The Speechwriter's Silence

Chapter 55: Danny's Family

The address in Silver Spring belonged to a block of identical brick duplexes, each with a struggling azalea and a mailbox on a tilted post. Arthur parked the sedan two houses down. He didn't move to get out.

"Noah." He kept both hands on the wheel. "She doesn't know I'm coming. I've been telling myself for four years that I'd do this."

"You don't have to do it today."

"I do, actually. Because I keep saying after the election, and after the election is a lie I've been telling myself since Anbar." He killed the engine. "Just—don't correct me. Whatever I say in there. If I get it wrong, let me get it wrong."

They walked up the path. Arthur rang the bell. The woman who answered was small and upright, sixty-odd, wearing a cardigan the exact color of a robin's egg. She looked at Arthur for a long moment without expression, and then she looked at Noah, and Noah understood immediately that she had known who Arthur was before she opened the door.

"Mrs. Reyes," Arthur said. "I'm—"

"I know who you are." She stepped back from the doorway. "Come in before the flies."

The living room was small and warm and crowded with photographs. Danny Reyes in Little League, gap-toothed. Danny Reyes in a dress uniform, badly lit, at some ceremony in a room with a beige wall. Danny Reyes holding a fish. The fish picture was the one that got you, because it was stupid and ordinary and there was no reason for it to be there except that a mother had liked it.

She gestured them onto a couch covered in a plastic slipcover, and Noah sat and tried not to make the plastic sound. She brought three glasses of ice water on a tray, no asking, and set them down and sat in the armchair facing them with her hands folded.

"You're the one writing the speeches," she said to Noah.

"Yes, ma'am."

"Which ones."

"All of them. Everything the senator says, the campaign puts it in front of me first."

"So the one where she said my son was a soldier who believed in this country." Her voice was flat. "You wrote that."

"I did."

She nodded slowly, like she was filing it. "The part about him wanting to serve. That part's true. He did want to serve. Since he was nine years old and he saw a jet at the airshow." She looked at Arthur. "The part about him dying to protect his squad. That part is also true. I'll give her that."

Arthur said nothing. His hands were flat on his thighs.

"But she never asked me." Mrs. Reyes picked up her glass and put it down without drinking. "Nobody from that campaign ever knocked on that door. I found out she was going to say his name when a neighbor called me, Thursday night, because she'd seen it on the news. The next day I watched a senator standing in front of a flag telling eleven hundred people what my son believed." She looked at Noah. "Did you know that?"

"No, ma'am. I didn't."

"Somebody did."

"Yes," Noah said. "Somebody did."

Arthur shifted. "Mrs. Reyes—"

"I'm not finished." She didn't raise her voice. "I don't mind a politician using my boy. That's the business, I understand that. Everybody uses everybody. What I mind is the shape it got bent into. He wasn't a symbol. He was twenty-four and he was scared half the time and he called me the night before and he said Mama, I don't want to be a lesson, I want to be a person."

Noah felt it land. He had written *he gave his life so that others might live theirs*. He remembered the line. He remembered hitting send at 2:14 a.m. and thinking it was good.

Arthur said, "I was there."

"I know."

"I was twelve meters behind him. Behind the wall." Arthur's jaw worked. "The campaign's version—the version my mother tells—is that he went back for two men under fire. And that's close. He did go back."

Mrs. Reyes watched him.

"But he went back because I told him to." Arthur said it evenly, like reading a number off a page. "We had a wounded man behind the second wall and the sector was hot and I gave the order. He went. He didn't volunteer. I ordered him, and he went, and he died doing what I told him to do, and then I came home and let a story get told about him that puts a better face on it than he ever got a chance to."

The plastic under Noah creaked. Nobody said anything for a while. Somewhere in the back of the house a television murmured through a wall.

Mrs. Reyes stood up. She went to the shelf and picked up the dress-uniform photograph and brought it back and held it out to Arthur, not as a gift—she didn't let go when he took the frame.

"You were his lieutenant," she said.

"Yes ma'am."

"He talked about you. He said the lieutenant don't eat till we eat."

"That's not true, actually."

"That's what he said." She let go of the frame. "You came here to tell me the truth about the worst thing in your life, and you flew a long way to do it, and I'll tell you what I think. I think he'd have wanted you to stop carrying it before he'd have wanted the credit." She sat back down. "You can't have both. Not in this house."

Arthur looked at the picture in his hands for a long time. Then he set it on the couch between himself and Noah, face up, and Noah looked at it too—the beige wall, the stiff collar, the kid who didn't want to be a lesson.

"I'm sorry," Arthur said. His voice broke on it. "For all of it. For the order and for the last four years and for letting them use him without asking you. That's the part I can't—Mrs. Reyes, the campaign used Danny's story without asking. I should have made them ask."

She nodded once.

"Are you going to make them stop?" she asked.

"I don't know yet."

"That's an honest answer." She reached for her water and actually drank this time. "Where's the speechwriter live?"

Noah said, "Columbia Heights."

"Long way from here." She stood. "You'll want to get back before the bridge traffic." And that was the visit, apparently over—she walked them to the door and stood on the step while Arthur and Noah went down the path, and when Noah looked back she was still standing there, holding the screen door with one hand.

They got into the car. Arthur didn't start it. He sat with his hands on the wheel and looked straight through the windshield at the identical brick duplex across the street.

"Nineteen days," he said.

"I know."

"This isn't closing the distance. I want to be clear. I told her the truth because she deserved it, not because it gets us anything."

"I know," Noah said.

Arthur started the engine. Then his phone, in the cupholder, lit up. He glanced down and Noah saw it before Arthur turned the screen away—not Harrow. The campaign. A group thread with three names on it and a line of text long enough to wrap.

Arthur looked at the message. He didn't react except to set the phone face-down on his thigh and pull out into the street.

At the light on Georgia Avenue he said, "They moved the debate."

"Moved it how?"

"Two days earlier. Thursday instead of Saturday." He watched the light. "And Dale wants me to answer the VA question straight from the script. The exact numbers. No deviation." He was quiet for a block. "My mother sent me the script personally. It's in the thread."

The light went green. Noah sat with the envelope full of pages in his head and the filing deadline in his head and the number nine in his head, and Arthur Whitmore beside him driving north with his phone face-down on his leg, and neither of them said the thing they were both doing arithmetic on.

"I'm dropping you at the Metro," Arthur said. "I meant what I said in the kitchen."

"I know you did."

At the curb outside the station Arthur didn't say goodbye. He said, "Thursday," like a date on a form, and pulled away.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 55: Danny's Family · The Speechwriter's Silence · Lumen Reads