The Unbinding

Chapter 81: Hart Island Records

Nicolas fell asleep on the couch around midnight, the photograph of Julian still on the cushion beside him, face up. Benjamin waited until his breathing had evened out, then took his phone into the kitchen and closed the door most of the way.

He'd photographed the index pages at the Trust in a hurry, bracing the pages flat with his thumb, moving the ceiling light out of the frame. The images were uneven but legible. He'd been scrolling them for two days, telling himself he was cataloguing, telling himself he was being careful. He was stalling and he knew it. The Hart Island line had been sitting there the whole time.

Row 1,438. See Hart Island. 1994.

He'd told himself it could be anything. A cost entry. A burial contract for a pauper's field. The Trust had a dozen financial tentacles you'd never untangle without the actual ledgers.

He typed Hart Island into the search bar of the municipal records portal and got the familiar wall. The island belonged to the city, its records sealed under a stack of privacy statutes that predated everyone at the table. Burials were public. Everything else was not.

So he went around it.

It took him an hour to find the right door. A digitization grant, ironically, awarded to a historical society in the late nineties, which had funded a scanning project for "institutional child welfare archives, restricted access." He didn't have credentials for the repository. He had something better: a conservator's reputation and the fact that archives administrators loved being useful to people who knew what things were worth. He sent an email at 12:40 a.m. to a name that had surfaced in the grant paperwork, a registrar at a state repository upstate, and claimed he was doing provenance research on a set of photographs he'd been asked to authenticate.

She wrote back at 7:15 the next morning.

By eleven he'd signed three forms and agreed to a supervised viewing, no photography, no note-taking apparatus beyond pen and paper. Fine.

He crossed into the reading room at a quarter past two. The registrar's name was Dana. She was in her fifties, brisk, and she did not want to make conversation, which he appreciated. She wheeled out two boxes on a cart and set them on the table between them, then sat in the corner with her laptop where she could watch him.

"Anything in particular?" she asked.

"Facility rosters," he said. "Nineteen ninety-one to ninety-six. Sibling records especially, if you have them."

She looked up. "Sibling records don't exist for that period."

"Then whatever survived."

She went back to her laptop. He opened the first box.

The paper smelled the way all forgotten paper smelled, dust, glue, cold basement. The top layer was administrative: budgets, staff rotations, quarterly reports with the word COMPLIANCE stamped diagonally across them in faded red. He went through it fast, page by page, watching for the word Hart or Hart Island, which appeared eleven times in box one alone, which was eleven times more than he wanted.

The Trust had been paying an annual fee. Every autumn. For decades.

Box two was smaller. Inside were folders, the cheap manila kind that disintegrates at the spine, and each folder was labeled with a range of intake numbers. He opened the one marked 1991 to 1996 and found what the digitization grant had paid for: intake cards, photographed, printed, stapled. Each card listed a first name, a date, a transferring agency, and a disposition code. There were hundreds. He started at the top and worked down, pen flat against the paper, and forty minutes in he found him.

JULIAN. No surname, no known surname. Intake: 03/11/1991. Transferring agency: Ellery Family Trust. Disposition: 09/08/1995.

He stared at the date. Four years. Nicolas had told him the placement had lasted a year, maybe less, that he'd been too young to hold onto it. But the records said four years. Four years in the same facility on a spit of land in the Long Island Sound where the city buried its unknown dead.

Benjamin wrote the intake number in his notebook. Then he noticed the second card clipped behind Julian's, and pulled it free.

A sibling inquiry. Filed 1997.

He read it twice before his hand understood what it was doing, which was trembling, slightly, against the table.

The inquiry had been submitted by an unaccompanied minor, age ten, currently in a different placement in Essex County. It requested contact information for the subject JULIAN, previously resident, on the grounds of sibling relationship. It was signed with a single initial. N.

Under that, in a different hand, someone had stamped it.

DENIED. The stamp was old, the ink faded, but the handwriting in the margin was notarized and clear: E. Matheson, Trustee, personally reviewed. Recommendation: no contact. Maintain separation.

Benjamin sat back in the chair. The room hummed. Dana's keyboard clicked. Somewhere down the hall a copier ran its cycle and stopped.

He flipped the card over. On the back, in that same hand, a second line had been added later, dated the following spring.

Re: appeal, second inquiry from same minor, 1998. Denied. See file 22-C. Subject has no living family of record. Cease correspondence.

No living family of record. Nicolas had been eleven years old when Edith Matheson wrote that sentence. He'd been sitting in a group home in Essex County writing letters to a brother who, as far as the Trust's records were concerned, no longer had a family at all. And Edith Matheson had read those letters. She had picked up a pen and personally stamped them closed.

Dana looked up. "Everything all right?"

"Fine," Benjamin said. His voice came out level, which surprised him. "How long do I have?"

"Another hour."

He went through the rest of the box, but he wasn't really reading anymore. He was looking for something he could use, a reason the denials were filed where a records request would find them, a signature that would hold up if he ever needed to prove it. He found three more, all with the same stamp, all with the same marginal hand. Sibling inquiries, denied, across nine years. Different children. Same trustee.

He copied down every intake number and every date, and when Dana stood up to stretch he closed the box himself and pushed it to the edge of the table like he was eager to be rid of it.

Outside, the December air hit him flat in the face. He stood on the steps for a full minute with his phone in his hand.

The obvious thing was to tell Nicolas. That was the agreement, that was the point of everything they'd built since the warehouse, since Julian's name had first surfaced, since the night Nicolas had woken up shouting a name Benjamin couldn't hear from the other room. No more secrets. They'd said it out loud.

The other thing, the thing his hands knew before his head did, was that Nicolas had a crack running through him about Julian that had never healed, would probably never heal, and Benjamin was about to take it and press down on it with a document.

He put the phone in his pocket. He'd tell him tonight. He'd tell him tonight.

He was halfway to the subway when it went off. Nicolas.

"Where are you?" Nicolas said. Not accusing. Just asking, the way he asked now, which was its own kind of trust, which was worse.

"Research," Benjamin said. "I'll be back by six."

A pause. "You sound weird."

"I'm outside. It's cold."

Another pause, longer. "All right," Nicolas said. "I'll make something."

Benjamin hung up and stood on the corner with traffic going by, and understood that he had about four hours to decide whether the boy who had written those letters in 1997 deserved to be protected from what Edith Matheson had written back.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 81: Hart Island Records · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads