The Water Beneath

Chapter 2: The Rival

The Col·legi d'Arquitectes de Catalunya occupied a stone building off Plaça Nova whose interior had been gutted in the nineties and rebuilt as a series of white ramps that always made Inés feel she was walking through the inside of a seashell. She arrived at seven-forty, ten minutes before the hearing was due to start, and the lobby was already loud with the particular hum of architects pretending not to look at each other's shoes.

She signed in at the desk. The woman behind it ran a finger down a printed list and found her name under Observers, which was where she belonged now, technically. Fourteen months back she'd been the one presenting. Now she was a line item.

"Inés." Marta Puig detached herself from a cluster near the stairs and kissed her twice. "You came."

"I said I would."

"You said you might." Marta had been two years ahead of her at the ETSAB and had aged into the sort of architect who wore linen in February and made it look deliberate. "The whole floor's talking about you. The letter to the Ajuntament."

"Three lines and a legal citation. It's not a manifesto."

"It's a start." Marta steered her toward the ramp, lowering her voice. "Listen. Before you go in. The project — the one that won the competition — the name on the technical annex."

"I know the name."

"Do you know he's here?"

Inés kept her face still. "It's an association hearing about a demolition in the Raval. Of course he's here. He has to sit and watch them vote."

"He's not sitting. He's presenting." Marta's hand tightened on her elbow. "Ferrer asked to speak in support of the demolition. He filed the request Tuesday."

The ramp turned. Below them, through the glass balustrade, Inés could see the hall filling — rows of fold-down seats, a long table at the front with water glasses and a microphone that someone was testing with soft percussive taps. Half the city's planning committee was there. A television crew was setting up along the side wall, which meant this had stopped being a neighborhood matter some time ago.

"Did you know he was the lead engineer?" Inés asked.

"Not until the annex. He's been very quiet about it."

"He's been very quiet about a lot of things."

They took seats at the back. The hall settled. The president of the association, a small precise woman named Ferrán, opened the hearing with the flat courtesy of someone who had run too many of these, and then Jordi Solà stood up at the front table and summarized the project in eleven minutes: two hundred and forty residential units, a public plaza, the façades of plots sixteen to twenty-four retained as a decorative shell with the interiors demolished, reinforced and rebuilt behind. Every number checked. Every survey signed.

He did not look at the back of the hall once.

When he finished, Ferrán said, "The association has received a request from the consortium's technical lead to address the committee. Señor Ferrer."

Inés had not seen him in nine years. She had a memory of him at twenty-six, in a café on Carrer de Verdi, arguing about timber and gesturing with a pencil until it flew out of his hand and landed in someone's soup. He had been too quick to argue, too sure, and she had spent a summer finding that attractive and then the following autumn finding it unbearable.

He came up the side aisle now, and the room turned to watch him the way rooms do when someone has that specific gravity. He was taller than she remembered or she had gotten used to a different scale. Dark suit, no tie, reading glasses pushed up into his hair. He took the microphone off the stand and held it rather than bending to it, which was a small vanity she recognized, because she did the same thing.

"Thank you," he said. His voice carried without effort. "I'll be brief. I know what this hearing is about for most of you and I know a lot of you have a position already. I'm not here to argue with that."

He set a folder on the table.

"Two documents. The first is the geotechnical survey from 2019, which was done for the previous owner and which nobody had looked at in five years. The second is the updated one we commissioned in November. Page eleven, both of them."

He waited. People turned pages.

"The subsoil under plots sixteen through twenty-four is not what the original brief assumed. It's a compacted layer over a void — a cistern system that fed the block from the eighteenth century until the mains came in, 1911, according to the municipal records. The void is unfilled. It runs the length of the courtyard and continues under the party wall shared with number twenty-six."

Inés sat very still. Her mother's basement had a damp wall she'd been told as a child was just the mountain under the city. A cistern. Under the figs.

