The Venetian Frame

Chapter 43: The Trial Begins

The courtroom in Padua was smaller than the Venice tribunals Matteo knew, a converted municipal hall with bad acoustics and a radiator that ticked like a metronome. He sat in the second row, behind the prosecution bench, where he could see the back of Leon's head. The wound had left Leon's left arm stiff; he kept it angled against his ribs, and every time he shifted in his chair the movement cost him something. Between sessions, Matteo had watched a court officer bring him water he only half drank. He had not been allowed to speak to him in three days.

"Call the matter."

The judge was a woman in her sixties with reading glasses pushed up into silver hair, and she handled the preliminary documents the way a butcher handles a knife — efficiently, without sentiment. The clerk recited the charges. Fraud. Conspiracy to defraud. Aggravated fraud in connection with the Elena Sartori estate, Padua, some years earlier. Documentary falsification. The list went on long enough that Matteo stopped counting and just listened to the flatness of the words, how a life's arrangement of small deceptions could be read aloud in under two minutes.

"Mr. Castellani. How do you plead?"

Leon stood. It took him a moment. Matteo saw his jaw work once before he spoke.

"Guilty, Your Honor. To all counts."

A murmur went through the gallery. Matteo didn't turn to see who was sitting behind him. He kept his eyes on Leon's shoulders, which did not move.

The judge looked at him over her glasses. "You understand you are waiving your right to trial and that the court will proceed to sentencing on the basis of the evidence and your cooperation. You understand the range of penalties available."

"I do."

"Then sit down."

Vianello was first. He read from his notes with the bland precision of a man who had spent two decades refusing to be surprised by anyone. He described the fraud operation as he had reconstructed it: the false provenances, the rigged private sales, the network Bianca had built from the inside of auction houses and the outside of them, Leon operating at the seam. He described Leon's complete statement against the network. He described the Tintoretto and where it had been found, the box in storage unit 214, the accounts in Bianca's hand and the wallet that had belonged to Luca Moretti. The word murder was said aloud twice. The judge wrote something.

Then it was Matteo's turn.

He took the stand and swore the oath and found, with some surprise, that he was not nervous. He had testified before. The difference was that this time the man in the defendant's chair was looking at him, and Matteo had to decide, on the record, how much of the truth about Leon he was willing to say.

"Mr. Bellini. Your relationship to the accused?"

Matteo's mouth was dry. "I am an investigator for Adriatica Assicurazioni. I met Mr. Castellani in the course of an investigation. We have since worked together on the recovery of a stolen canvas."

"Describe the nature of that cooperation."

He described it. He kept it factual: Leon's role in identifying the network, his voluntary statement, the risk to his person that the statement had created. He did not describe the storeroom in Venice where Leon had confessed to him with his back to the wall. He did not describe the piazza, or the way Leon had stood in the rain, or the way Matteo had spent three days making phone calls that could have cost him his position. The court did not need any of that, and he was not sure he was ready to say it out loud anyway.

Prosecution counsel leaned forward. "You have personal knowledge of the extent of the accused's cooperation?"

"I do. He chose to give a statement implicating a criminal network operating inside the art trade, knowing the statement would expose him to additional liability. He did not ask for anything in return."

"Did he ask for anything in return?"

"He asked for immunity. It was refused."

That got a reaction. The judge's pen stopped.

"Explain."

"Mr. Castellani's cooperation agreement was conditioned on immunity from prosecution for the network statement. The Padua matter fell outside the scope of that agreement. He gave the statement anyway, in full, and included his own conduct in the Padua matter without prompting. He could have concealed it. No one else present had firsthand knowledge of it in a form the prosecution could use without his admission."

The judge looked at Leon for a long moment. Leon looked back at her.

"Mr. Castellani. Is this accurate?"

"Yes, Your Honor."

"Why?"

The courtroom was quiet. Leon shifted slightly, the stiffness in his shoulder telegraphing through his whole frame.

"Because it was true," he said. "And because I was tired of deciding which parts of my history I got to keep."

Matteo drove back to Venice that evening because there was nothing else to do with himself. He had been told the sentencing hearing would be set for a date two months out, time for the defense to file cooperation submissions and for the prosecution to quantify the harm recovered. Two months. He sat by the window of the vaporetto and watched the lagoon move past in the dark, the water still holding its day's cold.

His phone buzzed. A message from Ferraro, brief: Sentence exposure is significant. He should prepare.

Matteo typed back: What does significant mean.

The reply took twenty minutes. Up to twelve years on the aggregate, reduced substantially for cooperation, possibly to four to six with time served considered. No guarantees. The judge is not sentimental.

Matteo stared at the number. Then he put the phone away and looked out again at the water, which had not changed and would not change, and which he had, for some reason, expected to tell him something.

In the morning he went to Padua.

The holding area outside the courtroom was a narrow corridor with a bench, and Leon was sitting on it with his hands cuffed and resting on his thighs, and when he looked up he didn't seem to have slept either. Matteo sat down beside him. The guard at the end of the corridor looked at them and looked away.

"Ferraro told you," Leon said.

"He told me the range."

"Twelve years, reduced for cooperation."

"Four to six."

"Or more. Or less." Leon's mouth quirked, but the rest of his face didn't follow. "You shouldn't have testified for me."

"I testified the truth."

"You testified a truth that happens to help me. Don't pretend there's no difference." He turned his head to look at Matteo properly. "You put your name to me. On the record. In a Padua courtroom."

"I know what I did."

"Do you? Because this town has a long memory. Adriatica has an office here. Investigators who vouch for men like me don't necessarily get the Venice assignment next time."

Matteo let that sit. There was a version of the conversation where he argued, where he insisted on the purity of his motives, where he defended himself the way an investigator defends a report. He was tired of that version.

"Leon," he said. "When you confessed to me. In Venice. The storeroom."

"Yes."

"You said you sat in the rooms where decisions like Luca Moretti's were made, and you took money off the same table."

"I did."

"And you were right to say it. That's why I testified the way I did. I didn't testify to help you. I testified because you told the truth at a cost, and someone needed to put it on the record."

Leon was quiet for a while. When he spoke, his voice was lower.

"The judge is going to send me away."

"Yes."

"And you're going to be here."

"I'm going to be here."

The guard stood up and said something about scheduling. Matteo stood. Leon couldn't easily rise with the cuffs and the shoulder, so Matteo reached down — careful, not dramatic — and took his elbow, and Leon allowed himself to be helped up, and for one second the two of them stood close in the corridor with the fluorescent light buzzing overhead, and neither of them said anything that could be entered into any record.

"Sentencing hearing," Leon said. "Two months."

"Two months."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 43: The Trial Begins · The Venetian Frame · Lumen Reads