The Unfinished Shelter

Chapter 39: The Trial Begins

The courthouse in Port Azure had been a customs house before the flood, and it still smelled faintly of salt and old rope. The ceiling fans turned too slowly to move the air. Matthias sat in the second row behind the bar, where Leon could turn his head and find him without searching.

Leon sat straight-backed at the plaintiff's table, Kael beside him, the blueprint tube upright against the table leg like something that might be asked to stand and speak for itself.

Dorian sat two rows back on the other side, in a charcoal suit, hands folded. He looked like a man waiting for a train he had already paid for.

Judge Arrieta took the bench at 9:20. Small woman, gray at the temples, a reading lamp she switched on even though the morning sun came through the tall windows. She spent four minutes reading the file without expression, then said, "Mr. Voss. Your motion."

Voss stood. He had the deposition lawyer's flatness, but wider in the shoulders, and he used his hands when he talked, small precise chopping motions.

"Your Honor, this is a case built on the testimony of a man who cannot remember his own signature. Mr. Idris claims to have designed a shelter. He cannot produce a contract. He cannot produce a client. He cannot tell this court the first name of the man who commissioned the work. He has been treated at the public clinic for retrograde amnesia. The defense does not say this to insult him. The defense says it because a court cannot found a finding of fraud on a witness who cannot found a memory."

"He produced the drawings," Arrieta said.

"He produced *drawings*." Voss lifted a folder. "Composite pages, unsigned, in a hand that Dr. Haddad has not been shown to have used before the accident. My client's firm has forty years of stamped, filed, notarized work. The plaintiff has a tube and a scar."

Matthias's hands had gone cold. He kept them on his knees.

Kael stood. "Your Honor, the defense's motion is an insult dressed as medicine. Mr. Idris is not the only witness. We have an inspector with dated field notes, bank records, and a license plate. We have a noncompliance notice that Meridian's own counsel was served on the sidewalk—"

"You were served," Voss said, mild.

"—after the notice had been notarized, yes, and the filing timestamp in your own complaint shows you drafted it before the article ran. Which means you had the article before the public did."

Arrieta's pen stopped. "Counsel will make that argument at trial, not at motion."

"Understood," Kael said. "But on the fitness question: Mr. Idris passed the deposition. He identified the structural logic of every page. The defense's expert has not examined him."

"Then examine him," Arrieta said. "Motion on fitness is denied. Motion on the blueprint's authenticity is a question for trial. Mr. Voss, you'll have your witness. Ms. Kael, call yours."

Matthias hadn't expected to be called first.

He stood, walked to the witness box, and read the oath off the card because his eyes didn't want to focus on anything else.

Kael came at him gently at first. Name, occupation, place of practice. The morning Leon was brought in. Matthias described the gurney, the water in the man's lungs, the two broken ribs, the swelling along the left temple.

"And the marks on his forearms," Kael said.

"Old scars," Matthias said. "Burn scars, both forearms, wrist to elbow. Healed irregularly. Consistent with hot metal or scalding liquid, over a period of—" he stopped, did the arithmetic he had already done a dozen times— "months. Not one event."

"Objection," Voss said. "The witness is speculating."

"Overruled," Arrieta said. "He's a physician."

Voss took him on cross. He stood close to the box, which put Matthias below him, which was the point.

"Doctor, did you treat Mr. Idris before the morning of the flood?"

"No."

"So you cannot say what his memory was like before."

"No."

"You cannot say whether the amnesia is real."

"I treated the man's injuries. The CT showed a subdural hematoma and diffuse axonal shearing. Those are not things people invent."

"People invent a great many things." Voss let that sit. "You are not a neurologist."

"I'm an emergency physician. I stabilized him and I read his scans and I called the consult, and the consult agreed with the scans."

"Did the consult certify him as incompetent to testify?"

"No."

"Did anyone?"

"No."

Voss turned a page he didn't need to turn. "Doctor, you've spent considerable time with Mr. Idris since. Have you ever seen him be mistaken about a fact?"

"Yes."

The courtroom shifted. Voss's pen paused.

