Louis filed at ten past nine on a Tuesday, because the IPO's online portal opened at nine and he was not going to be one of those people who hit refresh at 9:00:01 like a fool.
"Ashworth Bun," he typed into the trademark field. Class 30. Baked goods. He paid the one hundred and seventy pounds with the card he used for flour invoices, and it went through first time, and he sat back in the chair in the little office behind the counter and looked at the confirmation number on the screen, and felt absolutely nothing, which disappointed him.
Then he printed the receipt and pinned it to the corkboard next to the hygiene certificates, and got on with the morning.
By Friday he had a solicitor's letter drafted.
His name was Priya Nandakumar and she had a practice on Deansgate, and she listened to him for eleven minutes without interrupting once, which he appreciated, and then said, "You understand prior use is a complete defence."
"Prior use means *use*," Louis said. "He's been using the name for five minutes because he saw my sign."
"You've seen his invoices."
"I've seen a chalkboard."
Priya wrote something down. "Then we serve notice and see what he produces. It's cheap. It's not especially friendly."
"I don't need friendly. I need him to change the card."
She had it couriered over on Friday afternoon, and Louis stood at the bakery window and watched the courier walk four doors down, and watched him come back out again ninety seconds later, shoulders empty.
Nothing happened for two days. He baked. He sold forty-one buns on Saturday, which was his best Saturday. He did not look at the café window, except when he did, which was every time the door opened, and every time it opened it was somebody leaving with a coffee and not Harry.
Sunday he closed at two, as he always did, and was wiping down the last tray when the knock came, and he opened the back door onto the yard and Harry stood there in a hoodie with the hood down and a folder under his arm, and the folder was the kind of thing accountants used, cheap and grey.
"You had me served," Harry said.
"You were served on Friday."
"I know when I was served. I mean you actually did it."
Louis held the door. "Do you want to come in, or are we doing this in the yard?"
Harry looked at the yard, which was four metres of wet concrete, and then at the bakery, which smelled of butter and was warm, and something crossed his face that Louis couldn't read, and then he was inside and the door was shut and they were standing among the trays.
"Table's in the corner," Louis said.
Harry didn't sit. He put the folder down on the stainless steel bench, opened it, and took out a stack of paper held together with a bulldog clip, and turned the whole thing around so Louis could read it.
Invoices. Bacon supplier, dry goods, milk. Dates down the left. April, the year before last.
And on the fourth page, dated the eleventh of May, invoice from Elson & Co, dry goods, listing a line item Louis read three times before it made sense.
*Bun sleeves, printed 'Ashworth Bun', x 500.*
"You ordered sleeves," Louis said.
"I ordered five hundred sleeves." Harry's voice was flat. "They're in the back. I've got about eighty left."
"That doesn't mean you sold them here."
"Why would I print five hundred sleeves for a bun I wasn't selling."
Louis put both hands flat on the bench. The steel was cold and he stayed like that a second, because his hands wanted to do something and he wasn't going to let them. "It's my name."
"It's my bun."
"It's the same bun."
"It's a bun, Louis. It's flour and butter and a bit of brown sugar. It's not a patent."
And there it was — the thing he'd been circling for a week, said out loud by somebody else, in his own kitchen, over a folder of paper.
"Where did you get the name," Louis said.
Harry looked at him.
"Two years of posts," Louis said. "I went through all of them. Two years ago in April you're selling focaccia. There's a photo of a focaccia. You had a specials board that said *focaccia* on it. Then in May, nothing, and then in June you're selling a bun called an Ashworth Bun, and you've never once said where it came from. So where did it come from."
The silence went on long enough that Louis heard the fridge compressor kick in. Harry's jaw worked. He looked at the folder, and then at the back door, and then, briefly, at the pot under the sink — no, at the sink; at nothing; at the corner of the room.
"A customer told me about it," he said.
"A customer."
"A woman. Years ago." He picked up the folder and closed it. "She used to come in and tell me about things her daughter's boyfriend used to bake. Very good. Very exact. Wouldn't let anyone else touch the dough."
