The Unraveling Thread

Chapter 65: The Mother's Trial

The hearing was held in the old grain exchange, because the guild hall could not hold everyone who wanted to come.

By the eighth bell the floor was packed: guild-clerks in grey, cutters with their pins still in their collars, Hasket Street merchants, mothers with children on their hips. Two of the council's vacant seats sat empty on the dais like missing teeth. Sera occupied the Archivist's chair and kept both hands flat on the table, as though the wood might otherwise float away.

Elin stood at the witness rail with a copy of her mother's ledger in both hands. It had been rebound overnight so the pages would not shed. She had read the unfinished final entry so many times the words had worn smooth, like stones in a river.

"State your name for the record," said the clerk.

"Elin Voss. Threadworks, Hasket Street."

"Your relationship to the subject of this inquiry."

She had rehearsed six answers on the walk over. "She is my mother."

A murmur went around the room like wind through wheat. She let it pass.

"Master Voss's ledger has been entered into evidence," Sera said. "The witness will read the disputed entries aloud."

So Elin read. Lot numbers. Dates. A column headed *receipt* and a column headed *severance*, which was the guild's polite word for cutting a memory out of a living person. She read her mother's handwriting — the slanted, impatient hand she remembered from a hundred notes pinned to a workroom door — and heard it describe a woman from Osqueth who had agreed to lose her marriage in exchange for a season's rent, and a boy from Morency who had lost the name of his sister and been paid in brass.

"Those are the crimes," Elin said, closing the book. "They're in her hand. I won't pretend they aren't."

Master Tey, who had abstained and said nothing for a week, rose from the third row. He had the grey, careful voice of a man who had practiced sounding reasonable. "Then you concede your mother was among the architects of this trade."

"She was a bookkeeper for it," Elin said. "I don't know yet whether that's lesser. The book wants it to be lesser. I've stopped trusting the book."

"Then concede she is guilty."

"I'll concede she did the work." Elin set the ledger down and put both hands on the rail. "But I've also read the rest."

She turned to the clerk and asked for the second bundle — the thin packet of letters that had come out of the deep archive when Sera opened it two days before, and that no one had yet read into the record.

"Trafficking in severed memory is what the guild pays fines for," Elin said. "What it doesn't pay fines for is restoring them. Between the years marked in that second column, my mother paid for forty-one restorations out of her own pocket. She bought back memories the guild had sold and put them where they belonged. That is a crime under guild law. It is also the only reason a woman named Aline Cato in Osqueth knows her own daughter's face."

The room broke open. It took the clerk a full minute to restore order, and when he did, Tey was already on his feet again.

"Forty-one restorations against four hundred and twelve severances recorded in her hand. Ratio, Master Voss. Do you offer this as an accounting?"

"I offer it as a fact," Elin said. "You can weigh it however you like. I'm not here to balance her books for her."

"Then what are you here for?"

She had known the question would come and had not been able to answer it in the workshop, awake, at three in the morning, with the chronometer ticking on the sill. She answered it now because the whole floor was waiting.

"Because this city has spent two generations deciding who gets to be a monster and who gets to be a victim," she said. "Harrow sold thousands of memories and was voted onto the council. My mother sold hundreds and bought back forty-one and is being called to answer for it in a grain exchange. That isn't justice. That's arithmetic with a thumb on the scale."

Someone in the back shouted that Ilse Voss had ruined lives.

"Yes," Elin said. "She did."

Someone else shouted that she had saved them.

"Yes," Elin said. "She did that too."

"Witness, you cannot have it both ways," Tey said.

"I'm not asking for both ways. I'm asking for the whole thing." Elin turned to face the floor rather than the dais. "You want me to stand here and say my mother was a monster so you can feel clean. Or you want me to say she was a saint so you can keep buying from whoever inherits her ledger. I won't do either. She cut people open and she stitched them back and she took money for the first and spent it on the second, and if you want a neat word for that, you're going to have to invent one, because I don't have it."

The floor did not break open this time. That was worse. It went quiet, and the quiet had weight, and Elin understood she had just spent something she could not get back.

Sera finally spoke. "The inquiry will recess until the second bell. The witness is excused but asked to remain in the building."

Elin stepped down. Nessa was waiting at the end of the rail with her hands twisted in her apron, and behind her stood Orla, who had given up her chair and had not stopped looking tired since.

"That was either the bravest thing I've heard in this hall or the worst," Orla said.

"Which?"

"Ask me at the second bell."

They found a corner near the loading doors where the draught came in. Nessa produced a paper twist of nuts and made Elin eat them. Elin did not taste any of it.

"People outside are saying you defended her," Nessa said quietly.

"People outside would say anything. They're saying the Threadworks sells memories, too."

"I know. I heard a man say it to his wife at the fountain." Nessa's chin came up. "I told him he could come and watch us read the stitches on anything he owned. He didn't come."

Elin almost laughed. "Good."

Orla returned with two clerks and a face that had changed. She held a slip of paper between two fingers like something that might bite.

"Canvass from the eastern quarter," she said. "They're drawing up a petition to strike her name from the memorial of the erased. The argument is that a perpetrator can't be a victim."

"She was erased," Elin said. "The guild cut her out of her own life. I've read the seams."

"Half the city agrees with you. The other half has already signed the petition." Orla handed her the slip. "And there's something else. When the clerk called for the deep-archive letters, he found the folder had been resealed. Two sheets are missing."

Elin went cold. "Which two?"

"The ones from the last year. The ones postmarked from Osqueth." Orla's voice dropped. "Someone pulled them between last night and this morning. Tey signed the archive register at first bell to review the evidence. His name's on the page."

Elin looked across the floor. Tey was standing by the dais in quiet conversation with two guild-clerks, one hand resting on a satchel.

"If he's carrying them—" she started.

"He'll have handed them off already, or he'll be gone by second bell." Orla gripped her arm. "Elin. The missing year is the year your mother went east. Whatever she wrote to whoever's left in Osqueth — that's the part that says who's calling her home."

Elin took the chronometer from her pocket and turned it over. The little needle that timed stitches instead of hours lay still at the zero mark, as it had since Merek put it in her hand.

Second bell rang.

She looked at the satchel across the room, and at the door Tey was already drifting toward, and did the arithmetic she had refused to do all morning.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 65: The Mother's Trial · The Unraveling Thread · Lumen Reads