Breaking the Ice

Chapter 52: The Manager's Testimony

The hearing room was smaller than Megan expected. A windowless conference room on the fourth floor of the league offices, rented for the week, with a long table for the panel and folding chairs for everyone else. A court reporter sat at the end, fingers poised. Two league investigators ran the questioning, a man and a woman in dark suits who never smiled.

Megan sat in the third row with Vasquez beside her. Luke wasn't there. He'd been told to stay home, and he'd agreed without arguing, which told her how much he understood what this week could do to him either way.

Tom Kirby took the chair at the front. He was sixty-one, a Wolves equipment manager for nineteen seasons, and he looked like a man who had spent his whole life in a basement laundry room because he had. He wore a gray polo with the team crest and had clearly been told to wear it. His hands rested on his knees, and when the lead investigator asked him to state his name and role, his voice came out steady.

"Thomas Kirby. Equipment manager, Chicago Wolves."

"Mr. Kirby, you've been with the organization nineteen years."

"Yes."

"In the spring of last season, did anyone from the club's medical staff ask you to alter or destroy records relating to player injuries?"

Megan's hands went cold in her lap. Vasquez had warned her this would happen, that Tom was on the witness list, that he'd been subpoenaed rather than volunteering. But hearing it started, hearing the actual words, was different.

Tom looked at the panel. Then he looked down at his hands.

"They asked me to pull the training room logs for February and March and send them up to be *reconciled*." He said the word like it tasted bad. "That's what they called it. Reconciled."

"And what did that mean in practice?"

"It meant they wanted the original handwritten logs. The ones we keep in the binder. Not the digital scans." Tom shifted in his chair. "I've kept paper logs for nineteen years because players tell me things they don't put in the system. A guy comes in limping, he tells me it's his groin, he doesn't want it in a file. I write it down because I need to know who's hurt."

"So the paper logs contained information not in the digital records."

"Sometimes."

"Was that the information they wanted?"

Tom was quiet for a moment. The court reporter's keys clicked through the silence.

"They wanted the page for March twelfth," he said. "Number Forty-One. Luke Dawson. The baseline test entry."

Megan stopped breathing.

"What did they ask you to do with it?"

"Dr. Halloway's assistant came down. She said the page had a transcription error and asked me to give it to her so it could be corrected." Tom's jaw worked. "I've been doing this job a long time. There was no transcription error. What was on that page was what the trainer wrote down the day it happened."

"And what did you do?"

"I told her I'd need to check with the trainer first." Tom's voice hadn't wavered. "She said the trainer had already signed off. I called him anyway. He hadn't signed off. He hadn't been asked."

The investigator paused, letting that sit. "Did you surrender the page?"

"I did not."

"Did you destroy it?"

"No, ma'am." Tom reached into the folder on his lap and set a single sheet of paper on the table. Laminated, Megan saw. He'd laminated it. "It's right here. I made a copy before I told her anything, and then I took the original home, and then I had the copy laminated because I didn't trust myself not to lose it."

The room was very quiet. The investigator walked over and took the page, holding it by the edges like it was a relic.

"Can you read the entry for us?"

"March twelfth. Post-practice evaluation. Player reports dizziness, intermittent, third episode this month. Balance test abnormal. Recommended full neurological workup. Not cleared for contact." Tom cleared his throat. "Signed by the team trainer."

"And the digital record for that same date?"

"Says player reported fatigue, cleared for full participation." Tom looked up at the panel for the first time. "That's not a transcription error. That's a different sentence."

Megan heard Vasquez exhale slowly beside her. She didn't move. She was afraid if she moved she would cry, and she had told herself she was not going to cry in this room.

The questioning went on for another forty minutes. Tom described a second request in April, a third in June. He described an email from the club's general counsel that he'd also kept, printed and folded into his wallet. He described a meeting where he was told his position would be "reviewed" if he was uncooperative, and how he had gone home that night and told his wife he thought he was going to be fired, and how she had told him to keep the paper anyway.

"You've been with the club nineteen years," the investigator said. "You understood this could end your career."

"Yes."

"Why keep it?"

Tom took a long time to answer. When he did, his voice was rougher than before.

"Because I've had four guys in this organization retire early because somebody told them they were fine." He looked at the panel. "One of them can't drive at night anymore. I'm not saying that's anybody's fault. I'm saying I got tired of watching it and writing it down and then being asked to go get the page."

The panel chair, a gray-haired surgeon from the league's medical committee, leaned forward. "Mr. Kirby, do you have anything you'd like to add?"

"No, sir. That's all of it." Tom stood, and then stopped. "Actually. One thing."

"Go ahead."

"Nobody asked Luke Dawson what he wanted. That's the part that bothers me." Tom put his folder under his arm. "He's a grown man. It's his head. Nobody asked him."

He walked out. The door closed behind him with a soft click, and Megan finally let herself look at Vasquez, who was writing on a legal pad and did not look up.

The league announced the findings two days later. Not a verdict, exactly, because the disciplinary process would grind on for months behind closed doors. But the medical committee issued orders, effective immediately: an outside physician to approve any return-to-play decision following a neurological event, no exceptions. Independent audit of all paper and digital records going back three seasons. Mandatory anonymous reporting line for trainers and equipment staff. A suspension, pending further review, for the team physician.

Megan read the release on her phone in the clinic's break room, standing up, coffee going cold in her hand. Twelve lines. It shouldn't have felt like anything. It felt like standing outside after a long winter.

Her phone buzzed. Luke.

*Did you see*

*I saw,* she typed. *How are you?*

A long pause. Then: *Hallway. I'm in the hallway.*

She typed *call me* and he called inside three seconds.

"I'm in the basement," he said. His voice had a scrape in it. "I don't know. I came down here to get away from the kids for a minute and then I just — " He stopped. "They asked me, Meg."

"What?"

"After the first baseline. Someone asked me. It was Halloway's assistant, she said the trainer thought I should take a week, and I said no, because it was March and we were two points out." He breathed out. "I said no. So it turns out it wasn't only them."

"Luke."

"I'm not saying it's the same. It's not the same." His voice cracked and steadied. "But Tom said nobody asked me. And he's wrong. Somebody did ask me. I said no. And then I let everybody tell a story about it for two years where I didn't have a say."

Megan leaned against the counter and looked at the break room wall, at the water stain shaped like Wisconsin. "That's what you do when you're twenty-nine and you can still see the Cup," she said. "You're allowed to have made that call."

"That's not the thing." He was quiet. "The reassessment starts Monday. Six weeks. Same window as the coaching contract." A pause. "If they clear me, I have to decide whether to play again. And I have to decide it as a person who says yes to things when he shouldn't."

Megan closed her eyes. "Or as a person who says no when he shouldn't."

"Yeah," he said. "That's the one I've never tried."

She heard a door open behind him on his end, a kid's voice shouting his name, and Luke laughed, low and surprised, the way he did whenever he forgot for a second that he had a job he liked.

"I have to go," he said. "Practice."

"Go."

"Hey. The new rules." She heard him breathe. "That paper Tom laminated. You realize what that means for March."

She did. She'd realized it in the hearing room, watching the investigator hold that page by its edges. The club's own records were now going to be audited, and everything in them was fair game, and there was a copied tablet note with her name and her timestamp sitting somewhere that the league could find it whether or not she disclosed it first.

"Monday," she said. "I'll come with you to see Vasquez."

"Yeah," Luke said. "Monday."

The line went quiet, but he didn't hang up, and neither did she, and in the background a whistle blew on the youth rink ice.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 52: The Manager's Testimony · Breaking the Ice · Lumen Reads