"When?"

"He thought the archive closed at six. It closes at five. We missed it." Matthias kept his voice level. "He thought the bus came every twenty minutes. It comes every twelve. He was wrong twice about small things that had nothing to do with what happened to him. He remembers the drawings, the site, the man who hired him, and the load count on the concrete trucks. He doesn't remember his own name. Memory doesn't work the way the defense wants it to work. It keeps what it needs."

Arrieta looked at him over the lamp.

"Doctor," Voss said, quieter now, "is it not possible that Mr. Idris came to you in a vulnerable state and that you—how do I put this—*organized* him around a story?"

"No," Matthias said. "The blueprint was in the tube when they pulled him out of the water. I didn't put it there. The water did."

Voss smiled thinly and sat down.

Kael called Leon.

He walked to the box and the room got very still, and Matthias understood that the room had been waiting to see whether the man matched the rumor. Leon looked ordinary. Dark hair, scar at the temple, hands that had learned the shape of a pencil again in the weeks on Sofia's floor. He held the tube against his side like a man carrying a child through a crowd.

Kael walked him through the shelter. The roof he had designed to shed the meltwater. The footing anchors he had specified. The number of trucks the site had signed for versus the number of loads he had counted off the window ledge of the site office.

"Eight signatures," Leon said. "Seven pour dates. One pour flagged as short. I wrote it down. I drew a diagram of the load. I drew the rebar as it was set—not as it was specified."

"And you took this to your employer."

"I took it to Geraldo Ruiz, the inspector. He wasn't there. A man called Pascal took my report, told me it would be handled, told me not to come back to the site. I went back to the site. That was the mistake."

"What happened on the last night you remember clearly?"

Leon was quiet a moment. "I don't remember clearly. I remember rain on the roof of my car and the smell of wet rebar and a light in the site office that should not have been on. I remember three men. I remember someone using my own notebook page to copy Ruiz's signature. I remember being put in the water. After that it's blanks with edges."

"Objection," Voss said. "Memory is not evidence."

"Overruled," Arrieta said. "It's what he has."

Voss stood for cross. He came at Leon softly, which was worse.

"Mr. Idris. Your own deposition establishes you were drinking that night. Your clinic record notes alcohol in your system."

"One drink."

"Two. The file says two."

"Then two."

"You were under stress. You had been demoted, had you not? From lead designer to site supervising—a reduction."

"I asked for the transfer to the site. So I could see the pours."

"Or because you were fighting with your employer and wanted a record."

"Both," Leon said.

Voss paused, thrown.

"Both is not an answer a liar gives," Arrieta said. "Continue, counsel."

Voss picked up a photograph. "This is the hallway outside Mr. Idris's apartment, dated the morning after the flood. The neighbors told responding officers they heard a man shouting in the stairwell at approximately two a.m. Is that you, Mr. Idris?"

"I don't know."

"You don't know."

"No."

"You don't know if you were shouting in your own stairwell."

"I don't know if I was in my own stairwell."

"Then how," Voss said, turning to the bench, "does this court accept a blueprint held together by a man who cannot say where he was?"

"Because the concrete that killed eleven people didn't ask him where he was," Leon said.

The room made a sound and Arrieta did not call it down.

Voss finished without landing it. Marcus consulted with Kael while the clerk called the afternoon session, and Matthias had already begun to breathe when the doors at the back of the courtroom opened and a man in a gray suit walked down the center aisle, unhurried, carrying a thin leather folder.

He stopped at the defense table and said something to Voss, who read a note, nodded once, and looked up at the bench.

"Your Honor," Voss said. "The defense moves to call a new witness. The inspector's report is a forgery, and we have the man who prepared the forgery."

Arrieta looked at the clock. "Name."

Voss glanced at the gray-suited man. "Pascal Reyes, Your Honor. Former site liaison for Meridian Structures."

Leon's hand had gone white around the tube. Matthias looked at the doors and thought, we have one afternoon before he tells them where Elias is.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 39: The Trial Begins · The Unfinished Shelter · Lumen Reads