Breaking the Ice

Chapter 51: The Old Wound

The apartment smelled like the garlic she'd burned an hour ago and would be smelling for a week. Megan wiped down the counter twice, the same square foot of laminate, while Ethan's light clicked off down the hall and the radiator clanked its approval.

Luke sat at the table with a mug of tea he wasn't drinking, turning it slowly between his palms. He'd stayed after dinner. He'd been staying after dinner for weeks now, but tonight he hadn't turned on the television, hadn't asked about the panel prep, hadn't done any of the small things that filled a room when two people were circling something.

"Ethan's asleep," she said.

"I know."

She hung the rag over the faucet and made herself sit down across from him. The chair scraped. Everything in her kitchen scraped.

"You said choose you," she said. "I'm choosing. I'm here. But you should know what you're asking for."

Luke set the mug down. "I didn't come here to collect a confession."

"Then you're getting one anyway." She wrapped her hands around her own mug, cold now. "You left."

"I know I—"

"You left," she said again, and the second time it came out with an edge she hadn't planned. "Senior year. You got the call from the scout, and three days later you were gone. You didn't tell me. I found out from Dan Murray in the dining hall."

Luke's face went still in that way it did, the jaw setting, everything else going quiet.

"I'm not trying to score a point," she said. "I'm telling you why the exit's always mapped. It's not you. It's that I already know what it looks like when someone gets a better offer."

"That was—"

"I was twenty-two. I had a thesis and a boyfriend who was going to be in Chicago and then wasn't. He called me from a hotel in Edmonton, remember? Two days after he left." She heard her own voice thinning and stopped. Breathed. "I waited by the phone like it was 1955. That's the part I'm ashamed of."

Luke's hands had gone flat on the table. He didn't reach for her.

"I was scared," he said.

"I know you were."

"No, you don't." He looked at the wall behind her, at the pencil marks where she'd measured Ethan every birthday since he was three. "I was twenty-two and I got a call from a team that was going to pay me more money than my father made in his life, and I didn't know how to be a person who had that and also had a girlfriend in a dorm room. I didn't know how to say, don't worry, I'll figure it out, when I was pretty sure I couldn't figure out a bus schedule."

"So you just left."

"So I just left." He nodded slowly. "And it was the worst thing I did in my twenties, which is saying something, because I did a lot of things."

"What things."

"Hockey player things." A corner of his mouth moved. "Nothing you'd be impressed by."

Megan didn't smile. She wanted to. She kept her hands around the mug.

"I read the article," she said. "The one from the Boston paper, when you were twenty-four. It said you were 'a hard man to get to know.' I cut it out. I don't know why. I put it in a shoebox."

"You kept a shoebox."

"I have a shoebox for everything. That's who's sitting across from you, so you know."

Luke laughed, once, short, and then stopped as if it had come out wrong. He pulled his chair in closer. The legs groaned against the floor.

"I'm sorry," he said.

The words landed flat. He must have heard it too, because he shook his head and tried again.

"No. That's not enough. I'm sorry that I made you into someone who keeps a map to the door. I didn't know I was doing it. That's not an excuse, it's just — I was twenty-two and I thought if I said the real thing out loud it would break, so I didn't say anything, and I let you find out in a dining hall. That's what I did. That's on me."

Megan's eyes stung and she pressed the heel of her hand against one until it stopped.

"Okay," she said.

"Okay?"

"Okay. I heard you." She let her hand drop. "That's not the same as it being fixed."

"I know."

She stood, opened the cabinet over the sink, and pulled down the bottle of amber pills. Migraine medication, three-quarter full, label printed with her own name and the clinic's letterhead.

"Look at this," she said, setting it between them. "This is the life you're buying into. My neck goes out twice a year. I have a seven-year-old who still comes into my bed at three in the morning and a deposition in eight weeks and a lawyer who calls me at seven a.m. to ask if I've ever been alone in a hotel room with you."

