The Unbinding

Chapter 18: The Key in the Sketchbook

The studio smelled of wheat paste and old leather. Benjamin had cleared the worktable except for the sketchbook, which sat under the lamp like a patient waiting for surgery.

Nicolas leaned against the supply cabinet, arms crossed, watching him. Neither of them had slept. After Brighton Beach and the bank and Ruth's kitchen, sleep wasn't on the table.

"You said it yourself," Nicolas said. "The back cover's wrong."

Benjamin ran his thumb along the edge of the board. "A book this cheap doesn't get a cover this thick. It's a schoolboy's sketchbook, machine-bound, cardboard wraps. Should be two millimeters of pressed pulp. This is closer to six."

"Could be water damage. Swelling."

"Water damage warps. This is uniform." He set the sketchbook face down and picked up his scalpel. "Hand me the spatula."

Nicolas passed it over without a word. Benjamin slid the blade under the pasted-down endpaper along the spine edge and worked it slowly, centimeter by centimeter, releasing the old adhesive with the patience of someone who had spent fifteen years learning that haste was the enemy of everything he loved. The paper lifted clean.

Underneath, the board was a sandwich. Two thin sheets of millboard with a cavity between them, the gap filled with something soft.

"Someone built this," Nicolas said quietly. "Somebody made the cover themselves."

Benjamin nodded. He widened the opening with the spatula, and the cavity's contents slid out onto the felt: a small brass key, dark with age, and a photograph folded once.

The key was no bigger than his thumb joint. Flat, single-toothed, the kind that opened a cheap padlock or a cash box. A length of black thread still ran through its bow where it had been stitched into the board.

Benjamin looked at Nicolas. Nicolas was already looking at the photograph.

Benjamin unfolded it.

A boy, seven or eight years old, standing in front of a chain-link fence with his hands loose at his sides. Dark hair to his ears. A narrow face, serious, squinting slightly against whatever light had been behind the camera. On the back, in the same cramped hand that had written J. Vance on the intake form: *Julian, 1994.*

The room was very quiet. The radiator ticked.

Nicolas made a sound Benjamin had never heard him make. Not a gasp. Smaller than that. Something catching in his throat and stopping.

"Nicolas."

"I've seen him."

Benjamin set the photograph down flat. "What do you mean."

"In a dream. The same dream. Since I was a kid." Nicolas's voice had gone flat and careful, the way it did when he was holding something heavy. "I'm in a room with a lot of beds. Cots. Metal frames. There's a window with bars but it's not a prison. It's just - a window. And this boy is on the cot next to mine. Dark hair. He's got a scar on his left thumb, here." Nicolas touched the base of his own thumb. "He tells me we're going to get out. He says it every night. I never see his face, but I always know it's him."

He stopped. Breathed.

"I thought it was just a dream."

Benjamin knew better than to reach for him. He kept his hands on the worktable. "It's him."

"It can't be him. I don't remember any of that. I was placed at four. I don't have memories from before."

"Then you're remembering him from somewhere else." Benjamin picked up the key. It was warm from the studio heat, absurdly ordinary in his palm. "Or the dream isn't memory. Either way, the photograph is real and it was hidden in a book that was given to me with a name attached that wasn't mine."

Nicolas finally looked up.

"The box," he said.

The tin box sat on the worktable where Ruth had left it two days before, still padlocked, still shut. Benjamin had tried the key to his own apartment, and his father's old desk, and his lockbox at the studio, all on the long-shouldered reasoning that a man who hid a key might have hidden it somewhere he could find it. None of them fit.

The brass key slid into the padlock and turned.

The shackle dropped open with a click that sounded louder than it should have.

"Jesus," Nicolas said.

Benjamin lifted the lid.

The box was packed to the brim. Letters, mostly. Bundles tied with string, each labeled in the same cramped hand - E.M., unmistakably, the letters thick and slanted to the right. A small black accounts book. A manila envelope of photographs. Two loose keys on a ring. At the bottom, under everything, a stack of yellowed carbons: official forms, the same onionskin paper as the intake sheet he'd held in Sergei's shop.

Benjamin's hands were steady. He'd spent fifteen years handling things other people had hidden for decades. His hands were always steady. That was the trick.

He pulled out the first bundle of letters and undid the string. The top envelope was addressed to Ruth Cole, in Queens, and stamped May 1995.

Nicolas leaned in. "That's her."

Benjamin opened it.

The letter was two pages, handwritten, in ink that had faded to rust.

*Dear Ruth,*

*I know this is difficult, and I know you have questions, and I am sorry I can't give you the answers in person. But you have to trust me as you have trusted me before. Benjamin will be safe with you. He will grow up loved and he will never have to wonder about the people he came from. That is the gift. That is the whole of the gift.*

*There is only one thing I ask. You must never attempt to trace his origins. You must never allow anyone else to trace them either. And you must keep him away from the others. If any arrangement is ever proposed — any reunion, any meeting, any letter from a child who claims to be related — refuse it. Refuse it absolutely. The children must never be reunited. It is the only way any of them survive.*

*You have done a good thing. You have done a better thing than you know.*

*Yours,*

*Edith*

Benjamin read it twice. The second time he read it out loud, slowly, and hearing his own voice say *the children must never be reunited* made something cold settle in his chest and stay there.

Nicolas had gone very still.

"Reunited with who," he said.

Benjamin turned the letter over. Nothing on the back. He opened the next envelope in the bundle - the carbon of a placement agreement, dated 1992, Ruth's signature copied in, the child's name left blank. Then another letter, this one to someone else entirely.

He laid them out side by side on the worktable. Three letters. Three households. Three placements, all in 1991 and 1992. All from Edith Matheson. All containing some version of the same line: *keep them apart.*

"She wasn't hiding one child," Benjamin said. "She was running a network."

"She was hiding all of them." Nicolas picked up one of the carbons. "Look at this. '*Placement contingent upon permanent separation from sibling cohort.*' Sibling cohort. That's not language for adoption. That's language for a witness protection program."

Benjamin's hands, at last, were not quite steady. He set down the letter and looked at the sketchbook on the far end of the table, gutted now, its secret spilled out.

Ruth had told him his mother was dead. A private arrangement, eighteen thousand dollars, a woman who claimed the birth mother was dangerous. And now a letter from that same woman, saying the children must never be reunited - as if reunion were the danger, as if being found were the thing that killed you.

*Julian, 1994.*

A boy on a cot next to Nicolas's, in a dream Nicolas shouldn't have.

Benjamin picked up the photograph and held it so the lamplight fell flat across the boy's face. "He's not on the list of placements. He's not in any of these letters. He was in the holding facility on Hart Island and he stayed there."

"He stayed there," Nicolas repeated.

"He's either dead or he's still there." Benjamin set the photograph down. "Either way, Ruth was told a lie. My whole childhood was - someone built me out of a lie to protect me from something, and I don't know yet if it was a monster or just another scared woman with a padlock and a key."

Nicolas reached over and closed the tin box. The lid dropped with a soft metal thump.

"I'm going to Hart Island," he said. "Tomorrow. You can come or you can stay, but I'm not going to keep dreaming about a boy whose file nobody will read."

Outside, the radiator ticked. Somewhere below, a car went by in the wet.

Benjamin looked at the empty sketchbook, its cover split open, its thread still hanging like a severed nerve.

"I'm coming," he said. "But first, we call the watchman."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 18: The Key in the Sketchbook · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads