The city council's hearing room on Plaça de Sant Jaume held forty people and smelled of floor wax and wet wool. Inés arrived twenty minutes early and took a seat in the second row, where she could see the dais and the projector screen without craning.
She had twelve bound copies of her proposal in her bag. She'd spent three nights on it, pulling the geotechnical survey Álex had filed, matching it against the 1911 municipal water records she'd ordered from the archive, and drafting an argument that was, she had to admit, thin in places. But not wrong.
Álex came in at ten to nine, alone, carrying a slim folder. He wore the same charcoal coat. He didn't look at her. He sat on the opposite side of the room and read something on his phone until the clerk called the session to order.
The councilor presiding was a woman named Marta Puig, sixty-ish, with reading glasses on a chain and the manner of someone who had chaired too many of these. She laid out the agenda: two competing proposals for the future of the Carrer de la Llum block, plots 12 through 24. Thirty minutes each. Questions after.
"Consortium first," she said. "Señor Ferrer."
Álex stood. He didn't use notes.
"The block is unsound," he said. "The party wall between sixteen and eighteen has a four-centimeter lean that has progressed two millimeters in the last eighteen months. The cistern void Mr. Ferrer's firm identified—" he caught himself, and the room caught it too, a small ripple of attention "—that my firm identified in February makes excavation slower, not impossible. Our plan retains the façades as the heritage code requires, removes the interior courtyard structure, and builds a five-story mixed-use development behind the retained frontages. Forty-one residential units, ground-floor commercial, a public passage through the old courtyard line."
He clicked through images: clean renders, glass and pale stone, a courtyard garden with a single olive tree. It looked like every other new building in the Eixample. It looked like nothing.
"The financial model delivers a return to the municipal land trust within eleven years," he said. "We are ready to break ground in September."
Marta Puig nodded. "Thank you. Señora Vidal."
Inés stood. Her hands were steady. She had rehearsed this on the metro, in the shower, at four in the morning.
"The consortium's plan is competent," she said. "I won't argue with their engineering, except to note that a four-centimeter lean is not a demolition order. It's a repair schedule. What I want to talk about is what their plan doesn't account for."
She put up her first slide: the 1911 mains connection map, overlaid with the geotechnical survey Álex had filed.
"The block sits on an eighteenth-century water system. We know this. The consortium knows this. What neither their survey nor the city's records show is the extent of it. The cistern under the courtyard is not an isolated void—it's one chamber of a network. The 1911 connection documents list four separate mains entering this block, and only two have been accounted for."
"That's speculative," Álex said, without heat.
"It's archival," Inés said. "The records are in the municipal archive. I've cited them."
Marta Puig held up a hand. "Let her finish."
Inés put up her second slide: the conservation proposal. It was, she knew, less glamorous than Álex's renders. It proposed a full structural and hydrological survey before any demolition, preservation of the courtyard as a public space, adaptive reuse of the existing ground-floor structures, and a moratorium on the consortium's buyouts pending the survey results.
"The consortium is buying residents out one at a time," she said. "Seventeen has already gone. Twenty-four is expected to sign on Friday. By the time any survey is complete, there may be no neighborhood left to consult. I'm asking the council to pause the buyout process and commission the survey first."
"That's a delay of six months minimum," Álex said. "At a cost of—"
"I know the cost," Inés said. "I also know the cost of building on top of a water system you don't understand. Ask the owners of number twenty."
The room went quiet. Álex's expression didn't change, but his jaw tightened slightly, and she knew she'd landed something.
Marta Puig leaned forward. "What happened at number twenty?"
"In 1956 the owner sealed the cistern," Inés said. "The work was done without a survey. The following winter, the rear wall of the building subsided by nine centimeters. It's still there. You can see it from the courtyard."
She had not verified this yet—Amparo's box was still unopened. But the subsidence was visible on the façade, and the date she'd pulled from the property register. It was enough to say.
Marta Puig looked at Álex. "Is this accurate?"
Álex was silent for a beat. "The 1956 subsidence is documented," he said. "It was repaired. It has no bearing on the current structural assessment."
"It has bearing on the question of what we don't know," Inés said.
The councilor took off her glasses and folded them. She looked at the room—at the handful of residents in the back rows, at the two architects, at the clerk taking minutes.
"Here's where we are," she said. "The consortium has a viable plan and a financing commitment. Señora Vidal has raised a material question about subsurface conditions and about the pace of the buyouts. I'm not going to award the project today. I'm ordering a public consultation, thirty days, and I'm asking both parties to submit—" she glanced at Inés "—the full archival and survey documentation within fourteen days. The buyout process will continue, but no contracts will be executed until the consultation closes."
The room stirred. It wasn't a win. It was a delay, and a narrow one.
Inés sat down. Her heart was going hard.
Álex left the room before she did. She caught him in the corridor by the cloakroom, shrugging into his coat.
"Number twenty," she said. "You knew about it."
He turned. "I knew there was a subsidence. I didn't know about the cistern."
"You didn't look."
"I looked at what the survey told me to look at." He studied her. "You didn't verify the 1956 sealing, either. You've got a box of somebody's papers you haven't opened. You're arguing from a hunch."
"It's not a hunch."
"It's not evidence yet." He said it without malice, which was worse. "You have fourteen days. I'd start with the box."
He walked out. Inés stood in the corridor with her twelve bound copies and the cold air coming under the door.
Her phone buzzed. A message from Amparo: *The box is here. Come tomorrow at nine.*
She typed back: *I'll be there.*
Then she called her mother, whom she had not called in three weeks, and left a message saying she'd come to dinner Sunday. It was the first time she'd said yes in a long time, and she wasn't sure why she was doing it now, except that Amparo had said her father once organized the block to save the cinema, and she wanted to know how.
She put the phone away and walked out into the square. The sky over Sant Jaume was the color of wet slate. Somewhere under the stones of the street she'd grown up on, water was moving through a system nobody had mapped, and she had fourteen days to prove it.