The Term of Kinship

Chapter 59: After the Choice

The gallery was three rows deep by nine-forty. Diane took the counsel table alone, her laptop squared to the bench, a legal pad with handwriting so small Vera couldn't read it from the second row where she sat with her hands folded. She had worn gray. It was the closest thing to armor the courtroom permitted.

Judge Halloran came in at nine-fifty-two, earlier than posted. She had the file open before she sat.

"Ms. Okafor. I expected two counsel."

"Mr. Reyes is at the Attorney General's deposition, Your Honor. I'm instructed to proceed alone."

"Instructed by whom?"

"By both clients." Diane did not look back at the gallery. Vera appreciated that.

Halloran's pen moved across the page. "Then let's not waste the morning. Call your witness."

Dr. Frost came up the center aisle in a cardigan the color of oatmeal, carrying nothing—no binder, no tablet. She had testified in this room twice before, and both times she had brought nothing and both times she had been the most prepared person in it.

Diane kept it short. Practice, methodology, the remedial plan. Frost answered in the flat register of a clinician reading results, which was its own kind of credibility. She described the match test's design, the population sample, the eighteen-month window during which scores had drifted low across a demographic that correlated almost perfectly with insurance tier.

"Drift," Diane said. "Is that a technical term?"

"It's a euphemism," Frost said. "The correct term is adjustment. Someone adjusted them."

"Objection." Helix Well's counsel had sent a junior that morning, a young woman with a good suit and a bad seat. "Foundation."

"Sustained as to the word 'someone.'"

"I'll rephrase," Diane said. "Dr. Frost, in your professional opinion, were the adjustments consistent with error?"

"No. Errors are random. These were directional."

Vera watched the junior counsel write something down, then not use it. She'd been that lawyer once, in a different room, on the other side of this exact exchange, and she knew what it felt like to be handed a case to lose slowly.

Diane finished in twenty minutes. The junior counsel stood, tried three questions, and sat back down when Frost answered each one with a five-second pause and then a sentence that could not be unspoken. The judge let her.

"The court will take Dr. Frost's report," Halloran said. "Ms. Okafor, I'll hear argument on the remedial plan at two. We'll be in session for the deposition transcript when it's lodged."

They broke at noon. Vera found Diane in the corridor by the vending machines, holding a coffee she hadn't drunk.

"How bad is it," Diane said.

"He's still in the room. They took a fifteen-minute break at eleven and he didn't take one."

"That's not what I asked."

Vera looked at the machine, the lit rows of chips nobody wanted. "I don't know yet."

Nolan's testimony lodged at four-forty. The clerk handed Halloran a sealed transcript with a cover sheet, and the judge read it the way she read everything—fast, then slowly, then once more at the part that mattered.

Vera got the text at four fifty-one from Sam Idris, who had a source in the AG's office and no patience: *he gave them the committee minutes. all of them. veronika the entire deal is in the record now.*

She read it standing in the hall outside the women's restroom, and then she read it again, and then she put the phone in her coat pocket and stood there for a moment doing nothing at all.

The committee minutes. The meeting where she had voted to approve. Her signature on the resolution, the one line she had asked to be softened—*the premium structure is a secondary consideration*—because she had known, even then, that it was not a secondary consideration, that it was in fact the whole engine of the return, and she had let the language blur it anyway because that was what the room wanted and she was good at giving rooms what they wanted. A lawyer could have argued around it for years. Nobody was going to argue around her own handwriting.

At five-thirty Halloran said the court would stand in recess until Monday and that she wanted closing submissions in writing and not read aloud to her. Then she left, and the room exhaled.

The fire escape was the only good thing about the apartment, and it was, objectively, a fire escape—black iron, four floors up, a view of a brick wall and a slice of Grand Street and, on clear nights, one corner of a water tower that Nolan insisted was beautiful. Vera had told him it was a water tower. He had said that was the point.

