The apartment was on the second floor of a faded palazzo in Cannaregio, a long walk from the safe house and a longer walk from anything Chiara Priuli might have wanted to remember about her mother. Matteo climbed the stairs alone. They had agreed on that much. Leon waited on a bridge two canals over, hood up, watching the water like a man with nowhere to be.
Chiara opened the door before he knocked. She was forty, gray threaded through dark hair, dressed in the plain clothes of someone who had stopped performing grief years ago and simply lived inside it.
"You said you knew my mother," she said. Not a greeting.
"I worked a case that involved her. I need to ask you something."
She studied him for a long moment, then stepped aside. The apartment was small and warm and smelled of rosemary. A cat slept on the radiator. There were no paintings on the walls. Matteo noticed that the way another man might notice a missing tooth.
"People came about her paintings for two years after she died," Chiara said, leading him to a kitchen table. "Insurance men. Lawyers. One journalist who wanted to write about the scandal and got very disappointed when I told him there was nothing left to steal." She poured water without asking if he wanted any. "Which kind are you?"
"Insurance. But not about the settlement. I need her diary."
Chiara's hand paused over the glass. "Why."
"Because I think the people who ruined her are still working, and I think she knew more about them than she ever said. Including to me."
"You were the one." Chiara sat down across from him. "The investigator. The one who pushed her."
"I didn't push her. I did my job, and it was the wrong job done correctly." The words had been waiting four years. They came out flat and honest, which was the only way they had ever been going to come out. "I've thought about her every week since. I'm not here to make that better. I'm here because something she knew can stop it happening again."
Chiara was quiet. Outside, a delivery boat grumbled down the canal with a sound like a man clearing his throat. "She kept the diary in a biscuit tin," she said finally. "I never read it. I tried, once. I got two pages in and put it back."
She left the room and came back with the tin. Blue, rusted at the corners, the kind of thing that had held pandoro once. She set it on the table between them and did not let go of it right away.
"There was a man who came," she said. "Before she died. Maybe three weeks before. I let him in because he said he had a painting to return — he said one of hers had gone missing in the transfer, and he'd found it. He had this way about him. Charming. You wanted to believe him."
Matteo's mouth went dry. "What did he look like?"
"Late thirties. Tall. Italian, but a northern accent I couldn't place. Dark hair. Very good coat." She shrugged. "He wasn't there more than an hour. When he left she sat in the dark in the living room until I made her eat something. She said he'd come to warn her about something, and that it was already too late, and that I shouldn't let anyone into the house again."
"Did she say his name?"
"No. And I didn't push, which I've had four years to regret." She slid the tin across the table. "Take it. If it helps you do to them what they did to her, take it."
Matteo walked out with the tin under his arm and did not look back at the building until he was on the bridge where Leon was waiting. Leon turned, saw his face, and said nothing. That was, Matteo noted distantly, probably the smartest thing he had done all week.
They read it in the safe house that night, gloves off, door bolted. The diary of Elena Priuli ran to two hundred pages in a cramped, slanted hand, and for the first ninety it was what a diary should be — weather, jasmine on the terrace, a daughter's engagement, a hip that ached in winter. Then it changed. Near the end, the entries narrowed to single paragraphs, then to lines, then to what looked like notes for something she never had the nerve to write.
*The ring is four and one. Four who bring the canvases, one who finds the buyers. I have met three and I will not write their names. If I write them, I am complicit. If I do not, I am a coward. I have chosen cowardice. Let my cowardice outlive me.*
Matteo read it twice. "Four and one," he said.
"Same structure as the USB," Leon said. "Moretti's photographs. Four shots per painting, one buyer. It's the same organization."
"Or she was describing the same method because she'd seen it done to her." He turned the page.
There were names after all, but not written as names. Four entries, each a set of numbers and a first initial. A date. A place. 12/3 M. 04/6 G. 09/9 S.
"Those aren't dates," Leon said. "They're valuations. Ten-twelve March. Four-six June. In thousands."
Matteo looked at the initials. M. G. S. "And this one." He pointed at a name written out in full, once, on the second-to-last page, the ink pressed hard enough to score the paper beneath.
*Il tedesco.*
The German.
"There's no German in the USB," Matteo said.
"There's no German in anything I've been given either. Which means either she was wrong, or she met someone the ring never let near a camera."
Matteo kept turning. The final entry was dated eleven days before her death.
*Someone came. He sat where you are sitting and told me to stop. He said the file I kept was going to be found and the people who found it would not be gentle. He said he was sorry about what happened to me and that he had been part of it and could not undo it, only this. He left a name and a number and told me to call if they came. I did not call. I did not believe him.*
*He had a good coat and he lied about the painting. But I think he was telling the truth about the rest. It is strange, at the end, to be comforted by a liar.*
The room went very quiet.
Matteo set the diary down on the table and looked at Leon, who had gone still, who had not moved a muscle since *Il tedesco*, whose good coat was hanging on the hook by the door exactly where he had left it when they came in.
"Tall," Matteo said. "Late thirties. Northern accent."
"Matteo."
"You said you were in Milan three weeks before she died. You told me that. You told me and I didn't even — "
"I was in Venice."
"You told me Milan."
"I lied."
The word sat there. Matteo heard the water lapping at the foundations under the floor and the cat scratching somewhere upstairs and his own blood in his ears.
"You visited her," he said. "You sat in her living room and you told her to stop. You knew. Before Moretti, before me, before any of it. You knew her and you knew them and you never said a word."
"I warned her. That's all I did. I warned her and I left and she didn't call and eleven days later she was dead." Leon's voice was level, which was worse. "I found out on the news. I have not slept properly since."
"Then why lie to me. Every day. Every single day since the auction, you've had this in your pocket and you lied."
"Because I knew what you'd do." Leon finally looked at him. "I knew you'd look at me exactly the way you're looking at me now."
Matteo stood up. The chair fell over behind him and neither of them righted it.
"You're the one who found her," he said. "You're the one who warned her. And you still didn't tell anyone who they were."
"Because I didn't know — "
"You knew enough to warn her. You knew enough to buy a coat she'd remember. And then you spent four years doing what, exactly? Running scams in Florence?" He was at the door. He didn't remember moving. "You let Savoia sit across from us and talk about Moretti like a dead dog and you never once said *I knew Elena.*"
Leon didn't move. "Where are you going."
"To look at this villa I'm supposed to rob for a man who knows things I now have to wonder where he learned them."
"Matteo." Leon's voice cracked for the first time — actually cracked. "Take the diary with you."
Matteo looked back at the table. The biscuit tin, the slanting hand, the words *I did not believe him* in ink pressed through the page.
He picked it up. "You call Savoia," he said. "You tell him the Guardi comes out of that villa Friday night. On time. No delays."
"The diary — "
"The diary stays with me. And Leon." He was already at the stairs. "If there is one more thing in there that you knew and didn't tell me, I will hand all of it to the Carabinieri with your name in the margin. I mean it."
He went down the stairs three at a time and out into the Cannaregio night with the tin under his arm, and behind him, on the second-floor landing, Leon Moretti did not follow.