Rónán's thread was still in the air above the estate. Niamh could feel it without looking, a taut wire of something wrong running from the hawthorn stump she'd doused with the garden hose and out past the green toward the water it had no business reaching.
They couldn't leave him staked on the doorstep all night. Cáel had said so plainly, and then had done the difficult thing himself, hauling Rónán's bound weight to the back shed and locking the keg-room door with an iron hasp that predated the house. The screams stopped once the door shut. That was worse, somehow. The estate had gone quiet in the way people go quiet when they've decided not to come outside and ask.
Her mother was upstairs. Niamh had heard her moving for a while, then not.
She stood in the kitchen with the lights off and the tap dripping and her arm aching under the sleeve, and she decided. It was a small decision, the kind you can pretend was forced on you, but she made it anyway.
The hook was in her rucksack where she'd left it that afternoon, wrapped in the tea towel from her grandmother's kitchen, because the shrine box had needed a cushion and she had not thought about the shape of things. She unwrapped it now at the table. Bronze, palm-length, the barb worn smooth by salt and hands. The shrine on the headland above Spiddal had held it since long before her grandmother's grandmother, in a slate box no deeper than a loaf tin, and the parish had left it there the way it left the cliffs alone. She had taken it that afternoon as cover for the ambush, and had meant to put it back before dark.
Then Rónán had happened, and the day had burned forward two months in an hour, and now it was nearly one in the morning and the hook was on her kitchen table and her arm was hurting in a way that had nothing to do with Rónán's thread and everything to do with the row of neat scalded marks scoring her wrist inward toward the elbow.
She didn't know why she did it. She told herself it was information. She told herself Cáel would never tell her what he actually knew and this was the only honest thing in the room.
She laid the hook flat against her forearm, barb pointing toward her hand, the way it sat in the shrine box.
The kitchen went away.
Inisheer is bare in a way the mainland is not. In 1898 it was barer. Limestone and low walls and the sea chewing the south shore, and the clochán above the pier with its dry-stone domed roof, and the slate box inside it, and inside the box the hook.
She was standing in the clochán but not standing in it. The floor was packed earth. The light came in horizontally through a low doorway, and there was someone kneeling in that light, and it was not the thief.
It was Cáel.
Younger. Not by much — faerie years are quiet on a face — but the difference was in the eyes, which in the direct morning light of 1898 were still and wide and not yet tired. He wore a plain dark coat, the kind a man wears to be unremarkable in a town, and he was kneeling on the earth floor with one hand flat on the flags and his head bent like a man at prayer who doesn't believe in it.
Behind him, in the doorway, a man stood with a fishing bag over one shoulder and a knitted gansey the grey of wet stone, and he was looking at the shrine box the way a man looks at a thing he has already decided to do.
"Someone will know," the fisherman said. It wasn't a question.
No one answered him. Cáel did not turn. His hand stayed flat on the flagstone, and the flagstone was the only thing in the clochán that was warm, and Niamh understood without being told that the shrine's ward sat under his palm and that he was holding it down like a man holding a door closed from the wrong side.
"I have to," the fisherman said. "You know what I have to."
Cáel's voice, when it came, was quiet and had no edges on it at all.
"Yes."
The fisherman lifted the lid of the box. Niamh watched a human hand close around the hook — her hook, this hook, the barb that was now pressed to her skin — and lift it out into the horizontal light, and there was no thunder, no bell, no tearing of the air. There was only the sound of the sea on the south shore and a man in a door turning away with something in his bag.
Then, at the last moment, just before the doorway took him, the fisherman stopped.
"Will you tell them it was me?"
"I will tell them nothing," Cáel said. "That is the courtesy. You will not be named. That is all the courtesy there is."
The fisherman nodded like a man accepting a sentence and was gone. Cáel stayed kneeling with his hand on the flagstone for a long time after. When he finally lifted it, the stone was cold, and Niamh saw what she had not seen when the light was in her eyes: the ward, thin as a fishing line, running out from the flags through the wall of the clochán and down the hill and out into the sea, the whole shore knitted to the shrine, and every knot of it pulling slack.
He had known. He had been standing at the exact place where the gate between the headland shrine and the water crossed the ward, and he had let it cross, and he had stood aside.
Standing aside had a shape. She was looking at it.
The vision thinned. The clochán let go of her. There was a moment of something else, faint and no more than a change in pressure — a note, low and wet, like a bell rung underwater a long way off — and she had the strong and unwelcome sense of being noticed, of a room she was not in turning its head.
The kitchen came back.
Her hand had closed around the hook. It was warm now, warmer than her arm, and it was not supposed to be. Niamh sat without moving for the length of ten slow breaths, listening to the tap drip, and then she looked at her forearm.
The scalded marks had moved. Two of them, the newest, had drawn back toward her wrist and gone pale, like a bruise deciding to leave. The rest were not changed. It was small and it was not nothing, and she did not know what it meant that the hook had answered to Rónán's thread.
At the table, in her own kitchen, with the light off and her mother asleep upstairs and a bound man in her shed, Niamh understood two things at once and could not choose between them.
The first was that Cáel had stood inside a closed shrine in 1898 and let a human man walk out with the bronze hook. It was the same thing Rónán had screamed on the flagstones. It was not, she suspected, the same thing at all. "Not the way he means it" sat in her chest and did not resolve. There had been a reason in that doorway and she had heard the fisherman ask the question and she had not heard the answer.
The second was that she had never told Cáel she had taken the hook, and she was not going to. Not tonight.
She did not have the language for why. It wasn't the geis. It wasn't fear of the court, exactly. It was that she had spent six months learning the shape of him — the caught breath before he told the truth, the two-second pause that meant he was choosing his words, the way he said her name when he was about to say something worse — and something in her had begun to keep a second ledger.
She wrapped the hook back in the tea towel. Then she did what she had decided to do before she had decided to do it, and it was already done, which is how a decision like that announces itself. She took her coat from the back of the chair and folded the bundle into the inside pocket, deep, where a wallet would go, and she put the coat back on the chair with the bundle in it, so that the coat looked exactly like a coat.
Behind her, on the worktop, her phone lit up once with a message. Deirdre Nolan. *Thursday, weather permitting. Pier at eleven. Come alone if you can.*
She looked at it for a long moment. Then she put the phone face down.
The hawthorn stump was still smoking faintly out on the lawn. Above it, the thread went on running through the dark, thin as a fishing line, out past the green, down toward the sea it had no business reaching. It had not moved all night. It was waiting for something.
She had a strong, cold sense that it was no longer waiting on her.