She came out at eight with two glasses and the bottle of wine that had been sitting in the cabinet since the housewarming and which neither of them had opened, because opening it would have required acknowledging that they were having a housewarming for a life neither of them had planned on.

Nolan was already sitting, back against the railing, shoes off, one foot flat on the grating. He had his sleeves rolled and his collar undone and he looked like a man who had spent nine hours being asked questions he had spent a year trying not to answer.

She sat down opposite him, which on a fire escape meant their knees almost touched. She poured. He took a glass, and neither of them drank.

"Committee minutes," she said.

"Committee minutes."

"You know what's in them."

"I know what's in them."

He turned his glass a quarter turn. The wine caught the kitchen light coming through the window behind her, one red bead of it sliding down the inside of the glass and stopping.

"I want to explain," he said.

"I didn't ask you to."

"No. You told me to go to the hearing and I didn't." He said it without heat, without defense. Just a fact laid down between them like a card face-up. "And I'm going to explain anyway because if I don't do it now I'll talk myself out of it by tomorrow."

Vera waited.

"At the deposition," he said, "they asked me whether I understood that my testimony could expose you personally. Personal liability, personal bar, everything. And I said yes. And then they asked whether I understood that I was the custodial respondent in a pending placement proceeding and that cooperation with their office might be weighed favorably, and I said I understood that too." He took a breath. "And then I gave them the minutes. Because they asked a direct question and the answer was in the room and it wasn't mine to withhold. It was never mine. I told you that from the beginning."

"You told me it was your client's."

"It's hers. She's four." He looked at the window, at the light behind her, not at her. "But that's not the part I mean."

"Then say the part you mean."

Nolan set the glass down on the grating. It made a small sound, glass on iron, precise.

"I chose you over the case," he said. "And that sounds like it means I chose the case, because it's in the transcript with my name on it. But it doesn't. If I'd gone to the hearing, I would have let the deposition run without me, and the AG would have drawn their own conclusions about what I was hiding, and they would have subpoenaed the fund anyway in six weeks with a worse posture and a longer paper trail, and they would have had you on a witness list with everything already in their hands and nothing in yours." He finally looked at her. "I went to the deposition so that I could hand it over on the record, with an explanation attached, before they took it. So that the first person to say your name in that room was me."

Vera was quiet for a while. Down on the street someone was carrying groceries and a bag split and a man said *ah, damn,* and the sound carried up through the dark.

"That's a good story," she said.

"It's true."

"I didn't say it wasn't." She picked up her glass finally and drank, a real drink, and set it down. "I would have done the same."

"Would you have."

"Yes." She said it flatly, the way he'd said the other thing, a card face-up. "I sat in that gallery all afternoon and I was angry for the first hour. And then I was angry at the second hour because I'd started to think about which was the actual betrayal and I couldn't find it. You told me what you'd do and then you did it in the one order that kept her covered."

"I didn't know that order was the safe one when I did it."

"No. But you figured it out fast." She looked at him. "That's the job, Nolan. You did the job. I'd have done the job."

He laughed, once, the kind of laugh that isn't really one. "We keep saying that to each other like it's a defense."

"It's not a defense. It's just true."

The light through the window went off behind her—the timer, the one she'd never reset—and then she was just a shape in the dark, and he was just a shape in the dark, and the water tower had a light on somewhere across the roofs.

Somewhere below, Lila was asleep with the door cracked the way she insisted, and the case was briefcases and transcripts and Judge Halloran's handwriting, and in three days there would be a Monday and after Monday there would be a ruling and none of it was resolved. None of it.

Vera reached across the grating. She didn't look at him when she did it. She found his hand by feel—the grate was cold and his hand was warm and there was wine on his fingers—and she closed hers around it.

Nolan didn't look at her either. He shifted his thumb once, an answer, and they sat like that, two people facing opposite directions on a fire escape, holding on.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 59: After the Choice · The Term of Kinship · Lumen Reads