The gorge cut through the ridge like a wound that had never healed, its walls close enough in places that a careless rider could lose a wingtip to the stone. Kael had watched the cadets go from the training ring, and by the time he reached the cliff edge they were already strung out along the first bend, Maren at the front with the easy arrogance of someone who had flown the line a hundred times.
Vex stirred on Kael's shoulder, claws tightening. The dragonet was barely the length of his forearm, all wing and appetite, but his head came up at the sight of the others in the air.
"No," Kael said quietly. "We're not—"
"You're not what?" Maren's voice came from behind him. The cadet lord had circled back, and he sat his grey dragon with his chin lifted, looking at Kael the way a man looked at a stain on a tablecloth. "You're not going to fly, is that it? Sensible. The runt would tire before the second bend."
Kael kept his face still. "Captain said I drill on the line."
"The captain says a great many things." Maren's dragon shifted beneath him, restless. "You know what the other cadets have been saying about you? That the ledger made a mistake. That some clerk wrote your name in the wrong column and one day the ink will lift and you'll be back out the gate where you came from." He smiled. "I told them they were wrong. I told them the ledger doesn't make mistakes. It just takes time to correct them."
"Then why are you talking to me?"
"Because I want to see it." Maren leaned forward. "A race. The gorge, top to bottom, first to the river landing wins. Your mountain-bred whistling against my reins. That's the whole of it, and when you lose, you stop pretending you belong up here."
Kael's shoulder throbbed where Vex's claws had torn it. He thought about the regulation line coiled in his quarters, unused, and about the way Vex had flown at dawn when no one was watching — like something wild remembering it had wings.
"Why would I race you?" he said. "I lose either way."
"Because if you don't, I'll tell the breeding masters what I saw at the Choosing." Maren's voice dropped, pleasant and cruel. "A dragon that refused every heir in the hall and chose the gate boy. They'll want to know why. They'll open the ledger and they'll look at you, and by the time the inquisitors finish with their questions, you'll wish you'd taken my race."
Kael's mouth went dry. He remembered Adrian's warning on the landing field, the careful way the captain had said the dragon was off the ledger, the sentence he had not finished.
"And if I win?" Kael said.
"You won't."
"Say it anyway."
Maren shrugged. "If you win, I'll say nothing. I'll sign whatever you like. I'll tell the cadets I was wrong." His smile sharpened. "But you won't."
Vex whistled low, three rising notes, the signal Kael had taught him for *hunt*. Kael had not taught it to him. Vex had simply known it, the way he had simply known to climb onto Kael's shoulders in a hall full of nobles.
"Let me ask my captain," Kael said.
Adrian was in the map room with his back to the door, a flight ledger open under one hand. He did not turn when Kael came in.
"No," he said.
"You don't know what I'm going to ask."
"Maren found you on the cliff edge. There's a wager circulating in the barracks, and the only thing that would bring you to me in the middle of a drill is a proposal you already know I'll refuse." Adrian turned. There was grey at his temples that Kael had not noticed before, and the afternoon light made his face look older than it did in the air. "So. The gorge."
"A race. First to the river landing."
"And if you refuse?"
"He threatens to take it to the breeding masters." Kael kept his voice flat. "He saw everything at the Choosing. He'll tell them the dragon chose wrong, and they'll pull the ledger, and I'll be answering questions I can't answer."
Adrian was quiet for a moment. Then he set down his pen. "Maren's father sits on the Breeding Council. He has been angling for a position in the masters' hall since before you were born. If his son brings them a scandal, they will use it. They will use you to do it." He crossed to the window. "Which is why you will not fly. I'll handle Maren."
"How?"
"I'll tell him the dragon is under evaluation. That it isn't cleared for gorge terrain." Adrian's jaw tightened. "It's a small lie. They'll accept it."
"And in a week? A month? He'll still be here, and so will I, and he'll still have seen what he saw."
"Yes," Adrian said. "He will."
The captain's honesty landed harder than a refusal. Kael stood there with Vex warm against his neck, and for a moment he wanted very badly to be the kind of man who did as he was told.
