The Tide-Token

Chapter 54: The Council Divided

They met in the old coastguard station above Inisheer, because it was the only roof left standing that belonged to no one in particular. The O'Malleys had swept it out that morning. Peig sat nearest the cold hearth with her stick across her knees like a musket, and Danny stood behind her because sitting still had never suited him since the cave. Tadhg Flaherty had come, white-faced and out of place in his mainland coat, and Saoirse sat close to Niamh with her hands wrapped in her sleeves, still not warm since the water.

They had barely begun when they came.

Not invited, not announced—the door swung in off the wind and a dozen of them walked through it, and the room went quiet the way a room does when the tide turns. Niamh had seen the fair folk before, at the edge of fields, in the corner of a wake-house, but never so many at once and never so plainly at war with each other. The young ones came in first and stood along the wall by the window, luminous and quick, watching Niamh with a frank and hungry curiosity. The old ones took the far side, by the door, and they did not look at Niamh at all. They looked at Peig, and at the ring, and then at nothing.

Cáel stepped in last. He was slower than he'd been a month ago, and the room saw it. He crossed to stand beside Niamh and no further, and she heard the small catch in his breathing from the climb.

"You'll not be called to order in my house," Peig said, not rising. "But you'll speak civil or you'll speak outside."

"We're not yours to order, O'Malley," one of the old ones said. He had a voice like a hinge. "We've come because the drowned debt is being meddled with, and the meddling is being done by a mortal who can't hold the sea in her two hands, and a gatekeeper who gave up his gate. That's not a council. That's a scandal."

"Then hear it as a scandal," Niamh said, and stood. Her voice came out steadier than she expected. "I'm not asking your permission. I'm telling you what's going to happen on the twenty-second, and I'm telling you why it has to."

"You'll return what never belonged to you," the hinge-voiced one said.

"It was never mine to keep and never yours to lose." Niamh held up her hand and let the pearl-ring catch the grey light from the window. Every faerie in the room went still, the young ones leaning in, the old ones flinching back a half-step as if she'd shown them fire. "You all know what this is. It went into the true deep and it came back. It came back to *me*, and not because I'm clever. Because the sea knows whose it is, and it's not done being owed."

"Pretty speech," said a woman from the old side.

"It's not a speech, it's an inventory." Niamh reached into her coat and laid the copies on the table—the treaty, the parish record, Cáit's tracing. "The debt was signed in 1603 by Eoghan O'Connell, who traded this coastline for his family's safety. My family. And the man the sea took to seal it was a Conneely who married into a Flaherty, and his blood survived, and it's standing in this room trying not to sit down."

Tadhg made a small sound.

"You don't have to prove it tonight," Niamh said to him, gentler. Then, to the room: "We prove it on the twenty-second, at the spring tide, when Peig O'Malley stands witness and swears the claim she's been holding since before any of you were born."

Peig didn't move, but her stick tapped the floor once. Assent enough.

"That's a mortal tribunal," the hinge-voiced one said. "The sea doesn't answer to mortals."

"No," Cáel said. "It answers to me. Or it did, and it will take my voice one more time before it's finished with me. And that's the part you keep arguing around like children." He walked out into the middle of the room, onto the rug Peig's grandmother had woven, and turned to face the old ones where they stood. And no one stopped him, because no one had ever seen him do it.

"You want a scandal?" he said quietly. "I signed the covenant. I held the gate for sixteen hundred years on the strength of another man's signature, and I never once told a soul it was signed in fear, by a man who'd already lost a son to the water and would have traded the whole coast twice over to keep the rest. I let the ring be taken. That was me. Not Bríd." Some of the young ones looked at their feet. "I let it be taken because I was tired, and because I thought the debt had outlived its debtors, and I was wrong. And the punishment is that I'm mortal now, and I'm aging, and I'll have perhaps forty years on this earth if I'm lucky, and every one of them is hers." He nodded once at Niamh. "That's the whole of it. You've heard the complaint. The complaint is me."

The room was very quiet.

Then the hinge-voiced one said, "You've no standing. A mortal forfeit has no voice."

"He has mine," Peig said, and stood, and the stick was not a stick exactly. "I've an unpaid claim on that one going back further than any of you were bartered. I've not spent it. Say another thing and I'll spend it here."

The room rearranged itself without anyone moving. The young ones had already drifted toward Niamh's half of the floor. Now two of the older ones followed, then three, and one—a gaunt old fisherman-shaped thing Niamh had never seen—sat down on the edge of the table and said, "I remember the drowning. I was the one that opened the water for it. The man went down holding the ring because the covenant required a token, not because he was owed anything. We were told to say he was owed." He looked at Cáel. "We were *told*."

"You were told by the one who wrote the covenant," Cáel said.

"By the one who *ran* the covenant," the old one said. "And she's been running it since, and she's the reason four of us standing on this floor never got to go home."

The hinge-voiced one said, "Careful."

"He's right." A young one, hardly more than a girl, with sea-weed in her hair. "I wasn't there. But I've been at the drownings since, the ones nobody signs for, and I'm done holding a debt I never signed. We're with the mortal."

"You're with no one," the hinge-voiced one said.

"Then we're done being with you," the girl said, and crossed the room, and the others followed her, and suddenly Niamh had more faeries on her side of the rug than against her, and the ones against her were old and few and standing by the door.

Niamh said, before it could turn, "The spring tide, the twenty-second. The ring goes back through the descendant, and I'm the one holding it until it does. That's the return. That's all I'm asking this house to allow."

"Allowed," said the gaunt old one on the table.

"Allowed," said the girl.

"Allowed," said the others, in a ragged chorus, and the hinge-voiced one did not say anything at all, which was the nearest thing to a concession the sea had ever offered.

Only then did Niamh realize how quiet the doorway had gone.

Bríd stood in it.

She had not come in the door; the door had never opened. She was simply there, soaked to the elbow as though she'd walked out of water and up the hill, her hair flat and heavy, and she did not look at Niamh or at the ring. She looked at Cáel.

"You argued your own case," she said. "You should not have been permitted a voice."

"Your side allowed it," Cáel said.

"Your side," Bríd repeated, and something moved behind her face, old and vast and tired. "You think this is a room with two sides." She stepped in past the threshold—the first time since the drowning cave that Niamh had seen her cross a threshold uninvited—and the faeries nearest her moved back without deciding to.

"Be at the tribunal, Bríd," Niamh said. "You'll be heard too."

"I'll not be at your return." Bríd's voice was low and level. "The twenty-second, the spring tide, the ring, the boy from the mainland—you'll do as you like with it. I'll not be there." She looked at Cáel once more, and it might have been grief, and it might have been arithmetic. "I'll not need to be."

And she turned and walked back out through the wall of the station as though the wall were water, and was gone, and the room began to talk at once, urgently, like people after a fever breaks.

It was Saoirse who said what Niamh was thinking.

"She didn't refuse," Saoirse said, quiet under the noise. "She promised to stay away. Nobody stays away from a thing unless they've something else already set."

Niamh looked at Tadhg Flaherty across the room, still holding his hat, and then at the ring on her finger, and then out the grey window where the wind was coming up off the water. Six days to the spring tide. Twenty-five to the tribunal. And Bríd had already said she wouldn't need to be there.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 54: The Council Divided · The Tide-Token · Lumen Reads