The Unbinding

Chapter 20: The Ferry to Hart Island

The ferry left the dock at nine-forty with eleven passengers aboard, most of them city workers in orange vests who kept to the bow and talked about a baseball game. Benjamin and Nicolas sat at the stern on a bench worn smooth by decades of salt and rain. The water behind them churned gray and white, and Manhattan receded into something small enough to hold in one hand.

Nicolas hadn't said a word since they'd bought the tickets. He'd paid for his own, counting out singles on the counter, and Benjamin had watched his fingers move and thought about how you could share a bed with someone and still not know what they carried.

"You don't have to do this," Benjamin said.

"I know." Nicolas kept his eyes on the water. "That's not the point."

The crossing took twenty minutes. The island appeared first as a line of trees, then as a low gray shore, then as the institution it was: a dock, a gate, a road that climbed a hill toward buildings the color of old teeth. Gulls wheeled above the incinerator stacks. Benjamin had read that the dead arrived here by barge, stacked in pine boxes, thirty at a time, and that prisoners had dug the trenches. He had restored a ledger from a Brooklyn funeral home once, a hundred and forty years of burials, and the neat columns of names had made him feel closer to something than he'd ever been able to name. This was the same feeling, and worse.

They walked off the ferry after the workers. A woman in a windbreaker checked a clipboard and asked their business.

"Research," Benjamin said. "We're trying to locate a burial."

The woman looked at Nicolas, then back at him. "Public records office is in the admin building. Up the hill, past the chapel. You'll sign in." She said it the way other people said *don't touch anything*.

The road was gravel and the hill was steeper than it looked. Halfway up, Nicolas stopped and stood with his hands on his knees, breathing. Benjamin didn't touch him. He'd learned that much. When Nicolas straightened, his face was gray in a way that had nothing to do with the climb.

"There's no headstone," Nicolas said. "That's what I keep thinking. If he's here, there's nothing. Just a grid, and a number. My mother used to say that's the worst thing, not dying. Being a number."

"Your mother?"

"Ruth." Nicolas stared at his own hands. "I meant Ruth. I don't know why I said that."

They walked the rest of the way in silence.

The administrative building had a linoleum floor and a reception desk with a bell. The clerk found no Julian Vance in the burial index. She searched twice, once by name and once by year, and then, because Benjamin asked, she searched the intake records for 1996, and found nothing. *Returned*, she said, meant returned to the city, to the morgue, to an institution, to whoever had been waiting. *Returned* wasn't a person. It was a filing category.

"So he's not here," Nicolas said.

The clerk looked at his face and softened, the way people did with Nicolas, which Benjamin had noticed happened more often than Nicolas seemed to notice himself. "Records this old aren't always complete. There was a caretaker here until '98, retired, still lives on the island. Owen. Ask him."

Owen Ryerson lived in a cottage near the old administrative building, and he was eighty-one years old and did not seem surprised by anyone. He kept his door open and his radio on low and invited them in like he'd been expecting them for a decade.

Benjamin started with the date. "Nineteen ninety-six. A boy, somewhere between seven and ten. Not a burial. Someone who lived here."

Owen turned the radio down to nothing. "You mean the one in the clerical wing."

Nicolas made a sound. Not a word. Benjamin heard it anyway.

"There was a boy," Owen said. "Ninety-four to ninety-six. They had him in the little room off the records office, the one with the window. Officially he was a ward in transit. There was no transit. I asked once and got told it was above my pay, and I'd been here thirty years by then." He shook his head slowly. "He read the books. That's what I remember. The city sent over cartons of them, old ledgers, registration books, nothing a child would want. He read them anyway. He'd sit in the window and turn pages like a monk."

"What did they call him?" Nicolas's voice came out flat. He was asking something from far away.

"I called him the boy. Most people did." Owen squinted at the wall, at memory. "But he called himself Jules. That I know, because he corrected me. Once. Very politely. *I'm Jules*, he said. Like it mattered to him."

