, and Gabe smiled at both of them and said, "Okay. Third verse. Show me what you've got," and did not think about Denver, or the twentieth, or the empty chair this room would have in it three months from now.

Almost.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 11: The Debt Letter · The Second Chorus · Lumen Reads