The Speechwriter's Silence

Chapter 10: The Communications Director

Dale Kessler's office was the only one on the fourth floor with the blinds down, which Noah had learned meant someone was getting taken apart.

He knocked anyway.

"Get in here."

Noah stepped inside. Dale didn't offer him a chair. He was standing behind his desk in shirtsleeves with the cuffs buttoned, and he was holding a printout of Noah's draft, and he was holding it like it had bitten him.

"Read it to me," Dale said.

"I've read it."

"Read it to me."

Noah took the sheet. He didn't need it. He knew the sentences better than Dale did; he'd written them at two in the morning with the window open and Arthur's handwriting still on his hands. "The Whitmore family asks that the public respect the privacy of everyone involved. Personal lives are not campaign business. We will keep our focus where Senator Whitmore has always kept it—on the work."

Dale set his coffee down. Slowly. That was the tell; Noah had been here three weeks and had learned that a slow cup was worse than a slammed door.

"The Whitmore family," Dale repeated. "That's the problem. That's the whole problem right there. You've taken a rumor and you've given it a gallery."

"It's a non-denial."

"It's a *soft* non-denial. It's a non-denial with a velvet rope in front of it. You know what a soft non-denial says to a reporter? It says, *keep digging, fellas, there's something underneath this.*"

"Every statement this office has floated says something underneath it. That's what statements do."

"Don't." Dale came around the desk. Up close he smelled like the mint gum he chewed all day and never swallowed, and his eyes were the flat gray of a man who had run four Senate races and buried a federal judge's DUI in the middle of one of them. "Don't do the clever thing with me, Noah. I hired you because you do the clever thing with *them*. With me, you do the simple thing."

"I'm not being clever."

"You're being an artist. It's worse." Dale picked up a pen and clicked it twice, pointing it at the printout. "This line—'personal lives are not campaign business.' You write that, and the first call I get is from a producer who's already booked us a Sunday slot and now thinks we've opened the door. You've handed her a handle. She doesn't even have to turn it hard."

"That's not what it says."

"It's not what it says, it's what it *makes them ask*." Click. Click. "This is a hostile denial. We need a warm one. We need to make this about *him*, not about *us covering for him*. The kid is the only asset this campaign has that every voter already believes in."

Noah said nothing. He was aware of the floor, and the gap under the blinds, and the fact that Priya's desk was eight feet away on the other side of that wall and that Priya had not looked at him once since this morning.

"Here." Dale took the printout back, uncapped his pen, and wrote across the bottom margin in block capitals, then held it up.

*Arthur Whitmore remains focused on service, not speculation.*

Noah looked at the words for a second too long.

"Simple," Dale said. "Human. It moves the conversation off the women in the pictures—by the way, there are no women in that story that are going to hold up, so we're not even lying—and it moves it onto the one thing nobody in this city can touch."

Noah heard his own voice come out level. "Service."

"Serve the country, serve the state. Six years in the Army. Two deployments, the second one—you know the second one. Put him on a stage next to a bunch of guys in suits and *service* is the only word that matters." Dale's pen traced a little circle around the phrase. "You get him out in front of that idea and the story's dead in a week. Nobody stands up and asks a combat veteran to defend himself for something like this."

"Because it would look like an attack on the record."

"Because it would *be* one."

Noah felt something in his chest settle into cold. He'd spent a week with Arthur's record. He'd read the administrative discharge paperwork Arthur pulled up on his laptop and typed out his own summary of it, the neutral version, the version you hand to a scheduler. He'd heard Arthur explain the difference between what he did and what was done to him. And Dale was standing here—mint gum, gray eyes, a man who had never spent a night in a base hospital—calling it a shield, because that is what it was. A shield. Not for Arthur. *In front of* Arthur. Held up by the campaign so no one could see past it to the thing it was covering.

*Service, not speculation.* It sounded like it had been written by a machine trained on every campaign statement since 2004. Which was what he'd been: the machine.

"You don't like it," Dale said, watching him.

"I like it fine."

"You've got a face."

"I've got a face because I didn't write it." Noah shrugged. "That's all. It's the kind of line I'd have written in twenty seconds."

"Then write it in twenty seconds. Priya's got a version with the family line already in it. Take hers, add mine, and get it in the queue before the four o'clock call. I want it out today."

"Priya already flagged her version."

"Priya's paid to flag things." Dale was already back behind his desk, already scrolling. "You're paid to place them. That's the difference between the two of you, and it's why you're going to have a career, and I'm going to keep you on a leash until you do."

Noah took Priya's draft and a fresh coffee into the small conference room—the one with the window that faced the parking structure, which meant it was almost honest. He opened the document.

Priya's version was competent. It always was. She had kept two of his sentences and buried the third, and she had added a paragraph about the family, and nowhere in it was the word *service* or the word *speculation*, and he understood, looking at it, that Priya had likely kept the draft alive on purpose—that she had let it sit in her queue unapproved like a thing left out in the weather, so that when Dale eventually came for it, it would be a shape he could push against.

Or maybe she had simply not read it. He didn't know Priya well enough to know which.

He put the cursor at the bottom, after her closing. He typed Dale's line. *Arthur Whitmore remains focused on service, not speculation.*

Then he sat back and read the whole thing down top to bottom, the way he read anything before he sent it: as a voter. As a person. As somebody's mother in Sandusky, Ohio, glancing at her phone at a red light. There it was, the statement. There was the denial. There was Arthur, announced, defined, secured.

He thought about the debate answer Arthur had written out by hand in that windowless room, the one with the reserve component and the care-in-the-community line and the number Arthur had known from memory without looking it up. *For every dollar we claim to have put into veteran care, fifty cents arrives.* He thought about Arthur folding the paper and sliding it across the table, and saying: *this is what I'd say, if I got to say it.*

He thought about the other thing. The folder with the typo in the name, the oversight memo, the $340 million, the folder path saved in his phone in a note with no title. Then he thought about Danny Reyes, dead in Kandahar with his name on a framed photograph, and the fact that the campaign was about to put Arthur on a stage, hand him a piece of paper, and have him use his own dead friend's war as a partition.

Noah closed the document without sending it.

The four o'clock call came and went. At 4:12 his phone lit with a message from Dale: *Where is it?*

At 4:13, another: *Noah.*

He put the phone face down. Then he turned it back over and looked at the draft in the queue—his version, unapproved; Priya's version, unapproved; and under them the last line of the file history, which he had not noticed before, because Priya's name was on it and nobody was supposed to be able to add to it.

*Last modified 2 weeks ago by M. Bell.*

Noah stared at it. He opened the file history. There were three entries. Someone had pulled the veterans outreach section out of the drive two weeks ago, downloaded it to a folder named *VA-Outreach-Field*, and then the file had been reabsorbed into the campaign's master draft with its sourcing stripped.

He copied the entry into the tree at the bottom of his notebook, under the folder path and the number. Then he picked up his phone, ignored the two messages from Dale, and typed *Marcus Bell* on the line beneath.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 10: The Communications Director · The Speechwriter's Silence · Lumen Reads