The room went quiet except for the gulls.

"Where is he now," Nicolas said.

"I don't know. In 'ninety-six a woman came with papers and took him off the island. Not family. An agency. I remember because he left the books. All of them, stacked neat on the desk, like he was coming back for them." Owen looked at Nicolas. "He didn't come back."

They walked down to the dock. The afternoon ferry wasn't due for an hour. There was a concrete breakwater, and beyond it the water, and beyond that the pale vertical smudge of the city, holding itself up in the haze.

Nicolas sat down on the breakwater with his back to the island. He'd been holding something since Owen's cottage, some tautness in his shoulders and jaw, and Benjamin had watched him hold it the way you watch someone carry a full cup up stairs.

Then it let go.

It wasn't loud. Nicolas's shoulders came down, and his breath came out in a long, uneven sound, and he pressed the heels of his hands against his eyes, and he cried. He cried like a person who had forgotten how. His whole body seemed to disagree with it. His hands shook. He didn't try to stop, and he didn't hide his face, and Benjamin sat down beside him on the cold concrete and didn't say anything, because there wasn't anything, because *he's alive* was the only sentence and neither of them could be sure of it yet.

The crying went on for a while. When it stopped, Nicolas wiped his face with the back of his wrist and looked at the water and said, in a wrecked, ordinary voice, "I dreamed about him for twenty years and I thought it was a dream."

Benjamin took off his jacket and put it around Nicolas's shoulders, which was a stupid gesture, since Nicolas was the one with money and better coats and probably didn't need it, and Nicolas pulled it around himself without comment.

"You were a child," Benjamin said. "You didn't know it was a memory. That's not your fault."

"I know whose fault it is." Nicolas's voice had steadied into something harder. "Matheson. She put him on this island and she wrote that they must never be reunited and she was told he was placed in 'ninety-six by someone she couldn't confirm." He turned his head. His eyes were red and very clear. "Someone took him off this island in 'ninety-six, Benjamin. Someone with papers. That's not a placement. That's a pickup."

Benjamin had already thought it. He'd thought it in Owen's doorway and again on the road down the hill. Matheson's confession had said Julian was left here because no family could be found. But someone had come for him. Someone had files and authority and a name to write on a form.

"The discharge record," he said. "If he left in 'ninety-six, there's a record of who signed him out."

"Those records are sixty years old and half the island is a landfill."

"Then we find the half that isn't."

Nicolas almost smiled. It was a ruined, watery almost. "You're relentless," he said. "Do you know that? It's the worst thing about you."

"It's been said."

They sat. The wind came off the water and Nicolas leaned, finally, and rested his head against Benjamin's shoulder, and Benjamin kept very still, because he had spent his whole adult life carefully repairing blanks, and here was a man whose blank was the other half of his own, and neither of them had known it. Somewhere in a room in Vermont, or Queens, or the bottom of a river, a boy named Jules had read old ledgers in a window and corrected a caretaker, politely, about his name. Benjamin thought about the ledger he had restored, the neat columns, the way a name in a column was a kind of promise: *this person existed, here is the proof*. He thought about what he would do to the person who had tried to burn the column.

The ferry horn sounded across the water, low and long, calling them back.

Nicolas stood and handed back the jacket. His face was still blotchy and he didn't bother to hide it. He looked, for the first time since Benjamin had met him, like a man whose grief had a shape instead of an edge.

"Tomorrow," Nicolas said, "I want to see the discharge records. I don't care what it costs."

"We'll go in the morning."

They walked to the dock. The ferry was small and white and already turning, and the workers were loading crates onto the deck, and one of them nodded at Nicolas as they passed, the way people nodded at him everywhere, as if they recognized him from somewhere that wasn't here. Benjamin filed it away. He had a lot of files now. He was learning to keep them in order.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 20: The Ferry to Hart Island · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads