The Venetian Frame

Chapter 58: The Tintoretto Returns

The Contarini sketch hung on the wall of the Sala del Guarneri, three inches of it visible above a velvet cord, lit by a bulb Signora Contarini had chosen herself because it reminded her of the hallway in the family's old house.

Matteo stood at the back, near the door, where the catering trays came through. He had worn the good suit. He had brought no folder, no camera, no notebook, which felt like arriving naked.

"You're fidgeting," Vianello said, appearing at his elbow with a glass of prosecco she had no intention of drinking.

"I'm standing."

"You're counting the exits."

"That's standing."

The sketch itself was small — smaller than the photographs had suggested, a wash of chalk and ink on blue paper no bigger than a magazine cover, a knot of figures Matteo could not fully parse until he moved half a step right, and then the whole thing resolved: a hand, a shoulder, the suggestion of a lion in the dark. Tintoretto's hand at twenty-eight, before the studios, before the scale. You could see him learning. You could see the moment he stopped copying.

"Nine weeks," Signora Contarini said, coming up beside them, and Matteo had not heard her approach. She was ninety-one and moved like weather. "I told the carabinieri I would not cry at the ceremony. I have cried twice. The second time was at the photograph in the newspaper, when I saw what the man had done to the frame."

"The frame was replaced," Matteo said.

"The frame was replaced," she agreed. "That is what I mean."

She held out her hand. Matteo took it, and she held on longer than a handshake, her grip dry and absolute.

"My husband bought this in 1961 from a man in Mestre who was probably lying to him," she said. "For forty years it was in the corridor by the bathroom. We hung it there because it fit the wall. Then in 2004 someone came and told me it was worth more than the house, and I thought, well, then it should go somewhere with better light. So I lent it. And then it was gone. And I sat in this room with the insurance men and the lawyers and I thought: I have spent forty years doing the wrong thing with the right object. And then you people found it."

"You people," Vianello said, "is doing a lot of work."

"You." She pointed at Matteo. "You are the one who went into the vault."

"I went into the vault."

"Was it terrible?"

"Yes."

"Good," Signora Contarini said. "It should be." She released his hand and went back to the knot of relatives, and Matteo watched her go, her spine straight, her pearls worn the way people wear things that have never once been considered for sale.

Vianello drank half the prosecco. "You're gray."

"I'm fine."

"You went gray when she said vault."

"I said I'm fine."

"You have that look you get," she said, "which is the look of a man deciding whether to tell me something."

The room filled. A man from the Ministry made a speech in which he used the word patrimony four times. A carabiniere colonel presented a certificate. Photographers worked the edges of the room, and Matteo stepped out of the frames the way he always did, which had once been professional discipline and now felt like something else.

He kept thinking about shelf 14, box 9. About the forged bond with his own name on it. About the fact that Fabbri had put the location in his hands, and every recovered object in the room had passed through a channel that Fabbri had chosen to expose.

What is he making me miss.

The minister sat down. There was applause. Signora Contarini did not cry the third time.

Afterward, on the steps of the Palazzo, Matteo stood with his coat over his arm and watched the last of the police boats idle away from the quay.

"There's a letter," Vianello said.

"I know."

"Leon's. Is it still on your desk?"

"Yes."

"You've written five."

"Six," Matteo said. "I wrote another one last night. It's worse than the others."

"You going to open his?"

Matteo looked out at the water. A vaporetto went past, four hundred people standing in a lit rectangle, all of them going somewhere definite. "Not tonight."

"Matteo."

"I know what it says."

"You don't know what it says."

"I know it's from him. That's enough to know what it says." He put on his coat. "I have to go. Visiting hours end at six."

The prison was in Padua, forty minutes by car, and he drove it with the radio off, because he had learned in the last year that he could not hear music and think at the same time, and he had a great deal to think about and no framework for any of it.

The last time he had seen Leon was through glass, four months ago, when Leon had been arrested a second time for a thing he had not done and had taken it, Matteo thought, almost gracefully, as though he had been expecting the bill to come due eventually and had decided to stop arguing with the invoice.

Now Leon was in a chair by the window in the visitors' room, and he had grown a beard, and it suited him in a way that made Matteo's chest do something complicated.

"You got a haircut," Leon said.

"You grew a beard."

"That's how it works. We trade."

Matteo sat down. The chair scraped. There was a vending machine behind Leon, humming. There was a guard at the door doing something on his phone.

"The sketch came home," Matteo said.

Leon's face opened. It was the strangest thing, watching it — a man who had spent his entire adult life arranging his expression for a purpose, and then, once, on a Tuesday in April, letting it just do what it wanted.

"The Contarini one."

"Tintoretto. The chalk study. Signora Contarini made a speech about how it used to hang by the bathroom."

"Of course it did," Leon said. "That's what these families are for. They hang the Sistine ceiling in the laundry and then someone steals it and everyone acts surprised." He leaned forward. "Was it damaged?"