"Have you?"

"Luke."

"I'm allowed to ask."

"Then ask better." She slid the bottle back toward the cabinet. "What I'm saying is, I'm not going to be your girlfriend and act like none of this is happening. I'm going to be the woman who goes to counseling. Like, with you. For real. Because I sat on your couch—"

"Our couch."

"—I sat on that couch last month and catalogued every reason it could end, and I did it while I was smiling at you. That's not sustainable. That's not fair to you, and it's not fair to Ethan."

Luke was quiet for a moment. Then: "You want to go to counseling."

"I want us to go to counseling."

"With a stranger. Who makes us talk about our feelings."

"On Fridays, allegedly."

He laughed again, and this time it stayed. He rubbed a hand over his jaw.

"I've had coaches who did less for me," he said.

"Consider it dry-land training."

"Okay."

"Okay?"

"I'm saying okay." He looked at her across the table, and there it was, that steadiness that always made her want to believe him. "Megan. Yes."

She hadn't known until just then that some part of her had been braced for him to do the other thing. She let out a breath that turned into something closer to a laugh.

"There's a couples counselor on Halsted," she said. "She came through the clinic for a shoulder referral two years ago. She's good. She also knows exactly who you are."

"Great."

"She'll probably ask about the draft."

"She can ask."

Megan leaned back in her chair. The radiator clanked again, tuneless.

"There's something else," she said. "The car."

Luke went very still.

"The gray sedan," she said. "Three times now. Twice outside the clinic, once on the street behind the rink Wednesday night after Ethan's practice. I didn't tell you because it sounded paranoid, and because I didn't want you thinking I'm building a case. But it's been three times, and I'd rather say it to your face than have you hear it from someone else."

Luke was on his feet before she'd finished the sentence. He crossed to the window, nudged the blinds apart with two fingers.

"Wednesday," he said. "What time."

"Ten-forty. Why."

"Coaching gets out at nine-thirty. The rink lot clears by ten." He let the blinds fall. "Could be press."

"Press doesn't park behind a rink at ten-forty on a Wednesday."

"No."

"What does."

Luke came back to the table, but he didn't sit.

"Vasquez puts the preservation letter out tomorrow," he said. "Which means tomorrow someone at that club finds out the union's roster includes your name. There's a deposition in March. The most useful thing anyone could do right now is figure out what you'd say under oath, and the second most useful is figure out who you'd say it about."

"You think the club is watching me."

"I think the club has lawyers, and I think I've met the lawyers." He picked up his mug, then set it down without drinking. "So here's what we do. You tell Vasquez tonight. Not tomorrow. Tonight. I'll stay in the living room while you call."

Megan pulled her phone off the charger, and then stopped.

"There's one more thing," she said.

Luke waited.

"The note on my tablet. I told you it exists. I didn't tell you I'd already made a copy."

His face didn't change, and somehow that was worse.

"I made a copy the week after I met with the panel," she said. "I emailed it to myself. I didn't disclose it to anyone. It feels — it felt like insurance. It was insurance. It was me deciding you were going to leave and I was going to need evidence."

The radiator ticked. Down the hall, a bed creaked and went quiet.

"Call Vasquez," Luke said finally. "And tell her about the copy."

"Even if it looks like—"

"Exactly because it looks like something. You're the one they're deposing." He gathered up both mugs and carried them to the sink, his back to her. "And then we go Friday. The counselor. You make the appointment in the morning."

"I will."

He turned. In the low kitchen light his face was patient the way a bruise is patient.

"I'm not the same girl," Megan said. "The one who waited by the phone. I'm saying that with my name on the door, and a nine-year-old—" she caught herself. "Seven. Seven-year-old. And a lawyer, and a copy in my sent mail. I'm not her anymore. I need you to hear that."

"I hear it," Luke said. "Now call."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 51: The Old Wound · Breaking the Ice · Lumen Reads