The Unbinding

Chapter 1: The Photograph in the Gutter

The gutter was warped along the spine of signature four, a slow tidal curl of paper that had been wet a century ago and never forgiven anyone for it. Benjamin Cole had spent the last forty minutes coaxing it flat with a humidity dome and a stack of museum board, and it was almost there—almost—when the scalpel slipped.

Not far. Half a millimeter, the width of a hair, the kind of error that would have made his old mentor at the Morgan exhale through his nose and say nothing at all. But half a millimeter was enough.

The blade caught the folded edge of the gutter and lifted it, and something small and stiff slid out from the spine hollow and landed on the blotter with a soft click, like a domino set down.

Benjamin went still. He was a man who went still the way other men flinched—reflexively, completely, his whole body agreeing to stop while his mind caught up. The studio was quiet around him. The radiator ticked. Outside, on the third floor of a converted warehouse in Sunset Park, the elevated train on Fourth Avenue groaned through its turn, and the windows shuddered in their frames the way they always did.

He set the scalpel down first. Then the bone folder. Then he peeled off his nitrile gloves, one finger at a time, because you did not touch a find with gloves that had been handling 1890s rag paper and wheat starch paste. You looked at it first, and you thought about what looking at it was doing to you.

It was a photograph. Small, black-and-white or nearly, the kind of square print that fell out of drugstore envelopes in the 1970s—or out of a county fair booth in upstate New York, if the back of it was anything to go by, and it was, because he turned it over and read in faded pencil: *Pine Hollow Fair, Aug.*

The date was smeared. But the front.

The front was a boy, six years old, maybe five, standing in front of a livestock pen with a paper cone of something in his fist and his face half-turned toward whoever was holding the camera. He was wearing a too-large windbreaker with a broken zipper pull. His hair was a dark bowl cut gone shaggy at the edges. He was squinting into the sun with an expression of profound, private suspicion—a face that did not want to be photographed and was being photographed anyway.

Benjamin knew the face.

He had a photograph of that face in a shoebox in his closet, and he had not looked at it in eleven years, and he did not need to look at it now because the features were his own, desaturated and small, staring up from the blotter at the center of a project he had been hired to complete by a man he had met exactly twice.

He sat down. Not in the chair—on the floor, his back against the leg of the workbench, which he would later recognize as a strange thing to do and which at the time felt like the only available option.

Pine Hollow. He turned the name over. Nothing. No smell of fried dough, no memory of a Ferris wheel, no mother's hand. His childhood was a set of photographs and a set of things other people had told him, and the two did not always agree, and he had long ago stopped trying to force them. He had been six in 1997. He had grown up in three towns in two states before he was ten. A county fair was exactly the kind of thing that would have happened to him and left no mark.

Except this one had left a mark. It had left a photograph. And someone had sewn it into the spine hollow of a Hudson River School sketchbook, which was not where photographs went. Photographs went in albums, in drawers, in shoeboxes. They did not go into the gutter of an 1893 sketchbook from a Saranac Lake estate, between the third and fourth signatures, where a restorer would find them only by making the kind of mistake Benjamin Cole did not make.

He looked at the sketchbook. It lay open on the bench under the weight of the humidity dome, its pages showing the pale gray ghosts of thirty pencil studies—the Hudson highlands, a sloop on the river, a stand of hemlocks—all of them good, all of them anonymous. No signature. The client had said the artist was unrecorded and the attribution uncertain and the value, therefore, mostly sentimental.

The client.

Benjamin got up and found his phone and called Nicolas Ashford.

It rang three times. Then: "Cole." The voice was low, unhurried, almost bored, and it had the effect it always had, which was to make Benjamin feel like he had interrupted something more important than whatever he was about to say. "You don't call."

"I found something in the book."

A pause. Not a long one. Long enough that Benjamin, who had spent his adult life listening for the tiny asymmetries that told you when a person was lying, noticed it. "In the gutter of signature four," Ashford said. "I wondered if that fold would open."

"You knew."

"I knew the gutter was damaged when I bought it. I didn't know what was in it." A sound like ice in glass. Ashford drank in the middle of phone calls, always, as if the conversation were a performance he was attending rather than part of. "Describe it."

"It's a photograph. Of a boy at a fair. It says Pine Hollow."

"And?"

"And it's me."

The ice chimed again. When Ashford spoke next his voice had not changed at all, which was somehow worse. "Is it a good likeness?"

Benjamin pressed his thumb into the bridge of his nose. "Mr. Ashford. I need to know where this book came from."

"You have my provenance file. Wilson's, lot 219, the Estes estate. I sent it to you in October."

"Provenance files are for the book. Not for—" He stopped. He looked at the small square of paper on the blotter, at the windbreaker, at the squint. "This did not come out of the Estes estate. This came out of my life. There is no version of this where an 1893 sketchbook from a Saranac Lake collection has a photograph of me in it unless someone put it there."

"Someone did."

"Who?"

"That," Ashford said, "is what I'd like you to find out."

Benjamin laughed—one short, flat note. "I'm a conservator. I fix bindings. I don't investigate—"

"You fix things that are broken," Ashford said. "You are the best in the city at making a damaged object whole without lying about what it is. That is a very specific skill." A pause. "Finish the book."

"You can't be serious."

"The fold needs to be relaxed and the gutter relined or the signatures will continue to separate. You told me that yourself. The photograph has been in there for at least twenty years without doing further harm. It can wait three more days while you finish the work. Then bring me the book, in person." Another chime of ice. "And bring the photograph."

"Mr. Ashford—"

"Three days, Cole. Good night."

The line went dead.

Benjamin stood in the middle of his studio holding his phone, and the radiator ticked, and the train went by again, and he did not move for a while. Then he walked back to the bench and leaned over the sketchbook, and he looked—really looked—at the gutter, at the way the fold had been creased, at the faint offset stain on the facing page where the photograph had pressed against it for two decades. Someone had opened the spine, inserted a photograph, and closed it again. Someone who knew bookbinding. Someone who wanted it found by a restorer and not by a buyer.

Or someone who wanted it found by *him*.

He opened the bottom drawer of his desk. It was the drawer where he kept things he had not decided what to do with yet: an unlabeled key, a business card from a bar in Reykjavik, a set of house keys that had belonged to someone who was no longer alive. He laid the photograph on top of the pile, face up. Six-year-old Benjamin squinted at the ceiling of the studio.

He closed the drawer. He turned the little brass key.

Then he put his gloves back on and picked up the bone folder, because there was work to do, and because in three days he would be standing in Nicolas Ashford's house asking questions, and he wanted to be able to say he had not, in the meantime, given the man any reason to think he was afraid.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 1: The Photograph in the Gutter · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads