The square had emptied by the time Elin found the strength to stand on the fountain's rim. Water had frozen in the basin overnight, cracking the skin of ice. She climbed the stone ledge with Sera's slate under one arm, sixty-one names white as bone in the grey light, the back of it still blank. No chalk left.
"People need to hear it before the vote," Maud said. She stood at the fountain's base with her sleeves pushed past her elbows, as though the cold did not touch her. Fifteen others stood behind her, women the ritual had returned to themselves. They stood the way people stand when they have nowhere in particular to go.
Elin looked down at them. She had spent a week thinking in terms of postings and votes and contracts—of what could be written on a slate and what could be argued before a council. Tobin had said a list is not a scar. She finally understood what he meant. The city could sit through a confession and go home to supper unchanged, because a list was easy to file away. A workshop was not.
"Sera's slate is full," Elin said. "And it's the wrong shape for this. A posting tells the city what the guild did. That's the truth. But it leaves every one of you still holding the cost of it."
"We know the cost," Maud said, mild.
"I know you do. I don't want the city to know it as a sentence it reads. I want it to know it as a thing it does."
She slid off the fountain. Her hands were still raw from the ritual stitches, the fingertips split at the tips, and she kept them in her pockets.
"No posting," Elin said. "A workshop. On Hasket Street, in the old dye works—it's empty, it's guild-adjacent enough that nobody can seize it and separate enough that nobody can lock it. Not a branch of the guild. Not mine. Run by a circle, and the majority of that circle is the women whose memories the trade took."
Someone in the back said, quietly, "You're giving it away?"
"I'm saying I won't hold it."
The guildhall cutters came at noon, because Elin had sent Tobin word she would be in the front room of the dye works and anyone who wanted to ask a question should come and ask it to her face.
Nine of them came. Tobin came too, standing apart from the others with his arms crossed, which told Elin more than anything he'd said in a week.
The dye works smelled of old indigo and wet stone. Racks for drying cloth still ran along both walls, six deep, and Elin had cleared the center floor and set her mother's ledger on a barrel beside the door, closed, because she did not want to look at it while she talked.
"You broke the guild," said a cutter named Parren. He was old enough to have known Elin's mother, and he said it flat, no anger in it, which was worse. "Truth or not. You took a craft that has been kept whole for two hundred years and you cracked it down the middle."
"It was cracked before I touched it," Elin said. "It was just cracked in the places nobody had to look at."
"That doesn't mend anything."
"No. Mending is the work, though, and it takes longer than breaking. I'm asking which of you wants to do it."
Parren didn't answer. Two others left before she finished the sentence. She watched them go and made herself not call after them—one of the two, a woman named Isle, had been kind to her when she was a novice, and it cost something to let her walk.
Seven stayed.
"The craft was guarded because a guarded craft is a powerful one," Elin said, to the seven. "That was the guild's whole argument, and it was a good one, and it was also the same argument the slavers make about ships. What made the memory trade possible was never the buyers. It was that the reading of stitches was a secret held by twelve masters, so no one in this city could ever look at their own marriage gown and ask what had been written into it. You want to know what breaks that? Not a confession. Not a vote." She took her hands out of her pockets and held them up, split fingertips and all. "Teaching it. To anyone who asks."
Tobin uncrossed his arms. "To anyone?"
"Anyone who'll pass the reading test. Tailors, dyers, the women in that square, a fishwife, your cousin. I'll teach the reading before I teach the setting. Nobody learns to write a stitch before they can see what one says."
"Then the whole city's a workshop," Parren said.
"Yes."
He was quiet for a long moment. Then he picked up the old indigo paddle from the corner where it had leaned for a decade, and set it across his knees, and said, "I'll teach the warping. Whatever else I think of you."
She found Orla in the guild's back office at dusk, at the desk where the Chief Tailor had signed purchase orders for forty years. Orla had not taken the chair; the chair had not been sat in since. She was reading the confiscated ledgers with a lamp pulled close, and she did not look up when Elin came in.
"Hasket Street," Orla said. "The old dye works. Rumors move faster than you do."
"I need a writ. For a workshop that answers to no guild."
"You need the coin first." Orla turned a page. "The eastern bank called in Harrow's notes this morning. He held the paper on half the tailoring houses in the lower city, and now the bank holds it, and the bank has already let it be known that a workshop on Hasket Street would be a poor neighbor for anyone who wants credit in the spring."
Elin sat down across from her. Her legs had been shaking since the square, and sitting was a relief she tried not to show.
"So it's money now," she said.
"It was always money. It was money the whole time, underneath. You and I have been arguing about laws and it's been money standing behind the laws, holding the door."
"Then we don't take the bank's coin."
"With what?"
"The women in the square don't have restitution. They have memories the guild sold, which by any honest reading are theirs, and which the trade recorded a price for. Every one of those names on Sera's slate is a debt the guild owes, and the guild has coffers, and the coffers are yours now, because you're the one arresting people."
Orla set down her pen. "You want me to open the guild coffers for the women the guild erased."
"I want you to open them for the workshop, which will be run by those women, who will decide what to do with whatever comes in. I'm not asking you as a favor. I'm asking you because the confession I demanded says the guild profited from stolen lives, and if you're posting that confession in the morning, the coffers aren't the guild's anymore. They never were."
For a moment Orla looked at her the way she had looked at her when Elin was eleven, in this same room, being told she had hands for the work. Then she pulled a fresh sheet toward her.
"The writ will be contested. Harrow will argue it's an unlawful guild, existing to fence stolen memory-work. He'll do it before the council, and he'll do it loud."
"Let him."
"You'll need a name for it before the council meets."
Elin thought about it. Not a grand name; the grand names were how the guild had gotten into the business of owning things.
"Call it the Threadworks," she said. "Because that's all it is. A place where thread gets worked, and whoever works it keeps what they make."
Orla wrote it. Then she stopped, pen resting, and said without looking up: "You understand that if you teach this, the first person to learn it well will be able to undo what you did. Every restabilized weave in this city can be picked back out by a patient hand with your instruction. Including Lark."
Elin had not let herself think about Lark in three days, because thinking about Lark was a kind of falling, and she could not afford to fall before dawn.
"I know," she said.
"And you're going to teach it anyway."
"Yes."
Orla signed the writ. She blotted it, and held it out, and it was the first thing Elin had been given in weeks that had not come with a cost attached on the front of it.
She was on the stairs when Tobin caught her, out of breath, having run from Hasket Street. Behind him, past the guild's iron doors, the square was filling with lanterns, though it was not yet midnight, and the lanterns were the wrong color—a flat, pale green Elin had never seen in Lumen before.
"One of the eastern bank's men came to the dye works," he said. "Looking for you. He said the notes aren't being called in after all. He said they've been sold."
"Sold to who?"
"He wouldn't say. But he said they were sold for a price they'd only pay one way." Tobin looked out at the green lanterns, and the crowd gathering under them, and his jaw went tight. "There's a man in the square with a slate of his own, Elin. With names on it. And people are paying him to add theirs."