They took the train. Nicolas had wanted to drive — he always wanted to drive, as if motion itself were an answer — but Benjamin had put his foot down on the platform at Penn Station with the simple, immovable logic that neither of them should be behind the wheel of a car right now. So they sat across from each other in a half-empty car as the Hudson unspooled north, and Benjamin waited.
Nicolas had been waiting too, Benjamin realized. Waiting to be asked. Waiting to have no way out of it. He had agreed to tell the story on the condition of Montreal, and now Montreal was the thing in front of them, two hours of track away, and the story was the toll they had to pay to get there.
Nicolas turned his phone face-down on the fold-out tray. "Turn it off," he said to Benjamin. "I don't want this recorded anywhere."
Benjamin powered his phone down and set it beside Nicolas's, face-down, both of them dead.
"My parents," Nicolas said, "drove a 1989 Volvo 240. Wagon. Beige. My father was — I've told you he was an accountant. My mother taught piano out of the front room. We lived in Guilford, Connecticut, which is where people live when they can afford the commute and can't afford Manhattan. Nineteen ninety-four. It was late October."
"Late October," Benjamin repeated, because he was doing the math in his head already. Jules had been taken off Hart Island in 1996. Halvorsen House, 1996. But the discharge record said Jules had entered the system in 1994. The year.
"There was a dinner," Nicolas said. "Some kind of — I don't know what it was. My parents had a dinner, and there were two men I didn't know, and I remember being sent upstairs early, which wasn't normal, because I was allowed to stay up until eight on Fridays and this was a Friday. The two men stayed after I was sent up. I remember the sound of the kitchen door and the car engines in the driveway a long time after."
"How do you remember that if you were six?"
"I don't remember it as a memory. I remember it as the last picture before the blanks. Everything after that is reconstruction." Nicolas's jaw worked. "The police said my father lost control on Route 146, a stretch of road with a bad curve and a worse reputation. Black ice, they said, though it was the twenty-eighth of October and the forecast had been four degrees above freezing all week. The car went off the shoulder, rolled down an embankment, and hit a stand of trees. Both of them died at the scene. I wasn't in the car."
"Where were you?"
"With a sitter. The Sullivans — a couple my parents used sometimes. I woke up the next morning and there were police in the Sullivans' living room and a woman from the state, and they told me my mother and father had gone to heaven, and I remember thinking, that's wrong, only one of them would go to heaven."
Benjamin didn't smile. He watched Nicolas's face and understood that this was the place where something had first been taken out of him — a piece removed so cleanly that nothing had ever confirmed it had been there.
"The accident report," Benjamin said.
"I've read it. Once. When I was twenty-two and the trust opened and I could finally order documents without asking permission. It was ruled an accident. Black ice, unsafe speed, driver error. The word 'run off the road' appeared exactly once, in a witness addendum. And that addendum was attributed to a witness who arrived at the scene before the ambulance."
"Who?"
"The name was a woman's. Matheson."
The train rattled through a bad joint in the track and Benjamin's whole body went still. "Say that again."
"Matheson. There was no first name in the addendum, just an initial. E. I didn't think anything of it for years. I didn't have any reason to."
"Edith Matheson," Benjamin said, very slowly, "ran a network that placed children whose identities had to disappear. She was old enough in 1994 to be in the middle of her work. She was in Connecticut the week my — the week my own placement was sealed. And now you're telling me she was at the scene of your parents' car accident before the ambulance."
"I couldn't have known that when I read the report," Nicolas said. "I read it four years before I ever met you. And then she shows up in a tin box in a dead man's apartment."
They sat with that. The Hudson went by, slate-colored, indifferent.
"What happened after?" Benjamin asked.
"Foster care. Two years. I was moved twice — once within the first month, once after a year. The second placement is where I stopped being Julian Vance." Nicolas's voice was level in a way that took work. "Then the Ashfords. Paul and Margaret. They were old money, no children, and Paul wanted a son he could put his name on. The adoption went through when I was eight. They renamed me. Nicolas is not my name. It's a name they chose off a list of family names, the sort of name a boy gets at a christening, not at eight years old in a courthouse."
"You never said."
"Because I don't answer to it, and I never have, and if I said it out loud I'd have to decide what I do answer to, and I don't know yet." He looked up. "You don't call me Jules."
