The Caffè Florian had the decency to keep its forgers indoors. Matteo learned that on a Tuesday, when a claims adjuster from Generali called him about a Bellini—not his own surname, no relation, a small cruel joke of the universe—that a client wanted insured for an exhibition loan to a museum in Ljubljana.
"You're the one who does authentication consults now," the adjuster said. "Off the clock, but we'll pay your rate."
Matteo had taken off-the-clock work. He had to. Leon's restitution didn't care that Leon was in a cell in Padua; the court had set a schedule of payments that assumed a man with a future. Matteo was that man's power of attorney. Twice a week he sat at the kitchen table of his own apartment and did the arithmetic, and twice a week the arithmetic sat down across from him and did not move.
He did not examine why he was doing it. He had an itemized list of reasons, all of them defensible, and none of them the one he looked at only at night.
So on Tuesday he went to the villa in Mestre where the Bellini was being stored before the loan, and he knew before he crossed the threshold. It was the varnish. Not wrong, exactly—the right amber, the right age—but too even. A varnish laid down by a hand that had never had to work around a crack.
He asked for the provenance. The owner, a retired dentist with a well-groomed beard and the easy confidence of a man who had never been lied to because he had always been able to afford the truth, produced a folder. A 1968 Milan auction, a private collection in Bolzano, a receipt from a gallery in Trieste that had closed in 1989 and had, Matteo knew, never handled Bellini.
"Signori," Matteo said, setting the folder down. "May I take photographs?"
Half an hour later he was on the vaporetto, then in his office, then in front of what he had spent nine years learning not to see. He ran the images beside the Adriatica database, and the match came back in eleven seconds: a lost Bellini, assumed destroyed in a 1974 flood, surfaced in the same condition—same craquelure, same frame—in three separate Verona listings over the past two years. Three different owners. Three different stories. One hand.
He called Vianello.
"Was the painter ever good?" Vianello asked.
"The painter is excellent."
"Then we have a problem."
They had a problem. Matteo pulled the Verona listings and ran the sellers, and every one of them traced back to the same notary in Bassano del Grappa, and the notary traced back to a shell company, and the shell company traced back to nothing, which was exactly the point. But in the fourth listing—a Tintoretto that offended Matteo's eye from a thumbnail—he found a detail the other three didn't have. A conservation note, attached to the sale, signed by a restorer.
The signature was a single looping initial. *S.*
Matteo sat back. Outside, the light failed over the Giudecca.
"Leon's mentor," he said aloud to no one.
He had a name now, or nearly one. Leon had said it once, in the visiting room at Padua—*Silvio taught me everything worth knowing and half of what I'd rather forget*—and then, when Matteo had pressed, he had changed the subject with that fluid courtesy he used when a lie would have been too much work. Silvio. An old man. A restorer, once, with a legitimate practice and a reputation, and then somewhere along the line—1990? 2003?—something had gone wrong and the legitimate work had become the cover for the other thing, and the other thing had become the work.
And now there was a ring. Not Leon's ring. Leon's methods, though—the varnish, the closed gallery, the provenance built in reverse, the notary in the middle of nowhere. Someone had learned from Leon, or from the same teacher, and had decided that a man in custody was a man who couldn't complain.
Matteo dialed Padua. The call took twenty minutes to go through, and when Leon's voice came on the line it was thinner than it had been, worn smooth at the edges by the acoustics of a room Matteo had never seen.
"I'm not calling about the restitution," Matteo said.
"I know you're not. You do the restitution on Sundays."
"There's a ring operating here. Bellini, Tintoretto, licensed, insured, museum loans. Same varnish you use. Same reverse provenance."
The line hummed. Matteo listened to Leon breathe, and then to Leon not breathing for a moment too long.
"Who's the restorer?" Leon asked.
"Someone who signs an S. Someone called Silvio."
"Don't."
"Don't what?"
"Don't find him alone." Leon's voice had changed. The smoothness was gone; underneath it there was something Matteo had heard only twice before, once in the Padua box room and once in the visiting room when he had said *come out different*. "Matteo. I mean it. Silvio trained me, and he trained me to do what he couldn't do anymore, and when I stopped needing him he let me go, and I have spent five years being grateful that he let me go. He is not a man you approach because you have a file."
"I don't have a file. I have a signature."
"Then burn it."
"I'm going to find him," Matteo said, "and I'm going to ask him a question, and when he answers it I'm going to dismantle whatever he has built in this city before you walk out of that gate. Because you're going to walk out of that gate, and I refuse to spend the next five years watching you look over your shoulder at an old man."
Silence. Then, quietly: "You sound like me. When I was sure."
"I'm not sure. I'm just not going to stop."
He hung up. In Padua, three hundred meters from the prison gate he would stand before again someday, Leon held the phone in his hand until a guard told him to put it down. In Venice, Matteo opened a drawer he had kept shut since Leon's arrest, took out a notebook of his own—new, clean, unwritten—and wrote one word at the top of the first page.
*Silvio.*