"If we dig the basement levels as designed," Álex said, "we are removing the only thing holding the façades you want to keep from settling. The retention scheme in the current proposal requires two hundred cubic meters of concrete injected into that void before a single machine arrives. That's not a preference. That's arithmetic."

He let it sit. Somewhere behind Inés a man whispered to his neighbor and was shushed.

Ferrán leaned toward her microphone. "You're telling the committee the project is more complex than presented."

"I'm telling the committee the project is more expensive than presented, and that we can carry it. We have the margin. I filed the survey with the Ajuntament this morning under the technical annex, which is the correct procedure, and I'm here tonight so nobody can say later that it was done quietly." He glanced down at the folder. "That's all I have."

He did not look at the back of the hall either.

The floor opened. A woman from the Raval association stood and asked what "the margin" meant in euros and whether it came out of the social housing allocation, and Álex answered her directly, doubling down on the arithmetic, and Inés watched the room turn over in his hands — the planners nodding, the neighbors distrusting him but unable to fault the numbers, Marta beside her writing something on the back of her hand. He was good. He had been good at twenty-six and he was better now and it was, she thought with an entirely private irritation, going to be a problem.

When the session broke for air at nine-fifteen, she stayed in her seat. People filed out for the corridor and the water jug. Marta went to find the woman from the Raval association. Inés counted twenty seconds, stood, and walked down the aisle to the front table.

Álex was putting the folder back together. He glanced up, and then he stopped moving.

"Inés."

"Álex."

"You came." He said it the same way Marta had, which for some reason sharpened her.

"I live three streets away. It's my block you're injecting with concrete."

He closed the folder. Up close he looked tired in a way the microphone had erased — the skin under his eyes, the set of his jaw. "Number nineteen," he said. "The notice went up Tuesday, the same day I filed. I saw the name on the eviction list. Vidal."

"Vidal."

"I didn't know it was yours until the list."

"Would it have changed anything?"

He considered that with the same unhurried precision he'd used on the housing allocation question, and she found she hated it, that he could take a question of hers and turn it over like a document. "No," he said finally. "The arithmetic doesn't move. But I would have called you first."

"That's generous."

"That's not what I meant."

"Then say what you meant."

He put the glasses back over his eyes and immediately took them off again, which was a tell, and she remembered the tell, and she hated that too.

"What I meant," he said, "is that you're the only person in this building who has looked at that courtyard properly, and I've been sitting on a survey for three weeks waiting for someone to do something with it, and now here you are, and you're going to fight me."

"I'm going to fight you."

"Yes." He almost smiled. It didn't reach anything. "Good."

Ferrán appeared at his elbow with a question about procedure, and the moment closed. Álex turned away. Inés walked back up the ramp with her hands in her pockets and her heart going faster than the effort justified, and stood in the lobby while the hall refilled behind her.

On the noticeboard by the entrance, between a studio for rent and a call for papers, someone had pinned the association's monthly bulletin. She read it twice before the words resolved.

*Comissió de Patrimoni — Contract notice: technical assessment and conservation report, Carrer de la Llum 16–24, façades and shared structural elements. Open to collegiate members. Submission deadline, 21 March.*

Nine days.

She stood there with her back to the room where Álex Ferrer was answering questions about cubic meters, and did the arithmetic herself. A conservation report wouldn't stop a demolition on its own. But a conservation report did go into the file, and the file was read by the people who signed the permits, and the file on Carrer de la Llum was currently nine pages of somebody else's arithmetic.

Her phone buzzed. Her mother: *¿Vienes a cenar?*

She typed back: *Late. Don't wait.*

Then she photographed the notice, sent it to Marta with one line — *Can a report be filed by someone with a personal interest?* — and walked out into the cold of Plaça Nova where the cathedral stood lit and indifferent above the tourists, and started for home the long way, down through the Raval, past the block, which she would pass anyway whether or not she chose the long way.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 2: The Rival · The Water Beneath · Lumen Reads