The Unbinding

Chapter 68: The Grand Jury

The federal courthouse on Pearl Street had none of the grandeur Benjamin had imagined. It was linoleum and fluorescent light, a metal detector, a hallway that smelled of burnt coffee. He sat on a bench outside the grand jury room for three days and watched people walk in and out: a court reporter with a rolling case, two assistant U.S. attorneys who never once looked at him, a woman from the FBI who nodded at him like they were colleagues.

Julian walked in the first morning wearing a borrowed suit that didn't fit. He didn't look back.

The first day, Benjamin wasn't called. He sat with his phone face-down on his knee and read the same paragraph of a paperback eleven times. The journal was still in a courthouse evidence locker, tagged and bagged, its brown cover photographed from six angles. His own handwriting in the margins - the notes he'd made in Nicolas's apartment three months ago, the ones he'd thought would die with him - had been entered as an exhibit number. He'd stopped thinking of it as a book. It was a number now. 47-B.

The second day, they called him for two hours.

He'd expected the room to be bigger. It was a conference room, actually, with a long table and twelve chairs and a digital recorder blinking red in the center. The jurors looked like people pulled off the street, because they were. A retired teacher. A nurse. A man in a Mets cap who never took it off.

Benjamin answered the way Julian had coached him. Yes, he had been hired by Pearson & Vaughn Rare Books. Yes, an anonymous collector had retained the firm for the restoration. Yes, upon examination he had discovered that the manuscript's physical construction did not match its stated provenance. Yes, he had alerted his employer, and subsequently a second party. The second party being Julian Halloran. The second party being the man who had been, until 1998, known by another name.

He did not say Nicolas's name. Not once. He said "the collector" and let the prosecutors fill in the rest from Julian's earlier testimony. It was the only lie he told, and it was a lie by omission, which felt cleaner than the alternative.

On the third day, the news broke.

He was in the hallway when his phone started buzzing. Then it didn't stop. He stepped outside onto the wet sidewalk and looked at the screen: fourteen missed calls, a wall of texts, a push alert from the Times. He opened it.

**FEDERAL GRAND JURY INDICTS FORMER TREASURY OFFICIAL IN CONNECTION WITH DECADES-OLD CHILD PLACEMENT NETWORK**

The photograph was of Crenshaw, walking into the courthouse, handcuffed, his collar askew. He looked older than Benjamin had pictured. Small. Like a man who had spent forty years making other people carry his decisions and was only now being asked to hold them himself.

By the time Benjamin got back to the hotel in Paramus, Marsh had resigned.

He watched it on the wall-mounted television, the sound low so it wouldn't wake Nicolas, who was asleep on the far bed with his shoes still on. Marsh stood at a podium in a blue suit and read from a prepared statement. She said she was stepping down to spend more time with her family. She said she had always acted in the best interest of the children. She did not mention Benjamin's name. The crawler at the bottom of the screen ran a separate ticker: **RESTORER AT CENTER OF ALLEGED NETWORK HAS NOT COMMENTED; ADOPTION RECORDS UNSEALED BY COURT ORDER**.

Benjamin sat down on the edge of the bed.

He read the ticker three times before it registered. Adoption records unsealed. His adoption records. The judge who had handled the grand jury's evidentiary requests had granted a motion he hadn't known was pending, on the grounds that the records were material to establishing the pattern of the network's placements. Which meant that somewhere in a courthouse basement in Albany, a clerk had pulled a manila folder with his name on it and stamped it PART OF RECORD.

His file. His whole beginning, the blank he had spent thirty-four years repairing over. It was public now. Every reporter in the city could walk in, request it, print it.

He hadn't told Julian to do this. He hadn't been asked. He sat very still and tried to feel something about it and couldn't find anything. Not anger. Not grief. Just a low, flat hum, like a refrigerator running in another room.

Nicolas shifted on the bed. "What time is it."

"Late."

"Did they finish." Nicolas sat up, rubbing his face. He looked older without his glasses. "Julian?"

"He testified for three days. Crenshaw's been indicted. Marsh resigned an hour ago." Benjamin gestured at the screen without turning around. "It's over."

Nicolas didn't answer for a while. The anchors kept talking, speculating, gesturing at maps and timelines. Somewhere in the middle of a segment about extradition, Nicolas said, "Your name's in it."

"Yes."

"The records."

"Yes."

Nicolas got up and stood behind him, close enough that Benjamin could feel the heat off him. He didn't touch him. He just stood there, watching the screen, and Benjamin watched it too, and neither of them said anything for a long time.

"The thing is," Benjamin said finally, "I don't feel anything. I keep waiting to feel something and it's just - " He made a helpless gesture with one hand. "Quiet."

"That's the shock."

"No. That's not it." He turned around. "I spent my whole life thinking if I ever found out the truth I'd feel *something*. Rage. Grief. Relief. Whatever you're supposed to feel. And I'm sitting here watching a senator resign and a man get arrested and my own file get unsealed, and all I want to do is go to sleep."

Nicolas crouched down in front of him, so their faces were level. He looked like he was going to say something careful, something kind, and Benjamin braced for it, and then instead Nicolas just said, quietly, "You should sleep, then."

"I can't. Julian's still at the courthouse. They said he might be there till eleven."

"He'll call."

"He asked me to be his witness. I sat two hours in a room with twelve strangers and I didn't once say the thing that matters." Benjamin's voice cracked a little, and he was embarrassed by it. "I didn't say you kept him alive. I didn't say you gave up your name so he could keep his. I didn't say anything that was true about you."

"You weren't supposed to."

"I know."

Nicolas reached up and, very carefully, touched the side of Benjamin's face. Just two fingers against his jaw. It was the first time either of them had touched the other in three days that wasn't functional - passing a phone, passing a cup, leaning past each other in the tight hotel bathroom. Benjamin closed his eyes.

"Sleep," Nicolas said. "Julian will call. And tomorrow you can feel whatever you want. Today you get to just get through it."

Benjamin opened his eyes. On the television, the anchor had moved on to weather. The crawler at the bottom of the screen still said: **ADOPTION RECORDS UNSEALED BY COURT ORDER**.

"What time do you think the reporters start calling?" Benjamin asked.

"Six a.m."

"It's two."

"Then you have four hours." Nicolas stood and pulled the curtain shut, blocking out the parking lot lights, the highway, the city, everything beyond this one room. "Use them."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 68: The Grand Jury · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads