The Unbinding

Chapter 85: Nicolas's Real Name

The courthouse on Centre Street smelled like floor wax and old paper, which Benjamin supposed was why he didn't mind waiting. He'd been in worse rooms.

Nicolas sat beside him on the bench outside the clerk's office, knee bouncing, a manila folder on his lap that he kept opening and closing like he was checking the contents hadn't changed. Petition for Name Change. Order to Show Cause. A certified copy of a birth certificate that said Nicolas Matheson, which had never been true, and a stamped receipt from the newspaper that had run the required notice in the legal section for three consecutive weeks, which was the state's way of asking the world if anyone objected. Nobody had.

"You've read those documents nine times," Benjamin said.

"Ten." Nicolas closed the folder again. "I keep thinking they'll find something wrong. Some fee I didn't pay. Some box I didn't check."

"You paid. You checked. The clerk told you four separate times."

"The clerk is not the judge."

The clerk was, in fact, not the judge, and the judge kept them waiting another forty minutes while the calendar ran long, and when they were finally called, the proceeding took less than four minutes. The judge was a gray-haired woman with reading glasses pushed up into her hair who asked Nicolas two questions: whether the application was made freely and whether the purpose was fraud. Nicolas said yes and no, respectively. The judge signed the order, and the gavel was more of a tap, and they were back in the hallway before Benjamin had fully understood it was over.

Nicolas stood there with the signed order in his hand. He looked the way people looked when a long-held breath finally got released—unsteady.

"That's it?"

"That's it," Benjamin said. "Tuesday you go to Social Security. Then the DMV. Then the bank. Then the rest of your life."

"Right." Nicolas folded the order along its crease. "The rest of my life."

They didn't talk much on the walk to the subway. Canal Street was loud with delivery trucks and a man selling loose roses out of a bucket, and Nicolas walked through all of it with his chin up and his eyes somewhere else, and Benjamin gave him the room. At the platform Nicolas said, "Nicholas Vance," like he was testing the shape of it in his mouth. "That's the name on the birth certificate Julian pulled out of the house. Not Matheson. Vance was our father's—our actual father, the one Edith erased. So it's not even a name I invented. It's just the one that got taken."

"It's yours now," Benjamin said.

Under the fluorescent lights, the downtown train came grinding in, and Nicolas Vance, twenty-eight years old and legally as of that morning no longer a Matheson, stepped onto it without looking back.

The townhouse took three weeks to clear out and four more to sell.

Benjamin came uptown on the closing day because Nicolas asked him to, and stood in the emptied front room where the parquet floors showed pale rectangular ghosts of rugs that had been there since before Nicolas was born. The stagers had been through; there were white orchids on a glass table and nothing else. It looked like a photograph of a place rather than the place.

The buyer was a fund manager from Connecticut who shook Nicolas's hand without knowing or caring whose son he was, and that was the best part, Nicolas said afterward on the sidewalk. "Forty minutes. He asked about the boiler and the wiring and the water pressure. He did not once ask how I felt about selling my family home."

"How do you feel about it?"

"Like I just paid off a debt I didn't take out." Nicolas looked up at the facade, the tall windows, the wrought-iron railing Julian had supposedly once climbed as a child. "I put everything from the estate into a lawyer's escrow. There's a trust for Julian—he doesn't know yet, don't tell him, I want to surprise him after he gets settled. And the rest..."

"You kept some," Benjamin said.

"I kept enough for a year. I don't want more than that." He pulled out his phone. "Watch."

He opened the banking apps one by one and closed them. The accounts with the shell names—Vincent Hale, Marcus Reyes, two more Benjamin had never seen. He'd used those names for years, ghosting through the city under faces that weren't his, because a Matheson name in certain rooms got you either robbed or courted and he'd wanted neither. One by one the balances went to zero, wired out to the trust, to Julian, to a new account under the new name, and then gone—closed, dormant, dead.

The phone pinged with a final confirmation and Nicolas turned the screen toward Benjamin like a kid showing off a report card.

"All gone."

Benjamin looked at the empty accounts. Somewhere in one of them had been the money Nicolas paid him with, back at the beginning, before either of them knew what they were buying. He didn't say that.

"Good," he said. "Now you can get a library card under your own name."

Nicolas laughed, startled. "Is that the first thing you'd do?"

"It's the first thing I *did* do, after I got out of the system. I was nineteen. It was a Tuesday." He shrugged. "You don't have to."

"No," Nicolas said. "No, I think I do."

The East Village apartment was a third-floor walk-up on Seventh Street, two rooms and a kitchen the size of a closet, with a fire escape window that looked out on a courtyard full of string lights and someone's overgrown fig tree. No doorman. No intercom. The buzzer didn't work, so you had to shout up or text, and Nicolas texted *I'm here come up* and Benjamin came up and found him sitting on the floor amid unopened boxes of books, holding a painting in his lap that he hadn't yet hung.

It was one of the pieces from the townhouse—small, oil, a harbor at dusk. Benjamin had seen it in three different rooms over the past year.

"My mother bought this in Rockport," Nicolas said. "Edith. When I was nine. She said it was a good investment." He turned the canvas in his hands. "It's not. It's not worth anything. I had it appraised to be sure. Eight hundred dollars, at the most generous. She bought it because she liked it, and then she hung it in the hallway where no one went."

"Are you keeping it?"

"I don't know yet." He set it down against the wall, facing the plaster. "It's the only thing in this apartment that has any history. Everything else is—" he gestured at the boxes, the pressed-wood bookshelf, the mattress on the floor still in its plastic. "I bought a mattress and a coffee maker and a lamp. That's my whole life now. A mattress, a coffee maker, and the ghost of a bad painting."

Benjamin sat down on the floor across from him. The radiator ticked. Somewhere below, someone was playing a guitar badly and with great feeling.

"I talked to my lawyer this morning," Nicolas said. "About the basement ledger. Frances's ledger. It's not in the estate inventory—I checked every line. But the trust has a storage unit in Queens nobody's inventoried in fifteen years. He's going to get a court order to open it. Might take a month."

"A month," Benjamin said.

"A month." Nicolas picked at the plastic wrap on the mattress. "And there's something else. Julian called. He's been talking to some of the people I used to know—the ones who don't have job titles—about work. Bartending, maybe. Or courier runs. I told him no. He said I wasn't his mother." A humorless breath. "Which is fair. Benjamin, I don't want him near those people. I've spent ten years making sure nobody could trace me through them, and now he's going to walk right in the front door."

"Then tell him why."

"He won't listen to why."

"Then tell him anyway," Benjamin said. "The things we don't say are the things that get people hurt."

Nicolas looked at him for a long moment. In the dim light of a single unshaded bulb, he looked younger than he did in the townhouse, and less careful, like a man who'd taken off a coat he'd been wearing so long he'd forgotten it was on.

"There's a lot you haven't said to me," he said. Not accusing. Just stating it, the way he'd have stated the boiler pressure.

Benjamin's chest went tight. The Hart Island record. The Harold Matheson photograph from Sussex County. The copied Trust index with its entry pointing at children and 1994 and a woman's pen denying a sibling's inquiry. He had resolved a dozen times to tell him, and a dozen times found a reason not to, and every reason was a lie he was telling himself.

"I know," he said.

"Are you going to?"

"Yes." Benjamin met his eyes. "But not tonight."

"Okay." Nicolas nodded slowly, like he was filing it somewhere he could find it later. "Okay."

He stood up, crossed to the window, and lifted the sash. Warm September air came in—cigarettes and someone's pasta and the strings of the courtyard lights. Down on the street a car door slammed and a woman laughed and the city went on being itself, indifferent, endless.

"People have been telling me who I am since I was three years old," Nicolas said, half out the window. "Edith. The men who worked for her. The lawyers. Crenshaw. Even Julian, a little—he wanted his little brother back, which meant he wanted me to be three." He turned around. "I signed a piece of paper this morning and legally erased the last of them. But I have no idea who I actually am. It's like I spent thirty years learning to be nobody and now I have to learn something else from scratch."

He came back and sat down, closer this time, close enough that Benjamin could see the faint scar above his eyebrow from something he'd never explained.

"So," Nicolas said. "Who are you now?"

Benjamin heard the question land somewhere underneath his ribs. He thought about the index in his desk drawer, the truth he was carrying, the deadline of the archive transfer two days out. He thought about how every person he'd ever loved had been someone he'd eventually lied to, and how he was doing it again, right now, just by sitting here.

But Nicolas was looking at him, and not the way he usually looked at people—measuring, guarded, three exits mapped. He was looking at him the way you look at something you've decided to keep.

"I don't know yet," Nicolas said quietly. "But I'd like to find out with you."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 85: Nicolas's Real Name · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads