Nicolas had the phone on speaker, resting on the workbench between them, and the man's voice came through thin and careful, the way people sound when they've spent a long time deciding how much of themselves to give away.
"Who is this?"
"You're James," Nicolas said. "James Crenshaw."
A pause. Benjamin watched Nicolas's jaw tighten, watched him press both palms flat on the scarred wood as if bracing for a wave.
"Who is this," the man said again, and it wasn't a question this time so much as a warning.
"My name is Nicolas Voss. I've been looking for you for eleven years."
The line hissed. Benjamin could hear something behind it—a television, maybe, or traffic, the low continuous noise of a city. Then the man laughed, one short breath, and it was worse than anger.
"You found me. Congratulations." A sound of movement, a chair. "How."
"Records. A judge's obituary. A petition filed in October 1994." Nicolas's voice was steady, but Benjamin could hear the seam under it. "I know what your father did. I know you weren't missing. I know you were kept."
"You know nothing."
"Then tell me."
"No."
Benjamin leaned toward the phone. Nicolas shot him a look—don't—but Benjamin had already committed. "Mr. Crenshaw," he said. "My name is Benjamin Cole. I'm a book conservator. I've been working on a collection—"
The man's voice changed. It went quiet the way a room goes quiet. "Who's that."
"He's with me," Nicolas said.
"He's working with you."
"Yes."
Another pause, longer. Benjamin could picture him on the other end, deciding, doing some arithmetic he had done many times before. When he spoke again, it was to Benjamin, and it was almost gentle, which made it worse.
"You're working with my brother. You don't understand what he is."
"I think I do," Benjamin said.
"You don't. You can't. He's spent eleven years learning how to be someone else, and every one of those people is a lie he told himself he needed. That's what he is. A man made of rehearsals."
Nicolas closed his eyes.
"I'm not your enemy," Benjamin said. "We're trying to understand what happened to you. What was done to you. There are records—an organization, a network, people who arranged things like you and like me. I think you're part of it. I think I am too."
"Stop."
"I was adopted too. I don't know the truth of it. That's why I'm—"
"I said stop." The man's breath came through the speaker, fast, then controlled. "You want to find the people who did this. You want a witness. You want me to be the boy in the photograph so you can feel better about what you're chasing."
"We want to help you," Benjamin said.
"No," Julian said. "You want to help him. That's not the same thing."
And the line went dead.
Nicolas stared at the phone. He didn't move for a long moment. Then he reached out and ended the call that had already ended, thumb pressing the screen hard, and set the phone down like it might go off again.
"Montreal," he said.
"Nicolas."
"I'm going to Montreal."
"To do what? He just told you—"
"He told me he's afraid of me. That's information." Nicolas was already up, moving across the studio, pulling his jacket off the back of a chair. "He's been afraid of me for eleven years, apparently. I want to know why. I want to know who told him to be."
"He said you're made of rehearsals."
"I heard him." Nicolas stopped at the door. His coat was half on, one sleeve hanging. He looked at Benjamin and something in his face had come loose—not panic, not anger. Something underneath both. "Everything I did, I did to find him. And he knows my name and he hung up. He hung up, Benjamin."
"Because you broke the habit," Benjamin said. "You called as yourself. You told me you spent eleven years never doing that."
"So?"
"So he's never heard your real name before. He's heard the aliases, maybe, or he's heard nothing. And now a stranger calls and says he's been looking for him for eleven years and it's the truth, and Julian has no idea what to do with the truth. Neither would I."
Nicolas looked at him.
"I'm going," he said. "Alone. You don't need to be in this part. You have a studio, a police report with your name in it, a note under your door telling you to drop it. You have Ruth in a hotel and a letter in your drawer. This is my brother. This is mine."
"No."
"Benjamin."
"You listened to me," Benjamin said. "In the diner. You let me decide about the letter instead of deciding for me. I'm telling you the same thing now. You don't get to walk into this alone and call it protecting me."
"It's not about protecting you."
"It's a little about protecting you."
Nicolas's mouth twisted. "He knows me. He knows who I was before. If I bring someone—"
"Then he knows you weren't alone. Which matters, because he said you're made of rehearsals. He only knows the version of you that lied. Let him see one thing that isn't a lie."
The coat sleeve hung there. Outside, a car went past on the wet street, tires hissing. The studio smelled of wheat paste and old paper, the same as it always did, and Benjamin stood in the middle of it and watched Nicolas decide.
"There's a flight at six-forty," Nicolas said finally. "Reagan to Trudeau. I'll get two seats."
"Good."
"I'm not promising this works."
"I know."
"I'm not promising I don't say something wrong and lose him again."
"You won't," Benjamin said.
"You don't know that."
"No," Benjamin said. "But I know you've been waiting eleven years to say anything to him at all. And you finally have a chance. You're not going to spend it on a lie." He paused. "I'll call Fiona, get someone to watch the studio. Bring the folder. The index, the petition, the obituary. Everything."
Nicolas pulled his sleeve on and reached for the door handle, then stopped. He turned back.
"He said you don't understand what he is," he said. "What did that sound like to you?"
Benjamin thought about it. "It sounded like he was talking about somebody who hurt him. Or somebody who could. Or both." He looked at the phone on the workbench. "It sounded rehearsed. Like he'd said it before."
"To who?"
"That's the thing I'd want to find out."
Nicolas nodded slowly, and something in him seemed to land, to stop drifting.
"Six-forty," he said. "Pack light."
He opened the door, and the cold came in, and Benjamin already had his hand on the light switch. Then Nicolas turned one more time, hand on the frame.
"If we go, we go together. All the way."
"All the way," Benjamin said.
Nicolas looked at him for a beat longer than the words needed.
"Then don't," he said—and it wasn't a contradiction, it was the answer, the only way he knew how to say yes, and he was already halfway down the stairs.