The practice room smelled like rosin and old radiator dust. Gabe had his cello between his knees, bow arm loose, working the Prelude from Bach's first suite for the fourth time that evening. Not because he needed it. Because the building was empty and the silence at his apartment had started to feel like an accusation.
He played the opening figure again, slower. Let the low G ring against the block wall.
The knock came at the window, not the door. Three quick raps, small knuckles.
Gabe set the bow across his lap. Mayra Reyes stood on the other side of the glass, backpack straps dug into both shoulders, breath fogging. He crossed the room and pulled the door open.
"You know there's a front entrance."
"It's locked." She stepped in without being invited, which he was starting to understand was just how she moved through the world. "I saw your light from the parking lot."
"You walked here?"
"I live six blocks away." She looked at the cello. "That was pretty."
"Thanks." He set it on the stand, aware of how the room had changed shape with her in it. "Does your dad know you're here?"
She didn't answer. She walked the perimeter instead, reading the sheet music taped to the walls, the festival poster, the sign-up sheet with four names on it and room for twenty.
"I want to audition," she said finally. "For the solo."
"Okay."
"Without my dad's permission."
Gabe leaned back against the riser. Outside, the parking lot lights had come on, that sodium orange that made everything look like a photograph left in the sun too long.
"No," he said.
Mayra stopped walking. "Why not?"
"Because you're twelve, and I don't run auditions behind parents' backs, even when I think the parent is wrong."
"You do think he's wrong."
"I think he's scared. Different thing." Gabe picked up his bow, then put it down again. "You want to tell me why you're asking me instead of him?"
She had her mother's hands, he realized. Not literally—he'd never met the woman. But there was a way Mayra held them, fingers slightly curved like she was already finding keys in the air, that felt inherited rather than learned. He filed it away and waited.
"He said no," she said. "When you called, I mean. I heard him that night. He didn't know I was on the stairs."
Gabe kept his face still.
"He does this thing," Mayra went on, "where he answers a question with a shorter question. I asked if I could try out and he said, 'Try out for what?' Like he'd never heard of it." She toed the leg of a music stand. "Then he said the festival's not for us."
"For us?"
"He means for people like us. Me and him." She shrugged, but it wasn't casual, not really. "After my mom died, everything got divided into stuff we do and stuff we don't. Music is stuff we don't."
Gabe sat down on the riser. He gestured at the floor beside him and she sat, dropping the backpack between her feet like a small wall.
"Your mom—" He stopped. Started over. "What did she do? Musically?"
"She sang." Mayra said it fast, like the word had been waiting a long time for a chance. "Not, like, professionally. She worked at the hospital. But she sang all the time. In the kitchen. In the car. She had this keyboard and she'd sit with me and make up words to songs that already had words." She pulled her knees up. "She was recording something. Before. I heard her talking to my dad about it. A record, I think. I don't know if she finished."
Gabe looked at the sheet music on the wall. The Bach was still in his head, that descending line, patient, unresolved.
"So the festival," he said.
"He gets weird about music. I mean actually weird. He'll leave the room if a song comes on at the store. One time I was practicing and he came in and just—stood there. In the doorway. And then he said, 'Not that one.'"
"Which one?"
"The song. I don't know. I was doing scales."
Gabe almost laughed and caught it. It wasn't funny. That was the thing. This kid was describing a man walking around his own house with his grief set to mute, and it came out sounding like a small anecdote about a father who didn't like the piano.
"What do you want to happen?" he asked her.
"I want to sing the solo at the festival. In front of everyone." She said it plainly. Not looking at him. "My mom would have wanted that."
Gabe thought about that for a moment before he answered, because it deserved a moment. The easy move was to say yes, tell her he'd fix it, promise her something he couldn't actually deliver. He'd done that before. He'd been good at it once.
"Here's what I'll do," he said. "I'll call your dad. Not to overrule him. To talk. And if he still says no, then the answer is no, and you'll keep coming to lunch and we'll keep working, and maybe next year."
"Next year."
"Yeah."
"That's what he said. About everything. That it would be better next year."
"I know." Gabe stood and straightened the music stand. "That's why I'm going to call."
Mayra stood too. She shrugged the backpack up onto both shoulders and looked at the cello, then at him.
"You don't have to tell him I came here," she said.
"I won't lie to him."
"I'm not asking you to lie. I'm asking you not to volunteer."
Gabe ran a hand over his jaw. He was going to have to be careful with this one. She was smart in the exact way that made adults forget she was twelve, and that wasn't her fault, but it was going to get someone hurt eventually, and he didn't want it to be her.
"Go home," he said. "It's getting dark."
"Six blocks."
"Six blocks is six blocks."
She paused with her hand on the door. "Mr. Whitaker."
"Yeah."
"Are you good? Like—not park-your-car-in-the-lot good. Like actually good. With the cello."
"I'm okay."
"No." She shook her head like he'd answered wrong on purpose. "You played that Bach thing like you were mad at it. Nobody's just okay that way."
Then she was gone, and the door swung shut, and the parking lot lights hummed.
Gabe sat back down. He picked up the cello. He didn't play the Prelude. He played the Allemande instead, the second movement, and he let the notes fall where they wanted to fall.
The kid was right. He was mad at it.
When he finished, he got out his phone and scrolled to the number he'd already saved under Reyes, Adam. He'd called it four times in the last two weeks. Three had gone to voicemail, and the fourth had been picked up by a woman who said, "Fire station, non-emergency, how can I help you," and he'd hung up before he worked out what to say to that.
He looked at the sign-up sheet on the wall. Four names. Room for twenty.
He set the phone face-down on the music stand, opened his email, and typed out a message he wouldn't send for another hour. He was still composing it in his head when the time he had left on the building ran out and the lights shut themselves off on their timer, leaving him alone in a dark room with the shape of a girl's question still hanging in it.
He'd call. Tomorrow. For real this time.
He picked one of the four names and wrote it on the sheet in pencil, light, so it could be erased if it needed to be, and then he went home.