The hearing room was on the second floor of the Legislative Office Building, a low-ceilinged space with beige carpet and a digital clock over the door, and it was full enough that staffers stood along the back wall with their coats over their arms. Vera took the seat they'd assigned her at the witness table, third in a row of four, and set her phone face down. The woman beside her was a pediatrician from Buffalo. The man on the end was a former insurance executive who had spent the last year running a nonprofit about algorithmic fairness.
Craig Dunmore, the committee counsel, leaned over the microphone. "Ms. Chen. You own eleven million dollars' worth of stock in the company that built the system this bill would regulate."
"Hopper Diagnostics," she said. "I do."
"And your fund led their Series C."
"My fund did."
"You're asking us to write a rule that would cut the value of your own holdings."
"Would you like me to answer that," Vera said, "or would you like to keep reading my bio?"
The room laughed. Dunmore smiled thinly and sat back. Behind him, on the dais, six senators shifted in their chairs, and at the far left Senator Ruth Okonjo, who had introduced the bill, put her pen down.
"I'd like her to answer it," Okonjo said.
Vera turned to face her. Okonjo was in her sixties, an Omega with close-cropped gray hair and a reputation for not letting anything go. She had chaired the committee for nine years. Vera had read her file on the train up.
"I made money from the match-score system," Vera said. "Eight years of it. I sat on panels where founders pitched me differentiated fertility scoring and I asked them the same question I ask every founder, which is what the numbers do and who they do it to. And when the answer was that the numbers sorted people into tiers that no one could appeal, I invested anyway, because the market was real and the insurance companies were paying."
Somebody in the back row stopped moving.
"The system cost me my son's guardianship," Vera said. "A score assigned to him by that system was entered into a county court as evidence that he should not live with me. It was wrong. It took a crash and two years of litigation to establish that it was wrong. So when I say the score does something to people that it isn't advertised to do, I'm not speaking as an expert. I'm speaking as a defendant in a case I should never have had to defend. I made money from the system. Now I am trying to fix it, in the small ways I have access to, and I would rather you judged the fix than the portfolio."
Okonjo watched her for a moment. "The fix is going to cost Hopper."
"Hopper can diversify. It has a diagnostics arm in three hospitals that predates the scoring product. What it can't do is keep selling a risk tier to custody courts, because after this bill passes, courts can't buy it."
"Some people would say you're grateful for the crash," Okonjo said. "That it gave you standing."
"I lost two friends in that crash," Vera said. "Their daughter lives with us now. I'd trade every dollar and every hearing room in this building to undo it. I can't. So this is what's left."
Okonjo wrote something down and moved on to the pediatrician.
Nolan came up after lunch. He'd been designated a consulting expert on the standard of care in guardianship proceedings, which meant the committee could ask him anything and no privilege attached, and he sat with his hands folded on the table and took them through it clinically — how a score could enter a family court, what a social worker did with it, what a judge did, what a parent could do, which was not much.
"Walk us through the exit criteria," Dunmore said.
"There were none," Nolan said. "That was the design. A score was issued once and could not be appealed, amended, or re-run unless the custodial situation changed in a way a court recognized. There was no body that reviewed the scoring vendor's methodology. There was no adversarial process. The score came in on a form and it acted like a fact."
"And in your case."
"In my case the form said I was unsuitable as a primary caregiver because my score fell below the custody threshold. The threshold was sixty. I was at fifty-four. I have since been advised that the score was generated using a template with a known calibration error, and that several thousand other people received scores from the same template."
"You've never seen that template yourself."
"I've seen the audit that describes it."
"Which you obtained as counsel in this matter."
"Which I obtained while representing a client," Nolan said. "Yes."
Dunmore turned a page. "The bill would create a right of appeal and a review board. Isn't that just substituting one bureaucracy for another?"
"It substitutes a process with due process," Nolan said. "The current system is a private company selling a number to a public court with no record and no appeal. The bill puts a record and an appeal on top of the number. That's the whole bill."
The committee broke at four. Vera found Nolan in the corridor by the vending machines, jacket over his shoulder, reading the printout of the amended text. Lila was with Rosa at home, and they had a train at six-forty.
"Okonjo wants to talk," Vera said. "Ten minutes in her office."
"About what."
"I think about the board."
The board was the part of the bill nobody testified about, because it hadn't existed before this morning. It was Okonjo's amendment, circulated at two, and it created a seven-person oversight panel for scoring vendors: three clinicians, two consumer representatives, one industry seat, one member of the public with personal experience of a contested custody proceeding. The industry seat, the rumor said, had names attached to it. One of them was Vera's.
They walked over through the underground concourse, past the food court with its shuttered kiosks. Okonjo's office had a window facing the plaza and a wall of photographs, most of them of her with people who had since retired or died. She waved them into chairs and did not offer coffee.
"You acquitted yourself this morning," she said to Vera.
"I told the truth in the direction you pointed me."
"That's the job." Okonjo sat on the edge of her desk. "I want you on the panel. Industry seat. Three-year term, staggered, no pay, and the first year is going to be ugly, because the first thing we do is promulgate the scoring standards and every vendor in the country is going to send somebody to sit in that room and tell us we're killing innovation."
"I assumed."
"There's a conflict. You hold eleven million in Hopper, and Hopper is going to have to change its product or leave the market. Every decision you make looks like you making money or taking revenge."
"I know."
"So why should I put you on it."
Vera thought about it. Beside her, Nolan was very still.
"Because the alternative is that you put somebody on it who has never had a score read against them," she said. "Every honest panel needs one person who has been on the receiving end and has also been in the room where the numbers were generated. I've been both. The conflict is real, and the answer is disclosure and recusal, on the record, every time, for as long as I hold the stock. I'll take that condition. If you don't like it, I'll sell the position before the first meeting."
Okonjo looked at her for a long moment, then at Nolan.
"And you'll keep testifying."
"As a consultant," Nolan said. "I'm not on the panel."
"No," Okonjo said. "You're the one who watched what the score did to a family and couldn't do anything about it. That's a different kind of witness." She stood. "The bill moves out of committee Thursday. Both of you should expect to be called back for the floor vote. And Ms. Chen—" she picked up a folder from the desk and held it out — "read the charter before you say yes to anything. All of it. There's a paragraph at the end about recusal I don't think the drafters thought through."
Vera took the folder.
They caught the six-forty with four minutes to spare and sat in the quiet car while the buildings thinned to strip malls and then to dark. Vera read the charter with the overhead light on. Nolan read over her shoulder.
"Paragraph fourteen," he said.
She found it. A recusal provision that required any panel member with a financial interest in a scoring vendor to recuse from *any matter concerning scoring standards or enforcement*, which was not recusal. It was a lifetime seat with no vote. It would hand the industry seat to whoever had already divested—which meant it would hand the seat to Hopper's chief competitor, who had never built the scoring product and had spent two years arguing that the product was safe.
"Okonjo knew," Vera said.
"She said the drafters didn't think it through."
"She said it and handed me the folder." Vera closed it. "Somebody wrote that paragraph. Somebody who wanted the seat empty."
The train went through a station without stopping. Nolan looked out at the platform lights sliding past.
"Then the bill passes," he said, "and the panel that's supposed to fix the scores has no one on it who's ever had one filed against them."
"Unless we find out who wrote it," Vera said.
She opened the folder again and turned to the last page, and there at the bottom, in the change log nobody reads, the amendment to paragraph fourteen was attributed to a staff counsel. The name was Cordell Lattimore's former associate.