The Term of Kinship

Chapter 42: The Bar Hearing

The disciplinary committee room at the First Department was smaller than Nolan remembered from his first appearance, and colder. Four lawyers sat behind a folding table, three of them Alpha, one Beta. The chair was a woman named Ostrowski who had spent twenty years prosecuting attorney misconduct and had the voice of someone who had stopped being surprised.

"You may continue," Ostrowski said.

Nolan had been speaking for eleven minutes. He had prepared a statement. He abandoned it somewhere around the third paragraph and had been answering questions since.

"You are listed as counsel of record on the April 14 guardianship filing," said Ruiz, the Beta on the panel. "The signature page of the amended operating agreement bears your notary stamp. Did you notarize that document?"

"No."

"You notarized a document you did not witness?"

"I notarized nothing," Nolan said. "I applied the stamp after the fact, because my client told me the signatory had signed earlier and that I'd missed the appointment."

"So you falsified a notarial attestation."

"Yes."

Ostrowski made a note. Ruiz kept going.

"Why?"

"Because I believed the client. Because she was dying and I wanted to help her daughter. Because it was a Thursday and I had thirty seconds to decide whether to ask a question or sign a page, and I signed the page."

"You've had a lot of time to characterize it since," Ostrowski said. "Eleven months."

"Yes."

"You didn't come forward."

"I didn't know it was forged until this year."

"But you knew you hadn't witnessed it. From the first day."

Nolan put both hands flat on the table. "Yes."

The room's HVAC clicked off. In the silence Nolan could hear a phone buzzing in someone's bag.

"Mr. Reyes." Ostrowski folded her hands. "You've told us that Dr. Aris Thorne of Helix Well contacted you in March. What did he say?"

"He said that if I cooperated on the guardianship, the company would be generous. He said that if I didn't, he'd make sure the bar association heard about the notary stamp."

"And you believed him."

"I believed he could. He had the page number."

"Did you report the threat?"

"No."

"Why not?"

"Because reporting it meant admitting the thing he was threatening me about."

Ostrowski wrote another line. Nolan watched her write it. He had the sudden, specific sensation of being folded into a smaller and smaller box, and of being relieved, which was worse.

"Is that all?" she said.

"That's all."

"Then we'll hear from Ms. Chen."

Vera came in through the side door. She was wearing the gray suit she wore to board meetings where she expected to lose, and she carried no notes. She sat in the chair and folded her hands the way she did when she was about to take apart a company's revenue model.

"State your name and occupation."

"Vera Chen. Managing partner at Kestrel Ventures."

"Your relationship to Mr. Reyes."

"He's the co-guardian of my ward. My partner in the guardianship. And my — " She stopped. Started again. "He's my partner."

Ostrowski's pen paused. "Define partner for the record."

"I'm an Alpha. He's an Omega. We're in a co-parenting arrangement for a child neither of us is biologically related to. It's not a romantic relationship. It is a household."

"Thank you. You may testify to character."

"Then I'll testify to character." Vera looked at Nolan, not at the panel. "He's the most honest man I've ever worked with, and he just spent forty minutes telling you the worst thing he's ever done. I've sat through four hundred diligence meetings, and I can tell you what an honest person looks like under pressure. It looks like that."

"Ms. Chen, that's an opinion."

"It's an opinion I've earned."

"Do you have anything else?"

"Yes." Vera turned back to the panel. "You should know that I have a conflict of interest in this proceeding, and I'd like it on the record before you weigh anything I say."

Ostrowski set down the pen.

"Kestrel Ventures holds four point two percent of Helix Well Series C preferred. I sat on the board that approved the round. I did not know, at the time of the investment, that the company was running an unregistered differentiation study or that its executives were pressuring my ward's mother. I found out in February. I've been an investor in the company that's been trying to take Lila away from us since before Lila could walk."

Ruiz leaned forward. "Are you still an investor?"

"My fund is. I've recused myself from the position and filed an internal notice. I can't unwind the shares retroactively. I came here voluntarily to say this, because if you're going to give any weight to my character testimony, you're entitled to know what my fingerprint is on."

The four of them exchanged a look that Nolan had seen before, in courtrooms, in conference rooms, in the hallway outside his mother's bedroom. It was the look people gave each other when a problem had just become bigger than the person who brought it.

Ostrowski said, "The committee will note the disclosure. We'll take the matter under advisement. We have a threshold question about whether to consolidate the notarial issue with the pending inquiry into the guardianship matter, and we'd want the referee's report before we decide. Decision postponed."

"How long?" Nolan asked.

"Two weeks at the outside."

Outside, in the hallway, the reporters were waiting three deep against the pillars. One of them — a stringer for a legal blog, in a coat too big for her — got a recorder in front of Nolan's chest before he could step around her.

"Mr. Reyes — do you regret the forgery?"

He could have ducked it. He knew how. He had ducked questions for a living.

"I regret that I didn't ask for help," he said. "That's the part I'd do differently."

"Are you resigning your license?"

"That's the committee's decision."

"Ms. Chen —" Someone had spotted Vera behind him. "Is it true your fund owns part of the company investigating you?"

Vera stopped walking. She turned, and she put her hand flat on Nolan's back, which was a thing she did when she was about to say something she'd already decided to say.

"It's true," she said. "I'll answer any question about it you want in writing. Send it to my office."

She steered him down the corridor and out the side entrance onto Church Street, where the wind came off the river and the light was already going. They walked two blocks without speaking.

"Two weeks," Nolan said finally.

"Two weeks."

"Ferraro's hearing is Thursday."

"I know."

"So we lose Thursday, we lose the interim recommendation, and if my license is suspended —" He stopped at the corner. A delivery cyclist swerved around them. "If I'm suspended, I can't practice in the guardianship. I'm not counsel. I'm a witness, or I'm nothing."

"You're not nothing."

"I'm not counsel." He looked at the crosswalk signal. "Vera, the letter. Mira's letter."

"What about it."

"Frost has a copy. If the committee suspends me, the letter stops being a lawyer's document and becomes evidence. A reporter asked me today if I regret the forgery. Tomorrow a reporter asks whether the Alpha fund partner doctored the guardianship papers to keep a baby. That's the story. That's the story unless we get ahead of it."

Vera was quiet. The signal changed and neither of them moved.

"I want to publish it," Nolan said. "Not to Frost. To the Times. With the contact log, the page nine comparison, and my own misconduct in the same document. Everything. All of it, first, before they can shape it."

"That's the record," Vera said. "You're talking about burning the case to save it."

"I'm talking about choosing who writes it."

She looked at him for a long moment. Then she took out her phone, and she did not open her email. She just held it.

"Okpara will say no," she said.

"Okpara will say no."

"Frost will say worse."

"You're damn right he will."

The wind came up off the river. Somewhere behind them, in the corridor they'd left, a reporter was already filing the piece she was going to write.

"All right," Vera said. "Call her."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 42: The Bar Hearing · The Term of Kinship · Lumen Reads