Louis didn't move.
"Anyway," Harry said, and his voice had something in it now, a bright edge laid over the top of it like icing on a cake that didn't need it, "she stopped coming in. So I made the thing she described. And I called it what she called it. And I've been selling it ever since, so if you want it, we can go and sit somewhere neutral with our letters and pay two solicitors three hundred pounds an hour to say the word *prior* at each other. Or—" He stopped. He looked at the bench. "Or you can tell me what it is you're actually doing."
"I'm protecting my business."
"You're protecting something."
"I'd like you to leave."
"Right," Harry said. He put the folder under his arm. At the back door he stopped, one hand on the frame, not turning around. "Tuesday. Half ten. There's a place on Tib Street, coffee and nothing else, so we don't have to do the food thing. Bring your letter."
"There is a place on Tib Street," Louis said. "It's your cousin's."
"She's not my cousin," Harry said, and went out.
Tib Street on Tuesday was wet and half the tables had their umbrellas out, and the girl behind the counter poured them both filter coffee without being asked and left the pot, which Louis took as a bad sign about how long this was going to run.
The letters sat in the middle of the table like a chess position. Louis's, on Priya's letterhead, three paragraphs. Harry's, on something from a firm on King Street that had creases in it, two paragraphs and a list.
"You opened it," Louis said.
"Course I opened it. Did you think I wasn't going to open it."
"I thought you might bin it."
"I nearly binned it." Harry wrapped both hands around his cup. He looked tired in a way Louis hadn't seen before — not the café tired, the other kind. "Read yours first, though. Yours is better written. Mine just says *our client has used the mark continuously since the eleventh of May* and then his hourly rate."
"Priya's is ninety."
"That's obscene."
"That's Deansgate."
Harry laughed, one short breath, and looked out at the rain, and for about four seconds it was just two blokes with coffee. Then he looked back and it wasn't anymore.
"Here's what I'll do," Harry said. "I'll show you the sleeves, you can photograph the invoices, whatever you want. I'll take the name off the window. Not the boards inside — inside is mine, you can't police what's written on my own walls, but off the window, off the Instagram, off the listings."
Louis set his cup down.
"But you drop the filing," Harry said. "Not shelve it. Drop it. Withdraw the application, because if you keep it sitting there, every day I open up I'm waiting for the next letter, and I can't run a business like that, and neither could you."
"That's not a real offer. That's you asking me to give up the only leverage I have."
"It's a real offer. It's a bad one, but it's real."
"You've had two years of my name on your sign."
"I've had two years of my sign on your name," Harry said, "which is a different sentence, and I think you know it, and I think you've known it since the first morning."
The coffee had gone cold. Louis looked at the two letters, both of them folded now, both of them already slightly soft at the corners from being carried around in pockets. Six hundred pounds to have these written, all told, and the sum total of what they'd achieved was this table.
"I want to know who she was," Louis said.
"What?"
"The customer. The woman who told you about it. I want her name."
Harry looked at him for a long moment. Then he did something with his mouth that wasn't quite a smile, and he picked up his letter, and he folded it again along the crease it already had.
"You want me to give you her name," he said, "so you can make this about a person instead of a piece of paper. And I'm not going to do that. Because it's not the point."
"It's exactly the point."
"It's not." Harry stood up and put his coat on, and dropped two pound coins on the table for the coffee, which Louis had already paid for. "The point is you came in here on day one and told me I couldn't call a thing by its name. And I've got a folder of invoices and you've got a certificate from a website and neither of them is worth anything, really, is it."
"Harry."
"You can't trademark your dead mother's recipe, Louis."
The words landed in the middle of the table and sat there. Harry didn't look pleased with himself. He looked like a man who'd said a thing he'd been carrying for a while and was now waiting to find out what it cost, and behind him the rain came off the awning in one long run and hit the pavement, and Louis found that he could not, just then, get up.
"How," he said.
But Harry was already at the door, and he didn't answer, and the bell over it went when he left.