The Unbinding

Chapter 77: The Ellery Trust's End

The Ellery Trust occupied the fourth floor of a converted warehouse in Long Island City, and Portia Reed was already packing.

Benjamin stood in the doorway with the wind still on him from the walk from the subway, watching her lift a Hollinger box onto a hand truck. She didn't look up. She was seventy-one years old and moved like someone who had decided, some time ago, that the world could wait for her.

"You found us," she said.

"Your assistant gave me the address."

"Marsha gives everyone the address." Portia set the box down. "She thinks transparency is a virtue. It isn't. It's an excuse for never having to make a decision." She finally looked at him. Her eyes were pale and without apology. "You read the letter."

"I read the letter."

"Then you know what my mother did."

Edith Matheson's daughter. He had worked that out on the train, and it had settled into him like a swallowed stone. Benjamin had spent seventy-two hours sitting with it—the idea that the woman standing in this warehouse was the daughter of the woman who had taken him. The math refused to close.

"I didn't come here for an apology," he said.

"Good. There isn't one. She's been dead eleven years and I stopped defending her long before that." Portia gestured him inside. The room smelled of dust and cold coffee and the particular sourness of old paper going slowly to ground. Racks of files stretched back into the dark, and along the far wall, shelved and labeled, sat the thing he had come for: the Trust's archive. Twenty-seven years of it.

"I'm dissolving the Trust," she said. "The paperwork goes through Thursday. The archive goes to the New York Public Library."

Benjamin stopped walking.

"You're donating it."

"I'm donating it." She pulled a leather chair out from a desk and sat. She didn't offer him one. "There's a condition. Would you like to hear the condition, or would you like to argue first?"

"Say it."

"It stays sealed. Fifty years. No researchers, no requests, no exceptions, not even me." She folded her hands. "Effective on transfer."

He looked down the long rows of boxes. Inside them were names. He had learned enough in the last six months to know the shape of what sat on those shelves—files on children placed, children received, children moved from one house to another under arrangements that had never touched a court. His own file was somewhere in that dark. So was Elena's. So was everyone who had ever been run through the machinery his mother—his birth mother—had been pushed through at seventeen.

"Fifty years," he said. "Everyone named in those files will be dead."

"Most of them. Yes."

"That's the point."

"That is a point." Portia's jaw tightened. "It's not the only one."

He walked the aisle because standing still had become impossible. The labels were handwritten, half a system, half a scrawl. MATHE SON, PLACEMENTS 1978-1989. He touched the edge of a box and pulled his hand back.

"You have survivors in there," he said. "People who were told their mothers didn't want them. People who've spent forty years thinking they were abandoned when they were sold. You're going to lock the proof in a basement for fifty years."

"Forty-one of them." She said it flatly, like a number she had carried a long time. "Forty-one living individuals who are still identifiable from these records. I've spent four years with a lawyer going through them one by one. Do you know what happens to a sixty-year-old man when the world learns he was trafficked as an infant? When a newspaper prints his name next to a photo of the family that bought him?"

"They'd know the truth."

"Some of them would. Some of them would lose their marriages." She held up a finger. "Their children would find out the only family they've ever known is criminal. Some of them would be sued by the estates. Some of them—" she paused, and for the first time her voice dropped off its flat register—"some of them do not want to be found. I've asked them. That's what you don't know. I wrote to every one I could trace. Nineteen wrote back. Eleven said the same thing in eleven different ways: don't."

Benjamin stood in the aisle with his hand on the box and said nothing.

"Your mother wrote to me," Portia said. "In 2004. Did you know that?"

He turned.

"She wanted the same thing you want. She wanted the file opened. She wanted it public—she wanted the whole thing on the front page, every name, every placement, her name at the top of it." Portia watched him. "I wrote back and told her what I'm telling you. That the other names in these files aren't hers to spend."

"And she accepted that."

"She stopped writing." A pause. "She died six years later. I don't know whether that means she accepted it or just gave up. I've had a long time to decide whether it matters."

It mattered. Benjamin could feel it mattering, the way the letter had mattered, the way the state block in the provenance scrap had mattered—every time the past reached forward and laid a hand on him. Elena had wanted the truth out. Elena had been told no.

"So you're the gatekeeper," he said. "Same as your mother. Only with better paperwork."

Portia stood up. She didn't flinch, and he understood, watching her, that she'd been waiting months for someone to say exactly that, and had an answer ready.

"My mother's mistake wasn't keeping records. It was never intending for anyone to read them. I intend for someone to read them." She crossed to the hand truck and gripped the handle. "In fifty years there will be no one left in these files to hurt. The story will still be here. The methods will still be here. That's what's useful—not the names. The names are just people."

"And a researcher in 2075 finds out the whole thing and writes a book, and it's history, and nobody's alive to sue. Very tidy."

"Yes."

He hated that it was tidy. He hated more that part of him—the restorer's part, the part that thought in terms of stabilization and reversibility, of what could be done without irreversible damage—recognized the logic and couldn't move it.

"Fifty years is a long time to wait for a fact you already know," he said.

"You already know it." Portia pulled the hand truck toward the door, the box riding high and steady. "You're not asking for yourself. You're asking on behalf of a woman who died sixteen years ago and a boy who was nine and doesn't want to be nine anymore."

He said nothing.

"Take a box," she said. "Audit whatever you like before Thursday. I'd rather you did it than didn't. But when the transfer executes, the condition executes with it, and if you make the archive public after that, you'll do it against my explicit wishes and the explicit wishes of eleven survivors who wrote to me in their own handwriting." She stopped at the door. "I'll assume you'll decide what that costs you."

She left him there.

Benjamin stood in the aisle a long time. Then he went back to the desk, sat in her leather chair, and opened the index.

It was a bound ledger, card stock and careful hand, running alphabetically through twenty-seven years of names. He found MATHE SON, EDITH and read the column beside it. He found his own entry in a later volume, three lines in a registrar's hand he didn't recognize, a date of surrender and a placement code and no mother's name at all—a blank where Elena should have been, running down the page like a cut.

He photographed it. He photographed the index pages front to back, forty-two shots, phone braced steady against the desk lamp, and then he sat and looked at the printout on the wall—the Trust's own letterhead, its dissolution certificate sitting in a tray with a sticky note that read THURSDAY, DROP 2PM—and he made his decision the way he made every decision, quietly, without telling anyone, and without the foolish belief that it would stay cheap.

Fifty years. He could wait. He was good at waiting. He had eleven years of a sealed letter to prove it, and a discipline for the preservation of things that were not meant to be opened, and an index in his pocket now that would be his copy and his alone.

He did not know yet what he intended to do with it. He only knew he intended to have it.

He pocketed the phone, replaced the ledger exactly as he'd found it, and walked out through the rows of boxes toward the elevator, past the shelf labeled MATHE SON and the row of files that had waited for him all his life. Behind him the warehouse was empty and getting emptier, and Portia Reed was already downstairs, loading a stranger's childhood into the back of a van.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 77: The Ellery Trust's End · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads