The hearing was in a conference room on the fourth floor of the Daley Center, not a courtroom, and that disappointed Ethan more than Megan expected. He'd wanted a gavel. He'd wanted a judge in a robe with a bad temper, someone who banged things.
Instead there was a hearing officer named Doreen Whitlock, sixtyish, reading glasses on a beaded chain, and a court reporter with a steno machine, and eleven minutes of argument about a document Megan had signed in a room that smelled like Warren's carpet cleaner.
Alan Reyes sat beside her. He had asked to meet first, and she had said no. He had asked again, and she had said no again, and then he had shown up Thursday morning with coffee and a legal pad and the flat, humorless patience of a man who had already been yelled at this week by someone more important than her. "Just don't talk about the tablet until I say."
"I already told the league counsel about the tablet."
"Yes," Reyes had said, "which is half of why we're here."
Now Whitlock turned a page. "Counselor, take me to the clause that does the work."
Warren's attorney — a thin man named Fisk who kept touching his tie — read it aloud. The clause said that any dispute, claim, or disclosure arising from the care received at the office would be resolved by confidential binding arbitration, and that the patient waived all rights to discuss, describe, or characterize the care to any third party, in perpetuity.
"Perpetuity," Whitlock said.
"Yes, ma'am."
"For a woman who came in with a headache."
Fisk's ears went pink. "The clause is standard."
"Then it's standardly bad." She set the glasses down. "Counselor, I have read the record. This agreement was executed in early March, one day after Ms. Chen attempted to obtain her own treatment records and was refused. It was drafted to prevent her from describing data she had already independently generated and retained. The arbitration provision purports to strip a licensed professional of the ability to report a falsified medical record to a league, a board, or a police officer." She looked at Fisk. "Do you want me to keep going, or do you want to save us both the afternoon?"
Fisk tried anyway. He argued that Megan was not an ordinary patient, that she had financial motives, that she had already breached confidentiality in a public hearing. He said the word "leverage" four times.
Whitlock let him finish. Then she said, "This agreement is unenforceable as against public policy. All of it. Not severed. Nullified entirely." She signed the order in blue ink without further ceremony. "Ms. Chen is free to speak about anything that happened in that office, including the fact that this agreement existed. If Dr. Warren's counsel wishes to argue that this is a hardship, he may argue it to the disciplinary board that has already suspended his client's license."
It took forty seconds to clear the room. Then Megan was in the corridor with Reyes and her hands were shaking, which annoyed her, because she wasn't frightened. She was something else.
"Say it," Reyes said.
"Say what?"
"Whatever you're about to do. Say it to me first so it isn't a surprise."
She looked down the corridor at the vending machine and the man mopping near the elevators. "I'm doing the interview."
"Megan—"
"I gave you the tablet disclosure. I gave you Tom Kirby's name before the league had it. I signed on to the ethics committee on my own terms and I'll hold to those terms. But the NDA is dead as of"—she checked her phone—"eleven minutes ago, and I have been silent for six months on purpose, to protect my son and to protect an investigation, and both of those reasons are gone."
Reyes was quiet. Then he said, "Which outlet."
"Nayar. Chicago. Online and print."
"Priya Nayar has a quote from March where she calls you a hostile witness."
"Then she'll enjoy the follow-up."
He walked her to the elevator and didn't try again. At the doors he said, "For what it's worth, I'd have advised against signing that thing in the first place and I'd have billed you for the advice."
"I couldn't afford you in March."
"That's why I said for what it's worth."
Megan called Priya from the lobby. Priya picked up on the first ring, which was unusual, and said, "You got the ruling."
"How do you know about the ruling?"
"I have a stringer at the Daley Center who texts me when names he recognizes walk into rooms he wasn't invited to. Megan, I've had a question in my pocket since February."
"I know. You can ask it now."
Priya paused. "You're sure."
"I'm sure. But I'm bringing my son."
"Megan—"
"He's seven, he doesn't have to be there for the whole thing, but he has been told a partial version of this story twice now, by me, because I thought I was protecting him, and I'm done doing that. He can sit in the other room with a picture book and know his mother isn't hiding anything."
Priya was quiet for a second. "Okay. Tomorrow, ten, the diner on Lincoln where you take him for pancakes. The one with the bad pie case."
"Meet me at eleven. He's slow with pancakes."
They didn't fit at Priya's table in the diner, so they took the booth by the window, and Priya ordered coffee she didn't drink and set her recorder in the middle of the table, and Ethan sat in the booth behind them with a book about a hockey-playing bear and a plate of strawberry pancakes he had been promised he could leave at any time.
Priya started with the boring questions, the ones on the record, the ones about dates and documents and which office and who said what. Megan answered them flat. She had rehearsed nothing, but six months of not talking had made her precise in a different way.
Then Priya said, "For the record: you signed a nondisclosure agreement in March, at Dr. Warren's office, to remain silent about a medical record that you believed—and a lab has since confirmed—was deliberately altered to keep a player off the ice."
"Yes."
"Why did you sign it."
"Because I'm a single mother with a seven-year-old and a mortgage and no lawyer on retainer, and a man with a legal department told me it would end my career if I didn't." Megan turned her cup a quarter turn. "That's not a dramatic answer. That's just what it is."
"Do you think it would have ended your career?"
"I think he believed that, which is the same thing."
Priya's pen stopped. "What's the difference between what happened here and what happens at any club in any sport every season?"
Megan had thought about this one a lot, on the Kennedy at two in the morning, in the parking garage at the arena, at the sink washing a cup that was already clean. "The difference is that most of the time it works," she said. "Most of the time the player doesn't find out. Most of the time the record says week-to-week and the player does the rehab and the team says we're being careful and everyone agrees to call it patience, and the player's contract runs out or doesn't get renewed or gets traded for a fourth-round pick, and he never knows he was being held out because a doctor with a spreadsheet decided he was worth more as an asset than as a player." She looked up. "I know it works, because I sat in that room for eleven years and never asked. I didn't ask until it was someone I cared about."
"About that." Priya's voice had changed. Softer, or maybe not softer, maybe just lower. "You and Luke Halloran. It's my job to ask whether your professional judgment was affected."
"It was."
Priya blinked.
"It was affected the whole time," Megan said. "I was harder on him than on anyone I've ever treated, because I couldn't afford to be wrong in either direction, and I knew I'd get it wrong if I flattered him. You can print that. It's the most honest thing I've said all morning."
Priya wrote it down.
Behind her, Ethan turned a page and said, mostly to himself, "The bear scores."
Afterward, on the sidewalk, Priya put her recorder in her bag and stood there a moment. "The story runs Sunday. It'll go wide. The union's going to have to say something, and the league audit's going to have names in it before the season's out."
"Then I'll be here for it."
"There's one more thing. There's a woman named Colleen Ruiz. She was a trainer with the Thunderbirds from '21 to '23. She's been trying to get someone to look at her exit file for two years and nobody would call her back."
Megan took her number.
She walked back to the car with Ethan holding the pancake box he didn't finish, his hand small and sticky in hers. He said, "Are you in trouble?"
"No."
"Are you sad?"
"No." She unlocked the door and buckled him in and stood there a second with her hand on the roof, in the cold, looking down the street at nothing in particular. Then she said it out loud, to him or to the car or to the city, it didn't matter which.
"No more secrets."