The Selkie's Debt

Chapter 20: The Cave at Penn ar Bed

Plogoff in the rain was three streets and a church, the fields below it running to the sea in long gray folds. The bakery was the only thing open, and the woman behind the counter was older than the building, hands like knotted rope, and she looked at Ronan for a long time before she looked at Jules.

"Sit," she said. "You're the vet from Douarnenez. The Kerdraon one."

Jules sat. Ronan stayed standing by the door, water running off his coat, watching the street.

"My grandfather was Yann Kerdraon," Jules said.

She wiped the counter with the flat of her hand. "I know who you are. I knew him. That's not the same as forgiving him."

"I'm not asking you to."

"You're asking something." She poured two coffees he hadn't ordered and put one in front of him, and after a moment one in front of Ronan, who took it without sitting. "My husband fished out of Audierne forty years. He saw things in the water he never talked about. Yann Kerdraon came through here in the fifties and sixties with a boat and no fish, and men who asked why he had no fish stopped asking."

"Where did he go?"

"Penn ar Bed."

Ronan's hand stopped on the cup.

"There's a cave there," the woman said. "At the point, under the west face, past the black rocks. Near low water. You'd never find the door unless you were looking for a door. My husband was looking for abalone once and found it, and Yann Kerdraon was inside, and Yann Kerdraon told him if he ever spoke about it he'd regret it." She looked at Jules, level. "So you know what I'm doing, right now, saying it to you."

"Yes."

"He's dead. Doesn't matter. I've held it thirty years because he frightened my husband, and my husband's dead too, and I've decided that's enough." She set the pot down. "There was a chest in that cave. I don't know what was in it. I know it was on a chain."

Ronan set his cup on the counter, untouched, and walked out into the rain.

They went down from the road on a track the woman had drawn on the back of a receipt, and it took them an hour to lose it and an hour to find it again, and by the time they reached the rocks the tide was two hours from low and the spray was coming up white over the black shelf. The wind came in off the open Atlantic with nothing in front of it for three thousand miles, and Jules felt it in his teeth.

"There," Ronan said, and pointed.

Jules didn't see it. Then the water drew back, and the receding sheet peeled off a dark slit in the rock face, there and then gone, as if the cliff had an eyelid.

They waited. The sea drew back again, farther, and this time the slit was a mouth, low and black, with a wet slab leading into it. Jules went first because Ronan couldn't stop shaking, and Jules didn't say anything about it, which was the kindest thing he did all day.

The cave was bigger than the door. The floor was flat, scalloped black rock, dry past the first ten feet. The light from the mouth reached about halfway and then gave up. Jules took out his phone and turned on the torch and swept it across the walls.

Scratches.

Not natural. Long, straight, gouged into the soft stone on the left wall, three parallel, four parallel, at three different heights, one set low enough that a child kneeling could have made it. In a corner, a heap of old straw, rotted to gray-brown paste, and under it a coil of chain, rusted to lace, bolted into a ring set in the rock. The ring was iron and the bolt was iron and the wall around them was stained rust-orange for a foot in every direction.

Along the right wall, somebody had carved marks. Twenty-three of them, in four rows, cut with something sharp and patient.

Ronan walked past Jules to the ring. He crouched. He put one hand on the ring and didn't move for a while.

"How long ago?" Jules said.

"Not long."

"Ronan."

Ronan's voice came out flat and careful. "The rust takes years. That ring hasn't taken years."

Jules swept his torch across the floor. Shells, crab shells, the clean white bones of a gull. A plastic bottle. And by the wall where the marks were, half in the straw, something the torchlight turned brown and then, when he moved the beam, blue.

He picked it up.

A toy boat. Hand-carved, four inches long, with a paper sail glued to a matchstick mast, the sail gone to pulp and dried again into a stiff curl. On the hull, scratched in with the point of a nail: *MAËL*.

Ronan heard him stop.

He turned around and saw what Jules was holding, and his whole face did something Jules hadn't seen it do. It came apart. Not into tears, not at first. It came apart like a knot loosening, the thing that had been holding everything tight and still for weeks, and behind it there was nothing left that knew how to stand.

"He made that," Ronan said. "I taught him to make it — you hollow them with a hot nail, you seal the grain with candle wax, you put a knot on the sail so it can't blow off, you do it like this." His hands were doing the motions, in the air, without his permission. "He wouldn't let go of it. Not to eat. He slept with it."

He took the boat from Jules and held it, and that was when the weeping started, and it wasn't quiet. The cave pushed it back at them, over and over, and the sea pulled and pushed at the door and the noise of it swallowed him whole and he didn't care.

Jules put his hand on Ronan's back, between the shoulder blades. He didn't say it would be all right. He stood there and let the wind come in and put his hand on Ronan's back until the noise in the cave went quiet.

"There are marks on the wall," he said finally.

"I saw them."

"Twenty-three."

Ronan turned the boat over in his hands. The salt had gotten into the wood and split the grain, and he pressed the split closed with his thumb, like it might matter. "They keep him somewhere. They worked him, or they held him, or both, and they counted the days on the wall, and when he was done being useful they moved him. This place, they moved him out of it. Not years ago. Weeks."

"They used it as a pen," Jules said. "Yann hid a chest here. They inherited the cave the same way they inherited the house."

Ronan looked up at the ring in the rock, at the rust fan around it. "My father was in this room."

"Probably."

"My mother too, maybe. Before." He stood up. He tucked the boat into the inside pocket of his coat, against his chest, and buttoned it, and it was the single most deliberate movement Jules had ever watched a man make. "Where's the chest?"

They searched the cave for twenty minutes. There was no chest. The chain ran to the ring and nowhere else; there was no second channel in the floor, no ledge, no hollow. Whatever Yann had chained up here, someone had cut it free and taken it, and the rust on the ring where the chain had hung was fresher than the rust on the chain itself.

It had gone recently, too.

When they came out, the tide had turned. The water was already lipping at the slab, and they climbed up the black rocks fast, and by the time they reached the grass at the top of the cliff the cave mouth had closed like it had never been there at all.

Ronan stood with his back to the sea and the wind taking his hair sideways and his hand flat over the pocket with the boat in it.

"He's alive, Jules."

"I think so. Yes."

"You don't know that."

"No," Jules said. "I don't know it. But they're not collecting a corpse. They're holding him. That's what a hostage is." He took a breath; the wind took it. "And they sent us a bill. Bills mean they want to negotiate."

Ronan's jaw moved. "They want me."

"They want something from me first," Jules said. "Ronan. Look at me." He waited until Ronan did, and Ronan's eyes were red and wrecked and absolutely clear. "They've had him weeks. They've kept him alive for a reason, and it isn't mercy, and whatever it is, it means there's a moment coming when they have to put him in a room with somebody. That's the moment we get. Not before."

"You're asking me to be patient."

"I'm not asking. I'm telling you what's true, because you're the only person on this coast who knows how to find them, and if you go off the cliff at them alone I lose you too." Jules reached out and put his hand flat on Ronan's chest, over the boat, over the button. "I'm going to find him."

"Your grandfather put that ring in the wall."

"I know."

"You're the same blood."

"I know that too," Jules said, and didn't move his hand. "It doesn't change the mouth. It just changes who has to open it."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 20: The Cave at Penn ar Bed · The Selkie's Debt · Lumen Reads