The Speechwriter's Silence

Chapter 85: The Days After

The toothbrush happened on a Tuesday.

Not a ceremony. Not a conversation. Noah had spent the night — the third one that week — and in the morning Arthur was in the shower and Noah was standing at the double vanity in his bathroom with a travel toothbrush in his hand, the flimsy kind the hotel downstairs gave out for free, and he looked at the empty cup on the left side of the sink and put the toothbrush in it.

He went home at noon and did not think about it again until Thursday, when he came back and found the toothbrush still there. Arthur had not moved it. He had not asked about it. He had, at some point, rinsed it and set it upright so it would dry.

That was the whole negotiation. Noah understood it to mean yes.

The weeks after the benefit did not have a name. Noah kept waiting for a calendar to arrive — a debate schedule, a filing deadline, anything with his name in the corner and a countdown attached to it. Nothing came. The lawsuit sat in Richmond where it had always sat. The reporter called once more, and Noah did not answer, and then she stopped. The campaign's own spokespeople were busy with the bill, and the bill was busy with itself. Washington moved on to the next thing, as Washington does.

What Noah had instead was a Saturday.

Then another Saturday. Then a Wednesday that turned into a Saturday because neither of them bothered to leave.

"I want to be clear about something," Arthur said one night in the second week. They were in the kitchen. He was chopping an onion badly, and Noah was letting him, because it was instructive.

"Always a good start."

"I have no plan for this." Arthur set the knife down and turned. "I've spent thirty years with a plan for everything. Every room I walk into, I know the exit and the message. I do not have a plan for you." He looked almost apologetic. "I've decided that's acceptable."

Noah took the knife away from him and finished the onion himself. "You're holding it wrong."

"I'm aware."

"It's fine. I don't have a plan either." He scraped the onion into the pan. "I've never once done this without one, so I have no idea what I'm doing."

"That's not reassuring."

"Wasn't meant to be." He turned the burner on. "You want to hear something embarrassing?"

"Generally."

"I checked your schedule for the next two weeks," Noah said. "On the campaign system. Before I left. Out of habit. Then I sat there for a minute and realized I don't have any reason to know where you are anymore."

Arthur was quiet. Then he said, "And what did you do?"

"Closed the tab." Noah shrugged, stirred. "It's your schedule. If you want me to know something, you'll tell me."

The small things came out one at a time, the way they do when no one is extracting them. Arthur hated cilantro and had spent decades eating it without complaint because it made him look difficult to complain. Noah drank his coffee black. Arthur had assumed cream, sugar, some kind of elaborate order, because he had watched Noah order coffee for six months and never once looked past the cup. He found out on a Sunday morning when he set a mug down with milk already in it.

"You didn't ask," Arthur said.

"I didn't want to make it a thing."

"Ask next time."

"You didn't ask about the toothbrush," Noah said.

"I didn't have to." Arthur took the mug back and made him a new one, black. "It was obvious."

Dana texted once, three words: You okay? Noah wrote back: Better. She did not ask a follow-up. He understood that this was a gift and that she had filed it away somewhere and would use it later, and that he probably deserved it.

He called his mother on the second Sunday and told her he was seeing someone. He did not say who. His mother said, "Good," in a way that meant she was waiting for the rest, and he said he'd bring it up another time, and she let him. That was its own small, enormous mercy.

They had dinner with Marcus on the third Friday. An hour in, Marcus said to Arthur, "You're different. You've stopped performing."

"I didn't know I was."

"You always performed. Everyone in this town performs. You just did it better than the rest." Marcus turned to Noah. "What did you do to him?"

"Nothing," Noah said.

"He stopped planning," Arthur said. "Apparently it's reversible."

On the drive back, Arthur did not go home the way they usually went home. He took the long way up through the park, slow, past the closed gates and the dark trees.

"When the campaign calls," Noah said finally. Because it would call. It always called.

"It will," Arthur said. "And I don't know what I'll do."

"Okay."

"You're not going to ask me to choose."

"No," Noah said. "I'm not going to be that."

Arthur was quiet a while. The streetlights went over the windshield one at a time. "Camille called me Tuesday. She asked about you."

Noah felt his stomach drop, the old reflex, the flinch that used to come before every rehearsal. "What did you say?"

"I said you were the best writer I've ever worked with and that the campaign was lucky to have you." A pause. "She didn't ask anything after that."

"And if she had?"

"Then I would have decided when she asked." Arthur glanced over. "I've stopped answering questions that haven't been asked. You should try it."

Noah laughed, short and real. "That's the whole job I used to have. Answering questions before they're asked."

"Then you're between jobs," Arthur said.

The third week, Noah brought his own mug over. Arthur noticed and said nothing. The mug lived next to the toothbrush after that, which was as close to a lease as either of them was going to sign.

On Monday, Noah sat at Arthur's dining table with his laptop open and a draft on the screen, and it was a speech, and it was not for a candidate.

It was a statement. His own. A few hundred words that said he had been named in the committee report, that he had drafted the language in question while employed by the campaign, that the campaign had known and approved it, and that he was happy to cooperate with any inquiry. He had written three versions. Two were defensive. One was plain.

He read it four times. Then he closed the laptop.

Arthur came in from the kitchen with two coffees, black.

"What was that?" he asked.

"Nothing yet."

"That's not nothing." Arthur set the coffee down and sat across from him. "You're doing the thing where you write it before you say it."

"I always write it before I say it. That's the job."

"You're not on the job."

Noah looked at him for a second. Then he said, "You want to know why I was good at that job? Because I never had to say anything true. Every sentence I wrote was designed to survive a hostile read. And I was very, very good at it. And then I met you, and I started having to say true things, and I found out I didn't know how."

"You learned."

"Some." Noah turned the coffee cup around on the table. "I've been doing it for three weeks without a deadline and without a microphone and without a lawyer, and it's the longest I've been honest in about ten years, and honestly I keep expecting to get caught."

"Why would you get caught?" Arthur said. "You're not lying."

Noah laughed. "That's exactly what I mean. I don't have a script for this." He gestured at the apartment, the mug, the toothbrush one room away. "None of it. There's no version of me that knows how to do this, and I'm doing it anyway, and every day I think, well, this is the part where it falls apart."

Arthur drank his coffee. "And does it?"

"No," Noah said. "It keeps not falling apart."

They sat with that. The radiator ticked. Somewhere below, a car went by.

"This is the first time I have loved you without a script," Noah said.

Arthur set the cup down very carefully and looked at him, and for a moment he was the man in the ballroom doing the arithmetic of a room — and then he wasn't, and he was just himself, sitting in his own kitchen on a Monday.

"Same," he said.

The laptop sat closed between them.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.