"I didn't grow up with Jules. I grew up with nothing. The name in my mouth was yours only because of a dream."
"The dream I kept having," Nicolas said, quiet. "A boy in a dark room. I called him the hair-boy for years. Then the dream changed, after I met you — no." He stopped. "That's not true. The dream didn't change. I did. I recognized the room."
"Halvorsen House?"
"No. Before. The dream wasn't the island. It was the night of the accident." Nicolas put his hands flat on the tray. "There were two men. And then there were the police. I've spent the whole train ride deciding whether I should say the last part, and I'm going to say it, and you're not going to like it."
"Say it."
"The Sullivans told the state I arrived at their house at seven-forty in the evening. The police report says my parents' car left the road at approximately eight-fifteen. That means I was already gone when it happened. Which is what you'd expect — I was with a sitter. But I've been over that night a thousand times, and the last thing I actually remember is my father waking me up. Carrying me downstairs. Putting me into the back of a car. And the car wasn't ours."
Benjamin felt the floor move in a way the train had nothing to do with. "Your parents put you in someone else's car."
"My father did. My mother was crying. And my father said — I didn't remember the words until I was twenty-eight, and then I remembered them all at once, in a parking garage, at two in the morning, and I sat down on the concrete and couldn't get up." Nicolas swallowed. "He said, 'Don't look for us.'"
The car went quiet. Somewhere two rows back a woman's phone chimed and she answered it cheerfully and Benjamin heard every syllable of it and could not have said afterward what language it was in.
"Who drove the car?" he asked.
"I don't know. I was six and half asleep. A woman, I think. That's all."
"Edith Matheson."
"Maybe. I don't know."
"You were put in a car by your father, who knew the men in the kitchen, and told not to look for him, and four hours later your parents are dead on a road with black ice that wasn't there, and a woman named Matheson is standing at the scene before the ambulance."
"Yes."
"That's not a coincidence. That's a sequence."
"I know." Nicolas's eyes were going bright at the rims and he made no move to wipe them. "I have known there was a sequence since I was twenty-two years old, sitting in a library in Boston with the accident report in my lap. I have spent twelve years not pulling it. Do you know why?"
"Because if you pulled it, you might find out you were the reason they died."
Nicolas didn't answer. That was the answer.
Benjamin looked out the window. Vermont was coming up on them — the Green Mountains low and dun under the early dark, the first farms, the first roads peeling off the interstate, the little towns with one light each. Somewhere in there was a post office with a box that had been closed since 2003. And past it, three hours further, Montreal. Peggy's card was in Nicolas's coat pocket like a lit match.
"The report," Benjamin said, "will give us the witness address. It'll give us the responding officers, and it'll give us the other addendum names, and if there was a witness standing there before the ambulance, there was a reason she got there that fast, and that reason is either local or she was already watching the house. Either way, the report tells us which."
"But?"
"No but. We pull it." Benjamin turned back from the window. "Not instead of Montreal. Both. I'll call the Connecticut state records office on Monday; a 1994 accident report is a public record if we phrase the request right. Two weeks, maybe. And in the meantime we go to the address on Peggy's card."
Nicolas exhaled, long. "That's the most romantic thing anyone has ever said to me."
"You have a low bar."
"I have a very high bar and you just cleared it by not comforting me." Nicolas wiped his eyes with the heel of his hand, once, and then took a breath and put on the other face, the collector's face. "All right. If we pull the report and it names her — if it puts Edith Matheson at the scene of my parents' death —"
"Then the network didn't just hide children from dangerous relatives," Benjamin said. "It hid children from something that killed people. And two men in suits are asking after us right now."
The train slowed. Outside the window a sign slid past: SOUTH BURLINGTON.
"Matheson told me my mother might be hunting me," Benjamin said, more to himself than to Nicolas. "She kept me off every record because of it. But she never told me — she never told me anything about you, or your parents, or a car, or Connecticut. If she was there that night and she never said a word to me either, then either she didn't know I was connected to you..."
"Or she knew exactly," Nicolas finished, "and she's been managing it from the beginning."
They stood and pulled their bags down as the train eased into the station, and neither of them said the rest of it. That the woman who had made Benjamin had also, possibly, unmade Nicolas. That whatever they found at Peggy's Montreal address, one of them was going to have to decide which of those two things to believe.