"A little. A water stain on the mount. The restorers stabilized it."

"And the frame?"

"Replaced."

"Good. That frame was wrong. It was a nineteenth-century Bolognese thing that someone had gilded to make it look older." Leon said this with the fast, flat certainty he brought to objects, the only arena in which he had never once lied to Matteo, and Matteo sat with the fact that this was the thing he missed, the specific thing, the way Leon looked at an object and read its whole biography off the surface.

"There was a ceremony," Matteo said. "Ministry men. A colonel. Photographs."

"Were you in any of the photographs?"

"No."

"You moved."

"I moved."

Leon laughed, once, and stopped it. "I heard about Vezzoli. The arrest."

"Conviction, in absentia, on some of it. He's talking about a deal."

"He'll talk for five years and give them nothing," Leon said. "That's what the Vezzolis do. You watched the trial?"

"I testified."

"I know. I read the paper. It took me three days because the copy in here is missing a page in the middle." He said it without weight. He had gotten very good, Matteo noticed, at saying things without weight that would have set the room on fire a year ago.

There was a pause. Matteo looked at the table. Then he looked up.

"There's a bond," he said. "With my signature on it."

"I know."

"You don't seem surprised."

"Matteo, I have spent twenty years knowing what Fabbri does to people he thinks are useful." Leon put both hands flat on the table, which was a gesture Matteo had never seen him make, and realized after a second that it was not a gesture — it was a man stopping himself from reaching. "He issued a bond against you in 2018. I know that. I've known since Padua. I didn't tell you because the only way you'd have found out was by getting close enough to him to be a danger to yourself, and I decided I'd rather let you find out on your own than be the one who handed you the leash."

"You decided."

"Yes."

"How long have you known?"

"Fourteen months."

Matteo sat back. The vending machine hummed.

"I should be angry," Matteo said.

"You are. You're just also relieved, because it means I didn't build the trap for you, and you've been holding that question like a coin in your mouth for a year."

Matteo looked at him. There was no defense in Leon's face. There was no weapon. There was just a man in a prison beard, waiting.

"Signora Contarini held my hand for eleven seconds," Matteo said finally. "She counted my exits."

"She would."

"She said, and then it was gone, and I sat in this room with the insurance men."

Leon was quiet.

"I keep trying to describe what happened today," Matteo said, "and every version I build turns into a report. And I don't want it to be a report. I want it to be—"

He stopped.

"Yes," Leon said. "That's the problem with us. Everything we feel arrives pre-formatted."

Matteo laughed. It came out of nowhere and cracked in the middle. The guard glanced up.

"I wrote you six letters," Matteo said.

"I know. I had four of them read to me by my lawyer, under privilege, without your name, because I wanted to know if you'd said the thing yet."

"Which thing?"

"The thing where you stop apologizing and start planning."

Matteo looked down at his own hands on the table, six inches from Leon's. The distance was regulation. There was no rule against crossing it. There was just a very long hallway of facts standing between the two of them, and Matteo was tired, suddenly, profoundly tired, of being the kind of man who counts the exits before he sits down.

"How much time," Matteo said.

Leon blinked.

"How much time do you have left."

"Nineteen months, if the embezzlement of the Calvi estate is folded in, which my lawyer says it will. Eleven if the appeal on the fabric provenance holds, because the only witness was the man who testified from a hotel in Kuala Lumpur and hasn't answered a subpoena in two years." Leon said all of this the way he used to say the provenance on a Modigliani: fast, complete, slightly bored. Then he stopped, and looked at Matteo, and the boredom fell off him like a coat. "Why."

"Because I want to know how to plan," Matteo said. "I've never done it. I've planned cases, I've planned searches. I have never planned a life. It's the one field I have no experience in."

The vending machine hummed. Somewhere down the corridor a door shut.

"There's one condition," Leon said.

"Of course there is."

"I want to see the sketch. When I'm out. I want to stand in front of it with you and Signora Contarini, and I want to hear her say, for the fortieth time, that her husband hung it by the bathroom." He smiled, and it was a real smile, which Matteo had seen exactly twice before, and both times had been in a photograph Leon had later burned. "That's all I want. It's very cheap. You should take the deal."

Matteo didn't answer for a long moment. He was aware of the clock over the door, and the eleven minutes left in the hour, and the fact that he still had not opened Leon's letter, and that he intended to open it tonight, in the car, on the shoulder of the A4, before he was even out of Padua province.

"Friday," he said.

Leon raised his eyebrows.

"Friday at eight," Matteo said, and stopped, because Vianello's voice was in his head, and the rotation was in his head, and it was Friday, and the vault was waiting, and he had just promised something to a man in a prison visitors' room that he would need to survive the bank to deliver.

"Friday at eight what?" Leon said.

Matteo stood up. "Nineteen months. Write it down."

"Matteo."

"Write it down," Matteo said, "and I'll bring you the sketch in ink."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 58: The Tintoretto Returns · The Venetian Frame · Lumen Reads