The Term of Kinship

Chapter 32: The Ethics Board

The hearing room was on the fourth floor of the state bar building, a windowless space with fluorescent light that made everyone look pre-ill. Nolan had been in it once before, for a pro bono matter, and he remembered thinking the chairs were designed for discomfort. He had not been wrong.

He sat alone at the respondent's table. Vera was not permitted to attend; the committee had made that clear when they'd denied his request for a continuance. Two rows behind him, a woman from his firm's general counsel's office took notes on a legal pad. She had introduced herself in the hallway as Marisol and had said, almost apologetically, that she was there to observe, not to represent.

The forged insurance form sat in a plastic sleeve on the committee's table. Someone had mailed it in a manila envelope with no return address, postmarked from a sorting facility in Newark. The intake clerk had logged it at 7:14 Monday morning, which meant whoever sent it had known the bar's intake schedule down to the hour.

"Mr. Reyes." The chair of the ethics committee was a Beta woman in her sixties named Doreen Falk, with reading glasses on a beaded chain and a voice like a metronome. "You've reviewed the document."

"I have."

"And you recognize the signature."

"It's mine."

"It is not." Falk slid a second copy toward him. "Your signature appears on the second page of the guardianship trust authorization. This form bears your name at the bottom, but the notary stamp is from a commission that expired in 2029, and the date of execution is listed as March 3rd of this year. On March 3rd, you were in Albany for a continuing education seminar. We have your attendance records."

Nolan said nothing.

"The form authorizes the transfer of forty thousand dollars from a discretionary fund into a guardianship trust for one Lila Marsh. Ms. Chen's fund, if our records are correct."

"They are."

"So you signed a form you didn't sign, on a date you weren't in the city, using a notary who no longer holds a commission."

"I didn't sign it."

"Then who did?"

He looked at the form. He had known this moment was coming since the night he found it in his briefcase, since he had slid it back between the folders and not said a word, since he had gone home and cooked eggs and let Vera fall asleep against his shoulder. He had known, and he had thought he would know what to do when it arrived.

"I can't answer that."

"You can't, or you won't?"

"I won't."

Falk set her glasses down. The two other committee members, a young Alpha from Buffalo and a retired judge from Long Island, exchanged a look that Nolan did not need to translate.

"Mr. Reyes, the committee's purpose here is not to punish you. It's to determine whether a member of the bar created a fraudulent document to facilitate a guardianship transfer. If you are not the person who created it, you are the person best positioned to identify who did."

"I understand that."

"Then help us."

"I can't."

"Can't or won't."

"Won't."

Falk wrote something on her pad. The retired judge leaned forward. "Mr. Reyes, I want to make sure you understand the stakes. This committee has the authority to suspend your license pending a full investigation. That suspension can last six months, a year, longer. You have a guardianship petition before the family court. You have a child who—" He paused, consulting his notes. "A child who was placed in your and Ms. Chen's care following the death of her parents. Are you aware of what a suspension would mean for that petition?"

"I'm aware."

"And you're choosing not to answer."

"I'm choosing not to speculate about a document I didn't create. If you want to know who did, you should ask the person who mailed it. Whoever they are, they had my signature from somewhere. They had my name. They knew the trust structure. They knew the amount. That's not gossip. That's access."

"Are you suggesting someone in Ms. Chen's firm?"

"I'm suggesting someone with access to documents they shouldn't have."

The Alpha from Buffalo made a note. Falk put her glasses back on.

"The committee will take a fifteen-minute recess," she said. "When we return, Mr. Reyes, we'll ask you one final time. If your answer is the same, we'll proceed to a vote on suspension."

The hallway smelled like burnt coffee and carpet cleaner. Nolan stood by the window with his hands in his pockets until Marisol came out and stood beside him, not looking at him.

"You handled that about as well as you could have," she said.

"I didn't handle it."

"You didn't name her. That's what the firm was worried about. Whitcomb thought you'd fold under pressure and point at Chen to save yourself."

"He was wrong."

"He was. For what it's worth." She checked her phone. "They're ready."

The vote took four minutes. Falk read the decision in a flat voice: license suspended pending investigation, effective immediately, reinstatement contingent on full cooperation with the committee's inquiry and the resolution of any related civil or criminal proceedings. Nolan listened. He signed the acknowledgment. He took his copy of the order and folded it and put it in his pocket.

In the elevator, Marisol said, "Do you have counsel?"

"No."

"You should get some."

"I know."

"Mr. Reyes." She stopped the doors before they opened. "Whoever did this wanted you off the petition. You understand that, don't you? They didn't want you suspended. They wanted you disqualified."

"I understand."

"Then maybe you should think about who benefits."

The doors opened. He walked out into the lobby and through the revolving door onto the street, where the sun was out and the traffic was loud and nothing had changed except everything.

Lila was at the kitchen table when he got home, working on a drawing that appeared to be a horse with too many legs. She looked up when the door opened and then went back to her horse.

"You're early," she said.

"I am."

"Is Vera coming home early too?"

"No. Just me."

He made her a snack, apple slices and peanut butter, and sat down across from her. The horse had nine legs. He decided not to mention it.

"Lila, I want to tell you something."

She put her pencil down. She was eight, and she had already learned that when adults wanted to tell you something, it was usually bad, and she had gotten very good at preparing her face for it.

"I'm not going to be working for a while," Nolan said. "So I'm going to be around more. I can pick you up from school. I can take you to the park after. I can help with your homework."

Lila looked at him for a long moment. Then she said, "Does that mean you lost your job?"

He should have had an answer ready. He had drafted one in the hallway, then in the elevator, then in the taxi, and none of them had survived contact with her face.

"It means my job is on pause," he said.

"That's what losing is," Lila said. "When they say pause but they mean you're not coming back."

"Who told you that?"

"Nobody. I'm eight, not stupid."

Nolan put his hands flat on the table. The apple slices were already browning at the edges.

"You're right," he said. "It's a kind of losing. But it's not the kind that matters. The kind that matters is when you lose something you actually wanted. And what I wanted was to stay with you. That's not paused."

Lila picked up her pencil and drew a tenth leg on the horse.

"Vera's going to be mad," she said.

"Vera's going to be fine."

"Vera's going to be mad at whoever did it."

Nolan didn't answer that. Lila drew an eleventh leg.

"Are you going to tell her?" she asked.

"Probably."

"Good." She held up the drawing. "It's a spider now."

At 9:40 that night, his phone buzzed. A number he didn't recognize, no message, just a photo. He opened it.

It was the ethics committee's decision order, photographed on a desk somewhere, with a sticky note attached in handwriting he didn't recognize. The note said: *Next time, name her.*

He stared at it for a long time. Then he screenshot it and sent it to Vera.

Three seconds later his phone rang.

"Don't touch anything," Vera said. "I'm coming home."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 32: The Ethics Board · The Term of Kinship · Lumen Reads