The gold light on the water died the way a coal dies—red, then grey, then nothing.
Niamh came up choking. Salt in her throat, salt in her eyes, and under her the sea had gone flat and hard as a slate floor. She was standing. That was the first wrong thing. She was standing in the water, waist-deep, and the tide that had been dragging her down to Bríd had simply stopped, the way a heart stops, all at once and total.
Cáel broke the surface three feet to her left. He surfaced like a seal—no, he was a seal, then he wasn't, and he was standing too, streaming, his black hair flat to his skull, and he found her wrist in the dark and held it.
"Don't let go of the line," he said.
She looked down. The tide-line was still there, unbroken, a seam of light running from the strand out past her knees toward the open sea. The twelve O'Malleys stood along it on the sand behind her, gripping the salvaged rib of the Saint Brendan between them like a rail. Peig stood at the near end, both hands on the timber, and her eyes found Niamh's and did not let go either.
Above them, on the cliff, the shrine was dark. Every lantern out.
Then the dark moved.
It came down the cliff path without any of the trouble a body should have—no stumble, no scrape of boot on stone—and when it reached the strand the gold line guttered and lay down flat, like flame before a closed door. Bríd walked the strand barefoot in a green coat that was not her own coat, because her own coat was one of the three relics, sealed in wax-cloth on the altar above.
She was old. Niamh had never seen her look old before. The tribunal had not yet been called and already Bríd wore the face of a woman who has counted the years and found the sum short.
"You," Bríd said, to Cáel.
"Me," Cáel said.
"You held the line."
"I stood on it. The O'Malleys held it. You'll want to be precise—you're about to be judged on the record, and I've read your record before. It's very thin."
Bríd's hand moved, and the sea between them all stood up in a wall six feet high and hung there, black and smooth, holding. Niamh felt the water press at her ribs, at the underside of her chin, and did not move, because Peig O'Malley had not moved either, and the old woman was watching Bríd with the flat patience of someone who has waited fifty-one years for a bill to come due.
"Name the tribunal," Bríd said.
And the air went cold and crowded.
Niamh couldn't see them—not properly. That was the thing about a faerie tribunal, she'd read it in the vellum and never believed it: you don't see them, you see what they displace. The strand's light shifted as though a crowd stood around her and each of them cast a shadow the wrong way. Gulls out over the sound stopped in the air, mid-wing, and did not fall. The water wall stayed up because something on the other side of it was leaning.
A voice spoke out of nowhere in particular. It had the tone of a clerk reading a long list and enjoying it.
*Cáel, gatekeeper of the western door, bound by the empty-coast treaty of the year sixteen hundred and three. You are called on three counts. Aiding the return of a bound relic. Standing in breach of the covenant's line. Concealment of intent from the council you serve.*
"Two," Cáel said. "The second and the third are the same count wearing two hats."
*You will not be permitted to argue the indictment until the sentence is passed. That is the form.*
"Then the form is a farce and always was."
The cold air seemed to smile.
*Yes.*
"It's the weights first, is it?" Bríd said quietly. She was looking at Niamh now. "You took a net-weight off my altar and put it into the sea, and a mortal woman threw it where her brother drowned, and the covenant's record of that drowning—my record, the only place the name of Fintan O'Malley and the name of Bríd are written in the same hand—that is gone." Her voice did not rise. That was worse. "Two relics remain. The coat and the horn. The council will hear that the erasure has begun."
*The council has heard*, said the clerk-voice.
"And the gatekeeper who let it be heard?"
*The council has found.*
Cáel let go of Niamh's wrist. She grabbed for it and missed, and he stepped one pace forward out of the gold line and stood in the plain black water on the other side, where the covenant ran.
"Then say it to my face," he said, "because there's no face here but yours, Bríd, and we both know what it costs you to stand on this strand in your own skin."
Bríd's jaw tightened, and for one second Niamh saw the thing she'd been hunting in the archives for a year—the woman who signed the 1603 treaty with Tadhg Ó Máille, who accepted the depopulation of the west in exchange for a yearly tithe, who wrote her own name into the covenant because it was the only document that would keep it. Who had been keeping it ever since.
