The Term of Kinship

Chapter 20: The Motion Hearing

The clerk called the case at 9:14, and Judge Aliya Brennan took the bench with the expression of a woman who had already read everything and been unimpressed by most of it.

"Ferro *v.* State Health Authority, motion to exclude." She didn't look up. "Mr. Okonkwo."

Nolan stood. He had slept badly and it didn't show, which was its own kind of practice. Vera sat two rows back in a gray suit, hands folded, the only person in the gallery who wasn't a law student or a lookie-loo. She had told him she would come. He had told her she didn't have to.

"The match test is the sole basis for the bond petition," Nolan said. "The state certified it under a statute that requires documented methodology. Harborline Diagnostics has never produced that documentation to any party in this proceeding. Not to us. Not to the court. We're asking the court to exclude the result until it does."

"You're asking me to exclude a certified state record on a documentary gap," Brennan said.

"I'm asking you to treat it like what it is. A number with no arithmetic behind it."

Brennan's pen moved. "Counsel, the state's position is that the certification is presumptively valid."

"The certification says the methodology exists. It doesn't say what it is." Nolan kept his voice level. "Your Honor, we can't cross-examine a conclusion. There's a reason the statute requires the record."

The state's attorney, a young woman named Parks who had the tired patience of someone who did this forty times a year, stood and said the methodology was proprietary, that disclosure would expose Harborline to competitive harm, and that a confidential submission under seal would satisfy any legitimate need.

"Then submit it under seal," Nolan said.

Parks hesitated half a beat. That was the tell. Vera saw it too; he could feel her seeing it, the particular stillness she got when a counterparty flinched.

"May I be heard on the practical question," Brennan said, and turned to Nolan. "You're also the guardian of record in the related bond matter."

"I am."

"And the child's alpha of record is Ms. Chen."

"By provisional designation."

Brennan looked at the gallery then, the way judges do when they've been handed a name they recognize. Vera didn't move.

"Granted in part," Brennan said. "Motion to exclude is denied at this stage. Limited discovery is granted: the petitioner's counsel may propound interrogatories and document requests to Harborline Diagnostics and to any successor entity, confined to the match protocol, sample handling, and chain of custody for the subject test. Responses under seal." She wrote as she spoke. "Fourteen days. If Harborline doesn't answer, I'll reconsider exclusion myself, and I won't need your motion."

Parks was already shaking her head at her file.

"And," Brennan added, "if the statutory authority that certified the test is a party in interest, it can explain to me why it certified a record it can't describe. Adjourned."

The gavel was barely down before Nolan turned. Cecilia was standing in the third row on the far side, arms crossed, watching Vera rather than him — the long, level look of a woman filing something away.

"Counselor," Cecilia said, passing him. "Fourteen days is a courtesy."

"From the court or from you?"

But she was already gone, heels ticking out the double doors, and she hadn't answered.

On the courthouse steps the light was flat and white, the kind of November noon that makes everyone look vaguely accused. Nolan was putting his phone away when the man fell into step beside him — early thirties, canvas jacket, a recorder in his hand that he wasn't hiding.

"Nolan Okonkwo?"

"Yes."

"Sam Idris, City Ledger. Can I ask you two questions about today?"

"One."

"Is it true the petitioner's guardianship rests on a match test your own motion called unscientific?"

"My motion called it undocumented. Those are different words. The court agreed enough to order discovery."

Idris nodded, wrote nothing. "Second question's for your co-guardian, actually." He turned, unhurried, to Vera. "Ms. Chen. Juniper Lane is a limited partner in the fund that holds a stake in Helix Well, which is Harborline's former parent. You're in court trying to invalidate a test run by a company your own fund profits from. Do you have a comment?"

There was a short silence. A woman on the sidewalk glanced over. Nolan felt the question land in his chest like a dropped plate.

"No comment," Vera said, evenly, and kept walking.

Idris didn't chase. He hadn't needed to. He'd gotten everything he came for, which was the picture: her, and Nolan, and the space between them.

They walked two blocks without speaking. Vera's car was idling at the hydrant on Centre, Deon's man at the wheel, the engine running for the heat. Nolan stopped at the passenger door and didn't open it. She turned, and looked up at him, which she almost never did, and he understood she knew exactly what was happening and had decided not to preempt it. She was going to make him ask.

"A stake," he said.

"Yes."

"In the fund. Junior Lane —"

"Juniper Lane. It's a co-investment vehicle. I'm a limited partner. I signed the line item two years before anyone at Harborline knew who I was."

"Two years before the test. That's the defense." He heard his own voice go flat. "You've had it ready."

"I've had it ready since the day the petition was served." Vera's breath fogged. "Elias is on the board of the manager. He's also the reason this started, or near enough. If I go public —"

"I heard what you said at the gala."

"Then you know what I'm weighing." She looked at the car, then back at him. "You told me last night the fear was the only honest thing between us. This is the part I've been afraid of. Not the court. This."

"Because I'd find out?"

"Because you'd find out from him." She nodded her chin up the block, where Idris was still on the corner, phone to his ear. "And now you have."

Nolan put his hand on the roof of the car. Cold metal under his palm. He thought about the seizure ward, about signing the record, about standing at a window with this woman and believing for a few minutes that they were on the same side of something.

"Fourteen days," he said. "Harborline has to answer."

"They won't answer honestly."

"No. But if they answer at all, they answer under seal to a court, and someone at that company has to decide whether lying to a federal judge is worth it. That's Priya's whole problem, isn't it? She won't testify because her brother's in a study. They're using people as collateral."

Vera's jaw tightened. "You think I don't know that."

"I think you've been holding three of the cards and showing me one." He opened the door for her because it was cold and because he was still, despite everything, that person. "Go to your meetings. I'll draft the interrogatories tonight."

"You'll send them to me before they go out?"

"No," Nolan said. "Not this time."

She got in. The window came down an inch.

"Sam Idris called you before he ever called me," she said. "He got your name off the motion. Which means he's reading the docket, which means he's already halfway to everything we're afraid of. Be careful what you tell a reporter, counselor."

"Be careful what you sign," Nolan said.

The window went up. The car pulled out and was gone in the crush at the light, and he stood on the corner a moment longer than he needed to, and then took out his phone and answered the number that had been buzzing against his leg for the last ten minutes.

"Okonkwo."

"Mr. Okonkwo." A man's voice, careful. Behind it, a television somewhere, a kid. "This is the Ledger. Sam Idris. You got a minute? Because there's a piece of this you don't have, and I'd rather you hear it from me than read it."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 20: The Motion Hearing · The Term of Kinship · Lumen Reads