The Second Chorus

Chapter 9: The Rehearsal

The community center's basement smelled like old carpet and radiator dust. Gabe had dragged four folding chairs into a ragged semicircle and set a music stand in front of each one. Mayra took the chair farthest from the door, backpack hugged against her chest, and watched the other two kids arrive like she was timing an exit.

"Cody, you're on the keyboard. Priya, percussion. Mayra—" Gabe tapped the third stand. "You're our voice."

"I thought there'd be more people," Cody said.

"Six weeks out, this is what we've got. We'll take it." Gabe handed out photocopied sheets. "Warm-ups first. Hum on the downbeat, don't push."

They hummed. Mayra's hum was there and gone, small and correct. When Gabe cut them off, she was already looking at the door.

"Okay. Page one. 'Rise Up.' Read the second verse before we go."

Cody stumbled through the chords. Priya kept a plodding four-count on the hand drum. And Mayra sang.

Gabe stopped breathing for a second. The kid had a natural instrument — clear, low, no wobble, and she landed on pitch like she'd been doing it her whole life. But her face stayed flat and her arms stayed folded and she sang the words like she was reading a bus schedule.

At the end Gabe let the last chord ring and said, "That was technically perfect."

Mayra shrugged.

"So let's try it again and make it wrong."

"What does that mean?"

"It means you hit every note and told me nothing." Gabe pulled his stool closer, sat down at her level. "Second verse. 'I've been down so long the ground feels like a friend.' What is that about?"

"It's about getting up."

"It's about how it feels *before* you get up. The down part. Do you know what that feels like?"

Mayra looked at him for the first time all afternoon, flat and unimpressed. "Yeah."

"Then sing it like you know."

He counted them in. This time, four bars in, Mayra's voice cracked open a little — she leaned into the word *ground* and her chin came up and she sounded twelve years old and tired instead of a machine that had been programmed. Gabe kept his eyes on the sheet music so he wouldn't spook her.

And then, on the bridge, her voice died.

She got through the phrase and just stopped, mouth open, no sound coming. Cody looked over, confused. Priya stopped drumming.

"You good?" Gabe said.

Mayra stood up, knocked her folder off the stand, and walked out.

Cody started to say something. Gabe shook his head. "Run the first verse. Both of you. I'll be right back."

He found her in the stairwell, sitting on the third step with her back flat against the wall and her knees up. She wasn't crying the way children cry. She was crying the way people cry when they don't want to be heard, which is worse.

Gabe didn't sit down. He leaned against the rail a few steps below her, which meant he had to look up at her, which he suspected she needed.

"Hey."

"I'm fine."

"Sure." He waited. The radiator ticked somewhere overhead. "You don't have to come back in. But I'd like to know what happened, so I don't do it twice."

Mayra wiped her face with the heel of her hand. "It's a stupid song."

"It is kind of a stupid song."

That got half a laugh out of her, which he hadn't expected. She wiped her face again. "I can't sing it."

"You were singing it fine. Then your body decided to be honest."

"I *can't*." She says it sharper, then quieter. "I can't sing the ones that—the ones she liked."

Gabe kept very still.

"My mom," Mayra said, and then stopped. Then, fast, like she was afraid she'd lose the permission: "She sang. She had, like, a *voice*, she sang at the church and at weddings and stuff, and she had an iPod and a keyboard and she would record herself and, like, sing over it, and there's a whole folder, and everybody thinks it's so nice and they want me to sing them and I can't. I can't do it. I open my mouth and it's not—it's not—" She pressed her palms against her eyes.

Gabe didn't say *I'm sorry for your loss.* He didn't say *she'd want you to.* He'd watched enough kids get handed the wrong sentence to know better.

"Okay," he said.

"That's it?"

"That's it." He picked up her folder off the floor below and set it on the step beside her, squared to the edge, the way she'd left it. "We won't do that song. It's not the right song for us anyway."

"But you already made the copies."

"I make too many copies. It's a personality flaw. Ask my landlord." He stood, careful of his shoulder, careful not to reach toward her. "Take five. Or fifteen. Or just go home — your dad's picking you up out front at five, so honestly bailing early is more of a negotiation than you think."

Mayra looked up at him. Her face was blotchy and her nose was running and she still looked like she was bracing for something.

"You're not gonna ask me about her."

"No." Gabe put his hands in his pockets. "Not today."

She nodded once, small, and put her hand on the folder and pulled it into her lap. Gabe went back through the door into the basement, where Cody and Priya were, in fact, running the first verse, which was more than he'd expected.

They finished out the hour on the chords and the drum part and a hum Mayra didn't rejoin. At ten to five Gabe sent both of them home with instructions to look at the second page and not practice it, which they agreed to with the enthusiasm of children who knew exactly what they were promising. Then he stood in the empty room with the folding chairs and the copy of "Rise Up," four sheets of it, unsung.

He took out his phone and opened a notes app. He spent a while trying to type something and then deleted it.

Five o'clock came. Through the narrow window over the stair landing he watched Adam's truck pull up and idle. Mayra was out in the hall already, backpack on, before Gabe had time to follow her up.

He found them at the open door. Adam had one hand on the frame and the other holding two coffees, and Mayra was talking, actually talking, telling him something Cody had done with his folding chair and how Priya's rhythm was, and Adam was listening the way a man listens when he didn't expect to hear his kid say more than three words all afternoon.

Gabe stood in the doorway and let them have it.

Then Mayra turned around. "Gabe. Do you have another copy of the song? The one with the words?"

"The sheet music? Yeah. I'll print one for Thursday." He looked past her to Adam. "If Thursday's happening."

"That's what we came about," Adam said, and his voice was flat and careful. "Listen—"

"You want to come in for a second," Gabe said, "it's warmer than the parking lot. There's coffee in the lounge. Kind of."

Adam hesitated. Mayra had already walked back in and was headed for the piano, which was progress. So Adam followed.

In the staff lounge Gabe poured what passed for coffee into two chipped mugs and set one in front of Adam at the little round table, and they sat across from each other in the silence of two men who had been rude to each other in public.

Then Adam saw the folder lying open on the end of the table. It was Gabe's, from rehearsal, and the top sheet was blank staves.

But the second sheet underneath it wasn't blank. Someone had left it out after a different session, weeks ago, and Gabe hadn't cleared it. Three staves, mostly keyboard with a vocal line, chords penciled in above. And a title, handwritten, in the header where the title goes.

*Second Chorus.*

Adam stopped moving with the mug halfway to his mouth.

He set it down. He didn't say anything. He didn't ask what it was or whose it was or when Gabe had written it. He looked at the page exactly as long as it takes to read two words, and then he looked back at Gabe, and just like that his face was closed.

"Thanks for the coffee," he said, and stood up, and called down the hall, "Mayra. Wheels up."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 9: The Rehearsal · The Second Chorus · Lumen Reads