"Then let me fly it," he said. "If I win, he keeps quiet. That's a bargain that costs you nothing."
"It costs me a cadet," Adrian said. "The gorge is flown with reins because the winds shear at the second bend. Your whistling is not a system. It is a habit, and habits kill people."
"He answered the whistle at dawn."
"At dawn there was no one else in the air." Adrian's voice rose, just barely. "You want me to send you into a race you cannot win, against a rider who has flown that gorge since he was twelve, on a dragonet that has never been tested beyond a training ring, because a spoiled boy made a threat he cannot actually carry out without exposing his own father to the same questions." He stopped. Breathed. "The answer is no."
Kael nodded slowly. "Understood, Captain."
Adrian looked at him for a long moment, suspicion flickering. "Say it back to me."
"The answer is no."
"Good." Adrian turned back to his ledger. "Go help the quartermaster with the tack. Stay off the cliff."
Kael went to the cliff.
He told himself it was only to watch. The cadets were still in the air, working the bend in pairs, and Maren was circling the start marker with the lazy patience of a man who had already won something. When he saw Kael on the ledge, he banked and came in low, and his dragon's downdraft threw up a spray of grit.
"Changed your mind?" he called.
Kael checked Vex's harness, the stitching he had reinforced himself, the short lead he'd clipped in place of a line he didn't have. "River landing. First one down."
Maren's grin was almost warm. "Rules are rules. No touching. No cutting the bend." He lifted his reins. "On three."
"On three."
They went.
Vex launched like something released from a trap, wings snapping wide, and for three heartbeats Kael forgot the race entirely — forgot Maren, forgot Adrian, forgot the ledger and the sword reversed in the hall. There was only the gorge opening beneath him, red stone and cold air, and a small black dragon screaming with joy.
They took the first bend high and clean. Maren was below and to the left, riding the updraft along the wall, and Kael heard himself laugh out loud because Vex was faster, Vex was faster, and the second bend was coming up with its shearing wind and his dragon was already reading it, banking before Kael's whistle, as if the two of them had flown this a hundred times.
Then Maren came up beside him.
There was no warning. A flash of grey, a reach across the gap between them, and something bright and short in Maren's hand — a boot knife, Kael realized, and then he realized nothing else because Vex shrieked and wrenched sideways, and there was blood on the black scales, a long line along the flank, shallow but open and bleeding into the wind.
"Sorry!" Maren shouted, already pulling ahead. "Rules are rules! No touching!"
Kael didn't answer. Vex was losing altitude, wings beating unevenly, whistling the high distress note Kael had never heard him make. The river landing was a smudge of green far below, and the bend was coming, and Kael stopped racing.
He brought Vex down in a flat scrape of gravel on a sandbar, and the moment the dragonet hit ground he folded his wings and cried, a thin, reedy sound, and pressed his head against Kael's chest.
"It's all right," Kael said, hands shaking as he peeled back the harness strap. "It's shallow. It's just shallow." He tore a strip from his own shirt because he had nothing else, and bound the wound while Vex trembled against him, and above them the gorge echoed with the sound of grey wings passing the finish marker alone.
Maren landed a quarter hour later, dismounted, and walked over with his gloves under his arm.
"I won," he said.
Kael looked up from the dragon in his lap. "You cut him."
"I won," Maren repeated, "and you lost, and the bargain stands. I'll keep quiet." He looked at the blood on the bandage, and something moved behind his eyes that might have been shame, quickly buried. "You should have let him tire. You would have finished second, and no one would have bled."
He turned and walked back toward his dragon.
Kael sat on the sandbar with Vex's head in his lap and the river going past, and he thought, very clearly, about what he was going to say to Adrian, and how little of it would matter, because Maren had already gone back to the barracks to tell the others that the gate boy had lost.
But Maren had also been wrong about one thing, and Kael held onto it the whole walk back.
Vex had beaten him to the second bend. Even bleeding, even crying, even with a hand-cut gash along his flank — Vex had still been ahead when the knife came out. The race had not been lost in the air.
It had been lost because Kael had kept the whistled signals, and Maren had kept a knife, and only one of them was against the rules.