The kitchen light was on when Gabe pulled into the driveway, which meant Adam had been up for a while, or hadn't slept. Both were possible. Gabe sat in his car for a minute with his hands on the wheel, running the argument through his head one more time — the parking lot, the raised voices, Mayra's face going white before she ran. He'd replayed it all night.
He knocked. Adam opened the door with a mug in one hand and dark crescents under both eyes.
"Coffee's on."
"That's not what I drove here for."
"I know." Adam stepped back. "Come in anyway."
The house smelled like it always did — woodsmoke, coffee, faint lemon from the dish soap Mayra liked. Gabe had never been inside it without her somewhere in it. Her absence made the rooms feel bigger and wrong.
Adam didn't sit. He stood at the counter, both hands wrapped around the mug, looking at the window over the sink.
"I was out of line," he said. "In the parking lot. In front of everybody."
"You were."
"I'm not going to dress it up. I accused you of something ugly, and I did it where half the festival committee could hear, and that's going to be a thing in this town for a month." He set the mug down. "I'm sorry. That's it. That's the whole apology."
Gabe leaned against the doorframe. He'd spent two hours last night deciding what he'd say if this happened, and none of it survived contact with the man actually saying it.
"Okay," he said.
"That's not acceptance. That's a receipt."
"It's acceptance. I'm just — I didn't sleep either." Gabe rubbed his eyes. "I said things too. That you were pushing her away. That wasn't fair."
"It was a little fair."
"You don't get to agree with me. That ruins it."
Adam almost smiled. Almost.
"I'm not going to pretend it didn't happen," Gabe said. "But I'll say what I should have said in the lot, before any of it: I'm sorry I put her on that riser without checking with her first. I thought I was helping. I wasn't listening to what she was telling me."
Adam nodded slowly. "She didn't sing. She stood there with her mouth shut and then she bolted."
"Yeah."
"Why'd she do that?"
Gabe hesitated. That was the door he'd promised Mayra he wouldn't open, and he'd already leaned on it once too hard and nearly knocked it in.
"That's hers to tell you," he said. "I'm not going to do it for her. Not after — not after I already came too close."
Adam's jaw worked, but he let it go. That alone told Gabe how bad the last week had gotten, that the man would let a question go.
"So," Adam said. "Truce."
"Truce."
"For her sake. Not because I've changed my mind about you."
"I know."
"I still don't trust you with her." He said it plainly, no heat in it, which made it worse somehow. "I want that on the record."
"It's on the record." Gabe crossed to the table and sat, because standing felt like being interrogated. "You know that's not going to work, right? The festival's in three weeks. She's in it. I'm the one running the music. We're going to be in the same room constantly."
"That's why I'm doing this now instead of after."
Gabe looked up. Adam had the fridge door open and was staring into it like it had the answer. He closed it without taking anything.
"About her song," Adam said.
"Her song?"
"I decided last night. She can't do 'Second Chorus.' Not — not yet."
Gabe kept his face still. He'd been waiting three weeks for the man to say the name of the song out loud. He hadn't, not once, not even at the table when they'd sat across from each other and the drive sat between them like a live thing neither of them touched.
"You found it," Gabe said. "On the drive."
"I found it."
"And?"
"And we're not doing it." Adam finally sat, across from him, close enough that Gabe could smell the coffee and the soap. "I listened to it at two in the morning, and I sat in this kitchen and thought about my daughter standing on a stage singing her mother's voice back at me, and I can't. Not this year. She's twelve. She's got enough of Elena on her without that."
Gabe nodded. He'd expected a fight here, and now that it was here, there wasn't one in him. "All right."
"All right?"
"All right. It's your call. She's your kid." He meant it. That was the strange part. Two weeks ago he would have argued. "But then we need to decide what she *does* sing, and I want to be honest with you about how I think we should do that."
"Go on."
"Let her pick."
Adam's face closed. "No."
"Just — listen. She won't sing a thing you hand her. You saw the riser. She could have fifteen songs on a list and she'd stand there with her mouth shut and hate you for it, and then hate me too, and then the festival's over and you've lost the whole point of it."
"The point of it was giving her something of Elena's."
"The point of it," Gabe said, "was her singing."
Adam didn't answer.
"So here's what I'd do. She proposes a song. Any song, whatever she wants. She brings it to me, I teach it to her, we work it until it's solid. And before it goes anywhere near a stage — anywhere, not just the festival, not just rehearsal — you hear it. You hear it before anyone else does. If you say no, it's no. Final. I'll back you and I won't argue in front of her."
Adam stared at the table. "You're giving me veto."
"I'm giving you the last word. There's a difference and you know it."
"That's the same thing."
"It's not. Last word means you listen first. Veto means you don't have to." Gabe leaned back. "I watched you do this with the drive for a week. You don't open a thing until you've decided how it ends."
The kettle clicked off behind them. Neither of them moved for it.
"You really think she'll pick something you can work with," Adam said. "What if she picks trash?"
"Then we make trash sound good."
"I'm serious."
"So am I. I can arrange anything. That's the one thing I'm actually good at." Gabe shrugged. "And she's not going to pick trash. She's twelve and she's been listening to you breathe for a month. She knows exactly what she wants and she's been waiting to be allowed to say it."
Adam was quiet for a long time. Then he did something Gabe hadn't seen him do before — he laughed, one short breath through his nose, not really humor.
"I hate that you're good at this," he said.
"What, arguing with you?"
"Talking about her like she's a person."
"She is a person."
"I know she's a person." Adam pushed his mug away. "I know that. I've been treating her like a thing that's going to break, and I can hear myself doing it, and I can't stop."
Gabe didn't have anything to say to that, so he said nothing.
"Fine," Adam said. "The proposal. She picks, we both review, I approve it or it doesn't happen. If she hands me something I can't live with, it's over and we go with something off the list, and no one gets to be mad about it."
"No one gets to be mad about it," Gabe repeated.
"You first."
"Deal."
Adam stood and went to the coffeepot and poured him a cup without asking, which was the whole apology, maybe, the part that had actual weight. He set it in front of Gabe and stayed standing.
"There's one more thing," he said.
"Of course there is."
"She's at the shop with Mrs. Herrera this morning. She'll be home around noon. I want you to come back and do this with me." He was looking at the window again. "Tell her together. The proposal thing."
"Why me?"
"Because if I tell her alone she'll think it's a trap." Adam picked up his mug. "And because she doesn't believe a thing I say about music. She believes you."
Gabe wrapped his hands around the cup. It was too hot to drink, so he just held it.
"Twelve o'clock," he said.
"Twelve o'clock." Adam nodded at him, and it was almost like the parking lot had never happened, except that it had, and they were both still standing in the wreck of it being careful with each other.
Gabe got to the door before Adam spoke again.
"Gabe."
He turned.
"The drive," Adam said. "I put it back in the lockbox. I don't want to listen to it again."
"Okay."
"I'm telling you so you don't go looking for it."
"I wasn't going to."
"Good." Adam's hand was flat on the counter. "Because even if I never let anyone hear it — even if she never sings a note of it — it's still the last thing I have of her, and I'm not losing it twice."
He said it like a man closing a door. Gabe stood in the hall with the coffee going cold in his hand and understood, all at once, that the truce had a shelf life, and it did not extend past the lockbox.