*The tribunal rules.*
The stranded gulls dropped all at once and flew.
*Cáel of the western door is stripped of the gatekeeper's authority, from this tide forward and forever. The door he kept is not his to keep. The name he answered to is not his to answer to. He is bound to the mortal woman's contract as a hand is bound to a wrist, until the contract ends.*
Cáel stood very still.
*And at the next full moon he is to be unmade.*
The water wall came down. It came down gently, which was somehow the worst of it, folding into the sea like a coat laid over a chair. There was no wave. The strand was simply dry, the gold line gone, the rib of the Saint Brendan in the O'Malleys' hands as ordinary as driftwood.
Niamh got two steps before her knees went. She caught herself on the rib. Peig's hand closed over hers, dry and hard as rope.
"Up," Peig said. "You're not done."
"Full moon," Niamh said. Her voice came out wrong. "That's—how many days?"
"Twenty-nine," Cáel said. He hadn't turned around. He was still standing in the wet sand on the covenant's side of where the line had been, and she understood, with a lurch, that he couldn't cross it now. He'd been stripped. The strand on this side belonged to mortals and the strand on that side did not, and he was on the wrong one. "Twenty-nine days, and then I stop."
"Stop how?"
He looked at his own hands. "Unmade is unmade. There is no how. There's a where, and there's a when, and the when is the full moon."
"Then we finish it before."
"Niamh—"
"We finish it before." She got her legs under her. She was so cold she could barely feel her feet, and the tide-token hung between her collarbones on its leather cord, cold as a coin left in a well, and she was suddenly, blazingly awake. "Two relics. You said returning them voids the covenant. We returned one. You said destroying them by mortal hands ruptures it. We're not doing that. We're returning them, and every relic that goes back takes a piece of the record, and the record is the only place Bríd exists. She told us so herself, on the strand, in front of whatever that clerk was. She's got two coats left and a name that's already half gone."
"One coat," Cáel said.
"What?"
"The horn is not a coat. The weights, the coat, the horn—you've got two to go and they're not alike." He paused. "And there's the ring."
Niamh's hand went to her pocket before she could stop it. The pearl-ring. It had been in there since the first week, since before she'd understood anything, a thing she'd found in the hollow of a rotted mast and never handed over because it was hers, it had been her grandmother's, and because some buried part of her had known it didn't belong to Bríd's altar at all.
Cáel watched her hand.
"You're carrying the third relic," he said.
"It's a ring."
"All three of them are just things. A weight is just a weight. A coat is just a coat. That's the trick of it—the treaty bound them by what they were for, not what they're made of." He stepped forward, stopped himself at the invisible seam. "Niamh. If you're carrying it, the tribunal doesn't know. Which means there's a thing I can do that the council hasn't ruled on yet, because they think all three were on that altar."
Peig O'Malley made a sound behind her—not quite a laugh.
"Say it plainly," Niamh said. "It's been a long year of men not saying things plainly."
Cáel glanced once at Peig, at the O'Malleys, at the black flat sea behind him, and then at Niamh, and in the dark his face did something she'd never seen it do.
"The ring can give a faerie his mortality back," he said. "If I take it before the tribunal does, I'm not a gatekeeper to unmake. I'm just a man. A mortal man, twenty-nine days and a bit, and the full moon has no claim on a mortal."
"Then take it," Niamh said. "Now."
"No." He said it fast. "Because the moment I'm mortal I can't cross the water, and the coat and the horn are across the water, and Bríd's tribunal will be waiting at the shrine, and you will walk up that cliff alone." He let that sit. "I can't be both the man who's saved and the man who saves you. That's the choice. That's always been the choice."
Behind them, out on the sound, a light came on. Small, yellow, moving slowly toward Inisheer from the north—a boat, and not Bríd's, and not the currach.
Danny's lantern. Finally on the water, finally coming in, three days after he'd gone missing, and Niamh understood with a cold drop in her stomach that he hadn't been lost at all. He'd been somewhere. Doing something. And whatever it was, he'd waited until the tribunal had finished before he showed his face.
"Twenty-nine days," she said again, and this time it wasn't a question.