The Term of Kinship

Chapter 14: The Cousin

Cecilia called at seven in the morning, which meant it wasn't a social call.

"Vera. I'm sending someone to help."

"I don't need—"

"It's my nephew. Mateo. He's at Fordham Law, third year, he's been working on a note about assisted-reproduction contracts since last spring. He knows the match-test cases better than half the attorneys I interview." A pause. "Nolan's motion is good, but he's arguing in the dark. Mateo can hand him a flashlight."

Vera stood at the kitchen window with her coffee going cold. Across the courtyard, a nanny was walking three children in a train formation toward the bus. "I don't like strangers in the house."

"He's not a stranger, he's my sister's boy. And this is not about the house, it's about the case. Let him meet Nolan. If you don't like him, you can throw him out."

That was the thing about Cecilia: she never let you say no to something you might say yes to an hour later.

Mateo arrived at nine, which was when Vera was leaving, so she saw him for exactly ninety seconds in the doorway. Mid-twenties, close-shaven, a black backpack worn high and tight on both shoulders, and the polite, weight-forward posture of a man who has been taught to make a good impression on people with money.

"Ms. Chen." He shook her hand. His palm was dry and his grip was calibrated. "Thank you for having me."

"I didn't invite you," Vera said. "Nolan did. Talk to him."

She took the elevator down and spent the whole ride thinking about how his eyes had moved across the apartment — the good lamp, the Bierstadt print, the tablet open on the counter — the way a person inventories a room.

Nolan found the three cases by two in the afternoon. Mateo found them faster.

They worked at the dining table, which annoyed Vera when she came home at six and found her mail pushed into a stack, a legal pad and two laptops occupying the space where she normally opened her laptop and sat with the view. Mateo had taken the chair facing the door. Nolan sat sideways, one knee up, sleeves rolled.

"Say it again," Nolan said.

"There's a category of case nobody cites," Mateo said, tapping the screen. "Low match under the statutory floor, biological parent petitions to vacate, court finds the methodology wasn't validated against a representative cohort. *In re Alvarado*, 2019, Southern District. *Petition of Kwan*, 2021, Eastern. And *Childs*, 2023, Appellate Division. All three, the match score came in under forty percent. All three, the court ordered the guardianship restored."

"Under what standard?"

"That's the interesting part. Not — the statute says the test is presumptive, right, so you'd expect them to fight on the science. They didn't. The challenged parties conceded methodology in all three and stipulated to a re-test. And every one of them is sealed."

Nolan straightened. "All three?"

"Every opinion. Sealed docket, sealed record, no published analysis. I found them through a citation in a *Harvard* note — the note cites *Alvarado* for a footnote, and the footnote says the file's closed, so I went to the clerk's office." Mateo shrugged. "It took four days. I had to file as a student researcher with a supervising attorney. I named you."

Nolan laughed, short and surprised. "You named me."

"You filed a motion two days ago. It's public. It made it easy."

Vera set her bag down and stayed standing. "Why would a court seal a case about a match score?"

"Because the numbers are the product," Mateo said, without looking up. "If *Alvarado* publishes, someone can reverse-engineer the threshold. Helix Well's whole position is that the methodology is proprietary and its results are dispositive. A published opinion saying a forty percent match was overturned is a road map."

"So someone paid to close them," Vera said.

Mateo finally looked at her. He had a pleasant face and it went carefully blank. "I don't know that. I know they're closed."

They ate dinner standing in the kitchen, takeout containers open on the counter. Lila was at the table with her crayons, filling in a house with a red roof, and every few minutes she looked up to check that all three adults were still there.

"Three cases," Nolan said. "That's a pattern."

"Three cases is three cases," Vera said. "It's not a pattern until you know who sealed them and why."

"Priya can run the docket numbers."

"Priya can't run anything without it landing in the fund's system." Vera picked at the edge of a carton. "Not yet."

Mateo had been quiet through dinner, eating methodically, answering Lila's questions (what's your favorite color, do you have a dog, why do you type so fast) with the patient good humor of someone who'd been raised around children. He washed his hands, and when he came back he said, "There's one more thing."

Nolan looked up.

"*Childs* isn't fully sealed. The order is sealed, the record is sealed, but the docket still lists the parties. I can pull the index tomorrow. If there's a superseding petition, or a fee application, or anything from the guardian ad litem, it might tell us who the respondent was." He paused. "If it's Helix Well, we should know before your motion gets heard."

"It's Helix Well," Nolan said.

"We don't know that."

"I know it."

"Then you don't need me to pull the index." Mateo smiled, small and mild. "But I'll pull it anyway."

Vera watched him across the counter. The eagerness was real, that was what unsettled her. She knew what eagerness cost and who paid for it. She had been twenty-five once, and she had walked into a room where people were deciding things about her and made herself useful, and she had learned that usefulness is a kind of leash.

"Cecilia says you're writing a note."

"Yes."

"On what?"

"On the enforceability of match-test clauses in gestational agreements. The argument is that the clause is being used as a substitute for an evidentiary standard the legislature never authorized." His voice was even. "It's a good argument. It's been a good argument for about seven years and nobody's made it stick."

"Why not?"

"Because the people it happens to don't have the money to appeal, and the people who have money don't want to be the face of a match score of thirty-one percent." He glanced at Nolan, quick. "No offense."

"None taken," Nolan said.

Vera took her coffee to the window. Down on the street, a delivery bike threaded between a cab and a bus. She thought about the sealed cases, and the redacted fourth row in Kevin's photograph, and the October 1 stamp on a form dated October 3, and she thought that all of it was a machine with a lot of hands on it, and she had just let a fifth hand into her kitchen.

"Mateo."

"Yes, ma'am."

"Who's paying for your note?"

The room went quiet. Nolan's pen stopped.

"The law review," Mateo said.

"Law reviews don't pay. Who's paying for the four days at the clerk's office."

"I'm a research assistant for Professor Bhattacharya. She funds it out of her discretionary account."

"Bhattacharya consults for Delgardo, Rice." Vera set the cup down. "They represent Hokkaido Bio. Which is Helix Well's largest licensee."

Mateo held her gaze for a full second, and then he did something Vera respected and distrusted in equal measure: he didn't flinch, and he didn't explain.

"Professor Bhattacharya funds a lot of student work," he said. "Including mine. That's a fact about her, not about me. I can leave, if you want me to leave. But the index is the only lead either of you has that doesn't come from someone who already lied to you."

It took Nolan three seconds to say, "Don't leave."

Vera said nothing. Which meant it stood.

He spread the printouts on the kitchen table at ten-forty, the index, the citation trail, the two-page note of the clerk's phone log, and he put his phone in the middle of it all, screen up, on the table where the light was best. Lila had been in bed for an hour. The apartment was at the hour when the city quiets, and the only sound was the rain starting on the terrace glass.

"This," Mateo said, tapping the second page. "Index line fourteen. The guardian ad litem in *Childs* filed an ex parte application for a re-test. It was granted. And the retest came back at fifty-eight percent."

Nolan leaned in. "Where's the application."

"Sealed. But the grant is on the docket, and the retest result is referenced in the fee application, which is also sealed, except the clerk let me photograph the index, because the index isn't the record." Mateo picked up his phone. "I'll send you both copies."

He angled the phone over the printed page, and the shutter clicked, once, twice, three times, and Vera — standing at the end of the table with her arms crossed, watching the small bright rectangle of his screen travel slowly down the last page — understood that whatever was on that paper had just left her house in a form she couldn't un-send if she wanted to.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 14: The Cousin · The Term of Kinship · Lumen Reads