The Term of Kinship

Chapter 11: The Brief

Nolan had the motion open on three screens and a legal pad that had stopped being useful around midnight. The drafting was the easy part. The hard part was writing a sentence that asked a court to disregard a test produced by the same company that had been threading itself through his life since Mira died.

He typed: *The Match Stability Index is not a diagnostic instrument. It is a proprietary score produced by an interested party, under undisclosed parameters, and offered here as though it were science.*

He read it back. It was true. It would also end his career.

At seven-forty, Diane came in with coffee she didn't offer him and stood behind his chair, reading over his shoulder the way she read everything — fast, and like she was looking for the lie.

"Kay v. Seton," she said. "You're citing a family court case from 2031 about a *kennel*."

"A custody dispute over a service animal. The court held that a proprietary temperament score couldn't override a documented care history." He turned. "It's the closest thing we have."

"It's the closest thing you have because nobody else has been stupid enough to file it." She set her cup down. "Do you know what happens when you attack the MSI in open court? Helix Well has four lawyers for every partner in this building. They will subpoena you. They will subpoena your firm's file, and then they will make an example of you, and every partner who ever put you on a matter will remember it."

"I'm not asking the firm to sign it. Just to file it."

Diane was quiet. "Marcus called me Thursday. He asked, very politely, whether you'd been under stress."

Nolan felt the floor tilt a fraction of an inch. "He called you about me."

"He called me about your *judgment*." She picked up her cup again. "I told him your judgment was fine. I'd like to keep being right." She nodded at the screen. "If you file that, you're making enemies, and they won't be mine. They'll be yours, and you'll be carrying them into a hearing where you need to look like a reasonable man."

"Are we still being retained?" Nolan asked. "The estate."

"The estate is being retained." Diane looked at him flatly. "The estate is not married to you."

She left. He saved the motion, checked the certificate of service twice, and at 9:14 clicked file.

The confirmation came back in fourteen seconds. By then he was already gathering his coat, and his hands, he noticed, were entirely steady.

The elevator was crowded and he was the last one in, nose almost to the panel. Someone behind him said his name.

Derek Vaughn was sixty and had made partner before Nolan had a law degree. He was holding a gym bag and looking at the button panel like it had insulted him.

"Congratulations on the motion," Vaughn said. "Somebody had it on their screen."

"Word travels."

"Word travels when it's a bad idea." The elevator dropped a floor. "You have a child at home now, I hear. Three years old? Four?"

"She's four."

"Mm." Vaughn shifted his bag. "I took two weeks when my daughter was born. Two weeks. I lost a client to a twenty-six-year-old who didn't take a single day. She's twenty-nine now and she runs a division of Nordic." He said it without heat, like a man reporting weather. "You want to file motions that make the firm nervous and go home at six to read bedtime stories, that's your business. But parental leave is for people who can afford it. The rest of us make choices."

The doors opened on the lobby. Vaughn stepped out, paused, and held the door with one hand.

"I'm not your enemy, Nolan. I'm telling you what the room says when you leave it." He let the door go.

Nolan stood in the lobby for a minute. Then he went out into the cold and walked the four blocks to the subway instead of taking a car, because he wanted to feel like he'd chosen something that day.

He got home at 6:20. The apartment had that hour-of-day smell, onions and something sweet, and Lila was on the floor of the living room with two wooden wolves and a cardboard box she'd decided was a den.

Vera's coat was on the hook. He could hear her in the kitchen, on a call, voice low and even.

"I don't care what the committee wants. I signed the recusal, and a recusal means I don't take the meeting." Pause. "Then tell him I'm unavailable. Yes. Thursday too." Pause. "Then tell him I'm unavailable Thursday, Priya."

The call ended. Nolan didn't mention it.

"The den is the apartment," Lila said, holding up the grey wolf. "This is the dad. He brings food and he is very good at sniffing."

"Very good at sniffing," Nolan agreed. He sat down on the rug, jacket still on. "And this one?"

"That's the baby." She put the small wolf inside the den. "Not a real baby. A wolf baby."

"Right. Wolf babies should be read to."

He pulled her onto the couch and she chose the book herself — a big floppy paperback, *The Wolf Who Went Home*, which had been Mira's, the spine cracked white down the middle. It was a bad book. The wolf spent eleven pages wandering and then found a family who were, it turned out, wolves, which Lila always accepted without argument and Nolan never had.

"Away from the pack, the wolf's ears went flat," he read. "He listened for a howl and heard only weather."

"Flat ears means scared," Lila said.

"Does it?"

"In the other one. The one with the drawing." She flipped ahead two pages to make sure he saw. "When his ears are flat he is scared, but he doesn't say it, because nobody asks."

Nolan stopped. She had a point, and she was four, and she had a point.

"Nobody asks the wolf," he said.

"Nobody asks him." She tapped the page. "Read."

He read to the end. By then her weight had gone heavy against his side and her breathing had evened out, and he carried her to her bed and stood in the doorway for a while with his hand on the frame.

Vera was at the kitchen table with her laptop open and the light off, working by screen glow. She didn't look up.

"Filed?" she said.

"You heard."

"You were on the phone with Diane at noon. The office is nine hundred square feet and I have ears."

He sat down across from her. "It'll be cited by the other side's counsel by Tuesday. Either the court strikes the score, or it doesn't — but it forces them to defend the methodology on the record, which means the batch log becomes relevant, which means Kevin becomes relevant."

Vera's hands stopped on the keys.

"That's the plan," she said.

"That's the plan."

She closed the laptop partway, and the room went dimmer. "Nolan. Diane told you it would cost you."

"She did."

"And you filed it anyway."

"I filed it anyway."

Vera looked at him for a long moment, and he could not read the expression at all — some combination of the way she looked at a deal she didn't trust and the way she looked at Lila across a room. She opened the laptop back up.

"Kevin's shift ends at eleven," she said. "His text came through while you were reading. He'll meet us in the lot on Borden Avenue, but he wants something first."

"What does he want?"

Vera turned the screen toward him. It was a photo of a page, poorly lit, taken on a phone in what looked like a break room — a spreadsheet with headers, and a column of dates. Nolan leaned in.

"October third, October third, October third," Vera said softly, running her finger down the screen. "Three intake rows stamped that morning. But look at the batch column."

He looked. He looked for a long time.

"Vera," he said. "There's no batch column."

"There is." Her voice had gone very flat. "It's under the third october row. See the row that's been blacked out in the source?"

He saw it. A single row, the fourth on the page, redacted in the file but visible in the phone's photo of the folder behind it — a batch number, and beside it, an operator ID he didn't recognize, and a chain-of-custody stamp reading **Oct 1**.

"That's not our sample," he said.

"No."

"That's a different sample, processed two days early, in the same batch range as ours."

"Same instrument. Same operator." Vera closed the laptop the rest of the way and the room went dark except for the streetlight. "Which means someone can put a sample through Helix Well's pipeline before intake, which means our October first stamp isn't an error. It's a method."

Nolan sat back. In the other room Lila shifted in her sleep, and the floorboards of the old apartment clicked once, the way they always did, and neither of them said anything for a while.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 11: The Brief · The Term of Kinship · Lumen Reads